Correspondence with Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 7
From this everyone can understand that a man who has the audacity to lie about his fellow man and to deceive them will not hesitate to fabricate lies about God, claiming that he is a recipient of Divine revelation, that it has been revealed to him that if a particular person does not give his daughter in marriage to him, that person would die , and that if such and such man does not accept him as the Messiah that man would incur [Divine] punishment. And thus, how can this claim of Divine revelation be considered truthful?
You are a claimant to the truth of three thousand such revelations of yours. I will accept you as a Mulham [recipient of Divine revelation] if only three from among these three thousand revelations are proven to be true, and I will, in that case, acknowledge that I made a mistake in regarding your beliefs and your teachings as being contrary to the truth, and you as being immoral and misguided. You may choose from these three thousand whichever three you consider to be manifestly true. The revelation concerning the death of Dayanand Sarsawati, for example, or the revelation regarding the release of Shaikh Mehr Ali, or the revelation about Dalip Singh returning unsuccessfully, or the revelation about the death of your supposed future father-in-law, and other examples like these. You may prove the truth of these [three revelations] and attain success easily in a gathering in which there should be present an equal number of persons from each side and three judges belonging to different faiths or who are free thinkers.
Leave aside three, let us take only one supposed revelation if Mirza Ahmad Baig of Hoshiarpur did not give his daughter in marriage, he would die within a period of three years from the date of the nikah [Islamic marriage]. Thus, Mirza Ahmad Baig did not marry his elder daughter to anybody for five years after becoming aware of this revelation and thus continued to live. After five years he gave her in marriage to a certain man, and in the sixth month after marriage, within the term of the prophecy he died. If this is a man-made affair, I adjure Batalawi to give an example of such a prophecy the truth of which had been manifested by God Almighty, or he might himself make such a prophecy. Otherwise, he should fear the curse which descends swiftly on the enemies of truth, like a rock falling downhill from the peak of a mountain. Author of yours—the last one—which you mentioned with so much enthusiasm at your Jalsa, the annual fair, to your followers and to those who are caught in your net, mostly illiterate common people, some selfish rationalists, and some mere spectators who had no interest in finding out the truth about you. You may prove that it was indeed a revelation.
Now, if you are a brave man, come into the battlefield; otherwise, be ashamed of such tall talk. You have spoken of your sea of ‘abundant mercy’, swelling and becoming agitated, there too, you have adopted your age-old habits of lies and deception. What do you have to do with mercy? Sympathy and kindness are entirely lacking in you. Your actions, behaviour, and words clearly bear witness that you are an extremely cruel and selfish, sinning and conceited man. Your tongue and the sword of Hajjaj bin Yusuf are twins.
You have called your opponents and objectors—whom you used to address as ‘my revered sirs or brothers’ and whose honesty of purpose you had acknowledged—by names such as ‘shameless,’ ‘faithless’, ‘savage animals’, ‘mad with rage’, ‘dog’, ‘a dog who will die on the numerical value of dog [52]’, ‘mean’, ‘petty’, and ‘barbarous’, etc., etc. Is this indeed the meaning of mercy and human sympathy?
You have misappropriated more than 10,000 rupees from the Muslims by way of payment for the book Barahine-Ahmadiyya and by tempting them with promises of acceptance of prayers while the book Barahin is still in your brain, and those who had put faith in your prayers are still looking up expectantly towards you. Is this indeed what is called sympathy and kindness?
When I had a good opinion of you, believing that you might possibly be a saint, I repeatedly requested you to let me stay with you and show me the Signs of [Divine] mercy and blessings. You never replied in the affirmative. Once, I had even said to you that your opponents and rejecters were more fortunate in that you invited them to witness heavenly Signs, promising them rewards of money, but you did not invite us—your friends—even without any promise of rewards; whereupon you smiled and became quiet.
Then, when you made the claim to being the Promised Messiah I, having manifested my opposition, expressed a desire to come to you for a private friendly conversation but after coming close to promising to invite, you went away to Ludhiana to sit there majestically and having set up the arena for controversy took refuge behind unfair conditions designed to avoid discussions. Then, when I compelled you, by going to Ludhiana and arriving at your house to hold a conversation, you interrupted this peaceful conversation and tried again to prepare the arena for a controversy, unfurling the banner of controversial debates in Delhi, Patiala, Lahore, Sialkot, etc.
Thereafter, avoiding actual discussion, you issued an announcement containing all manner of allegations and lies. In the meantime, you wrote Asmani Faisalah [The Heavenly Verdict] sparing neither unkindness nor abuse in the least. This unkindness and conceit resulted in dissension among the Muslims community—brother leaving brother and friend leaving friend. Is this indeed the outcome of mercy and sympathy?
If there had been even a trace of mercy or sympathy in you, you should have immediately invited me to your place when I had manifested opposition to your claim to be the Messiah, or else you should have taken the trouble of coming to my humble abode (as it had been your practice before and you had taken the trouble of coming to my humble abode at least three times and expressed your sentiments of solidarity) and, in this manner, you could have had the opportunity to prove your new claim. Now, this letter that you have sent, is also not free from your selfishness and intent of creating mischief. It is selfish because it is intended to make your followers think that you are well-intentioned and steadfastly established upon your claim, and ready to face your opponents. The intention to create mischief consists in wishing the other party to issue point-by-point rebuttals, thereby helping create dissension among the Muslims of Batala. The above is a rejoinder to your claims of revelation, righteousness, well-wishing, and mercy.
Now I proceed to reply to your request that: ‘My humble self should come to you and submit to you fearing the revelations and dreams of yourself and your followers or that I should allow you to publish those revelations and dreams consisting of warnings.’
If you are inviting my humble self to visit you for the purpose that I should make enquiries from you regarding your false beliefs, then from this point of view my coming is useless. We Muslims now have no doubts concerning the falsity of your erroneous beliefs. Therefore, there remains absolutely no need or requirement to make any enquiry.