Correspondence with Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan

The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam

Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan

Honoured and Esteemed Spiritual Healer—may Allah protect you!

Assalamu ‘alaikum [Peace be upon you]. My indisposition prevented me from sending a reply. Allah be praised, I am well now, and I trust that you are also in good health. The money has been sent through Mirza Khuda Bakhsh. I hope that Mirza Sahib would have informed you fully about everything.

Ever since the publication of your claim of being the ‘like of the Messiah’, everyone is in a strange state of agitation. There may be some special people who have not experienced any doubt, but I have been in a state of vacillation ever since. At times your claim appears to be correct, while at other times, there is a state of perplexity, so my condition is as if I am vacillating between rejection and acceptance. Much dialogue has now taken place, but my mind finds no satisfaction through it. After listening to the pros and cons, the condition of my mind is indescribable. Rather, I sometimes begin to doubt even the truth of Islam. The reason is that while, on the one hand, God Almighty promises in the Holy Qur’an that He would show

His way to those who strive in His way, but on the other, it is surprising that the promise remains unfulfilled. They may not have performed Istikharah , but hundreds of people are striving with the utmost sincerity to find the straight path and to clearly see the truth.

The following seem to be the issues that will reveal the truth.

First: There is no excuse left now as to why the opponents should not be challenged to a mubahalah [prayer duel] because as you have stated in reply to Maulawi ‘Abdul-Haqq, a mubahalah is not permissible until a discussion is held first, and a demand for a mubahalah is made therein, because the difference has to do with a matter of interpretation. This is no longer the case. Opposition has intensified, and arguments have been thoroughly established. You should now challenge the opponents to a mubahalah, and, with complete concentration, seek Divine permission for it. The mubahalah should bring out a result in the near future within a period of not more than two months, for people become weary of a long period of waiting. If it is said that the deniers will continue to deny even after seeing the result of the mubahalah, I would beg to state that the deniers may not believe, but those who are in a state of wavering would certainly come to believe. And a very great benefit would be that those who have already taken the Pledge of Allegiance will have their faith strengthened. In any case, a challenge to mubahalah now seems essential.

Second: In Nishan-e-Asmani [The Heavenly Sign] you have stated that the Istikharah should be free from sentiments of hostility or love; because, otherwise, Satan interferes, and one’s own thoughts determine the inspiration. Hence, it should be performed with perfect detachment from both of these matters. Now, this situation presents a great difficulty. Firstly, the person [doing Istikharah] would either be an opponent or a friend. Thus, according to this statement, friends will have an inspiration of a friendly character, while opponents will receive a hostile response. Hence, the result would rest entirely on one’s own thought process. Secondly, man is apt to incline towards that which he is asked to refrain from. Therefore, if you had not mentioned it, no one would have thought about it, but because you have mentioned it, some thoughts of one’s imagination will play a part in the Istikharah. Thirdly, the Istikharah is really meant for the opponents, and, when an opponent, because of innate hostility, gets an inspiration hostile to you, how will the argument be brought home to him? In every case, therefore, there is the possibility of the intrusion by Satan. These three difficulties stand in the way of the Istikharah being carried out, because in every case there is the possibility of Satan’s inspiration. Moreover, it is difficult to free oneself from sentiments of love or hostility, which creates a helpless predicament.

Therefore, for God’s sake, also pray that the Istikharah should be free from Satan’s inspiration that everyone who offers Istikharah—whether friend or foe—should have the real truth disclosed to them, and that the interference of Satan may be eliminated from it. As the matter is important, it is essential that we pray to God against the interference of Satan. It is strange that Satan should dominate an affair which is essentially spiritual and divine. If God Almighty does not help us and does not save us from the inspiration of Satan, how shall we be able to find true guidance? Thus, nothing can happen without the support of the Gracious God. Therefore, I beseech you to pray that Satan may have nothing to do with the Istikharah.

Let a public announcement be issued in connection with this matter; pray concentrate your spiritual powers and obtain Divine permission within 10 or 15 days. I too am ready for Istikharah; I shall perform it when, in respect of these three things, you have had a Divine inspiration that this Istikharah will be free from Satan’s interference and that, whether a friend or a foe performs it, the outcome in all cases would be the same. I shall perform the Istikharah, and I shall wait for a month for a good and proper reply. By reply, I do not mean a reply to the letter of my humble self but rather, what guidance you receive about Istikharah after you have prayed and concentrated your attention on this affair.

Third: There should be some extraordinary Sign so that truth may be brought home to the people.

I most respectfully beg, in the name of God, to give your attention to these three matters, for much dialogue has already taken place, and doubts are increasing day by day. The stage of argumentation is over, and we should now attend to the other side.

The legs of logicians are legs of wood—

And wooden legs are exceedingly weak.

If Faith had rested on argumentation alone,

Fakhr[-ud-Din] Razi would have found the secret of Faith.

And I adjure you most humbly, in the name of that One Supreme Being, who has brought you and me into being and who has created the whole universe, to kindly pray with concentration for all three of these matters mentioned above. In the prayer, please also beseech for a short span of time and not a longer term [in which the matter should be settled].

As the relation between the parties is delicate and the affair is of a spiritual character, please do not think that this letter of mine is impertinent, rather consider it as a request for beneficence. As I am pledged to you by Bai‘at, I have given you this trouble for my own peace of mind.

One more issue comes to mind. Writings have now lost all credence. Those who believe in you will trust your writing, and the opponents will trust the writings of the opponents. Caught in between are those who wish to decide after due consideration of writings of both sides. These people do not trust either side, for they have no special connection with you nor the opponents. They will always be faced with a trial.

Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan]

Please read this letter carefully at least three times. Although this letter is addressed to you, many of its contents are meant to dispel the misgivings of others, even though you are the apparent addressee.

My dear brother Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan, may Allah protect you!

10 of 10 left today