Correspondence with Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi

The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 8

If, however, you have any doubt or misgiving, you can, as always, come to my humble abode at any time.

You will be treated just as you have been treated before, and God willing, I shall try to satisfy you.

And if you are inviting my humble self to visit you so that you may show me some heavenly Sign, then to come for this purpose would not only be of no benefit but would, in fact, be a sin and cause for harm. A believer can never hope for a Sign from a person whose beliefs contradict Islam and the former faiths. And even if he were to show something through his trickery, jugglery, or mesmerism, etc., it would be against Islam to put any faith in it. You, too, have admitted this in your own announcement.

Of course, my going there would not only be permissible but spiritually meritorious if upon arriving there I were to make manifest to the people that you are incapable of showing any heavenly Sign and expose your falsehood and deception to the Muslims, for I believe you have nothing to do with mesmerism etc. and the weapon and device for deception that you possess is simply your clever speech and eloquence. However, if I were to go to Qadian for such purpose, I fear that you would try to end my life, thereby bringing about the fulfilment of your revelation that this person would die upon reaching the age of 52 years, which your disciples and friends, Miyan Chattu, the silk dealer, and Miyan Rajab-ud-Din, the rice thresher of Lahore, etc. are circulating among themselves. (Although in reality this could never be proven true, for I have already completed the age of 52; 17th of Muharram 1256 Hijri is my birthday, and now it is the year 1310 Hijri). Or you will at least plan to try to disgrace me. If, therefore, you wish to invite me to come to you keeping in mind this objective of mine, you should first remove this fear of mine by executing a written legal document which should be registered in court.

I shall send to you the draft of this document if you signify your agreement to bear this responsibility. Only then shall this humble one come to Qadian and perform the same service regarding you while residing there that I am performing here. If, however, you do not agree to the above condition, I cannot come to Qadian.

I was surprized at you asking for my permission to publish your and your followers’ revelations and dreams about me and I became convinced from this that you are a great liar in your claim of being a recipient of revelation. Why would permission to publicize and convey a Divine revelation be needed at all?

In the first place, the revelation that is received by a Prophet or a saint by way of a warning for some person must necessarily be published and conveyed as this is precisely the requirement of that revelation. But if the one bestowing revelations upon you sends you such revelations with a stipulation not to publish until they are reviewed and reconfirmed by someone else, why do you not ask your bestower of revelations whether or not to publish this particular revelation, and whether, if you publish them, you would not be entangled in some legal complication.

It seems to me that, by asking such permission, you simply wish to abuse me and plan to write and publish such words as might defame me and hurt and cause grief to me and my relatives. You have published such revelations regarding me before, and, at the same time, you also fear the law and consider the Government to be more powerful than the one who is bestowing revelations upon you. I cannot, therefore, allow you to publish such revelations in general. Nevertheless, I cannot withhold permission for the publication of revelations that you and your followers received to the extent that the law permits. And thus, considering the one who bestows revelation upon you to be weak and cowardly (who is certainly not God Almighty, but is Satan) and whom you consider being overpowered by the Government, you must limit your obedience to this bestower of revelation to remain within the law of the Government. If you act otherwise, you will be summoned to a court and then may have to visit some other resting place. I am also considering your past revelations, and I have not given up my intention of seeking redress regarding them.

I also do not think it improper to state that if you are gifted with communion with God and can ask God Almighty regarding the details of things needing explanation, and if, with all that, you have (as you claim in your letter) sympathy for mankind, then you should, instead of threatening and warning me, first make an enquiry regarding me from God Almighty; namely, whether the warning revelation you have received regarding me is irrevocable and bound to occur, or whether its occurrence is conditional, and the fear or punishment that is mentioned in it can be lifted from the person in the situation that he submits to it.

Thus, if God Almighty informs you that it is not irrevocable but that it is contingent, you should pray to God that He may enable me to recognize you and make me submissive to you, and that He may ward off that punishment from me. You should, in this regard, cause the sea of your abundant mercy to swell and act upon the example of that merciful Prophet s (as) whose blood was shed by his own people and who, while he wiped off blood from his face said, اللّٰھم اغفر لقومی فانّھم ال یعلمون—[‘O our Allah! Forgive my people, for they do not know’]. You should moreover act upon this example of the Holy Prophet s (as), that when the ‘Angel of the Mountains’ came to him and said, ‘I have been sent by God Almighty to crush your rejecters and

whose hearts are not dominated by crookedness and perverseness. Otherwise, such a person, in accordance with the verse

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[61:6] deprived of true guidance. Author opponents under the mountain if you so wish,’ he replied that he did not desire this and that he entertained the hope that such people would come into being among their descendants who would proclaim the Oneness of God. If, however, God Almighty informs you that this revelation is irrevocable and bound to occur, then you should discharge your obligation, and prove your claim to Prophethood and Sainthood to your followers by reciting that revelation before them. Preaching to me in this case would be useless, for no Prophet ever persisted in preaching after receiving the promise of inevitable punishment.

If, however, you persist in thus threatening me, then the seekers after truth and the just people will come to know that your preaching and warnings are fraudulent and false.

In conclusion, I also wish to inform you that if I am well-intentioned and in the right in opposing you, and am supporting the Faith of Islam, and my ego has no part in the affair, then God Almighty will help me and by guiding you will make you submit to the truth and the Faith of Islam, or He will destroy you by involving you in a severe punishment. But if my intentions are mischievous, God will Himself punish me for it. Your warning and threatening me is vain and pointless, especially because I consider you to be a great liar, and I consider this belief to be part and parcel of Islam. It is better, therefore, for you to abandon this bluster and bravado and become submissive to the truth. It is up to you now as how to behave in the future.

I can do no more than to clearly convey these things.

The Writer, Abu Sa‘id Muhammad Husain, may Allah have mercy on him.

The above letter was read out at a public meeting of the Muslims. Important persons present at the meeting approved of its contents and affixed their signatures thereupon. Some of the names are the following:

·

10 of 10 left today