Correspondence with Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 2
As-salamu ‘alaikum wa Rahmatullahe wa Barakatuhu [Peace be upon you, and the mercy of Allah and His blessings]. More than a week ago—rather, more than ten days ago—I received the affectionate letter from your dear self. As it contained several matters calling for a detailed response, and as I had very little time due to the compilation of the book A’ina-e- Kamalat-e-Islam—for which I am preparing my manuscripts daily—I was not able to write a response, nor were you pressing for a quick reply. Today it occurred to me that since you are a special loved one and your enquiries are based entirely upon sincere intentions and honesty of purpose, it is necessary that I should inform you of certain matters and apprise you of what is good for you. Therefore, I write these few lines below for your information.
It is true that ever since this humble one made the claim to being the Promised Messiah by the command of Allah the Exalted, those people who lack a decision-making ability have been flung into an extraordinary confusion and perplexity. You also say that verbal arguments will not now help in reaching a decision; that it is now time to get ready for a mubahalah. You also say that some Sign should be shown.
1. Regarding the mubahalah, Allah, glorified be His eminence, granted me His permission on His own a few days before your letter came. I consider this to be an agreement of your view with the will of God Almighty that you were moved to make such a proposal.
It seems to me that the wisdom in permitting the mubahalah now is that a mubahalah was not permissible earlier because the opponents had not yet been fully educated and were totally ignorant of the real situation. Moreover, they were not as vehement in declaring me to be a kafir as they have been more recently. But now, after the compilation of A’ina-e-Kamalate-Islam, the message has been fully conveyed, and after seeing this book, even a man of low understanding can realize that the opponents are absolutely wrong in their views. Therefore, I have been commanded to publish the request for the mubahalah together with the book A’ina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam. That request will, therefore, be published, if Allah the All-Powerful so wills, with the first part of the book.
Formerly, I was not sure whether a mubahalah with the Muslims was at all permissible, because mubahalah means pronouncing a curse against each other, and it is not lawful to curse a Muslim. However, these people now insist on declaring me a kafir [disbeliever], and the commandment of the Shariah is that whoever accuses a Muslim of being a kafir, when that Muslim is not really a kafir, the pronouncement of disbelief reverts to the accuser himself. This is why I have been commanded to invite those to a mubahalah who call me a kafir, have sons and female relations, and who are the leaders of the edict of disbelief.
2. What you write about the need for a Sign is also correct. In actual fact, there are two categories of people: those who are intelligent and virtuous and possess the quality of deciding for themselves. They can distinguish the speech which possesses the grandeur, the grace, and the light of truth, from the disputations of the opposing parties. Falsehood, which reeks of pretence and artificiality, also does not remain hidden from their view. Such people do not stand in need, for instance, of being shown the staff turning into a serpent in order to recognize Hadrat Musa [Moses], peace be upon him, nor is it necessary that they be shown lepers and paralytics being made whole and cured by the touch of Hadrat ‘Isa [Jesus], peace be upon him, in order for them to recognize him. Similarly, in the time of our Lord and Master, Hadrat Khatamul-Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets], may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, such illustrious people never asked for a miracle. No one can prove that the great Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, came to believe in him after witnessing some Sign. On the contrary, they were virtuous and possessed enlightened hearts. They came to recognize him by merely casting a glance upon the face of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as his was not the face of an impostor. Therefore, they were deemed to be the truthful and faithful in the eyes of God Almighty; they saw the truth and their hearts bore witness that he was from Allah.
The second kind of people are those who demand a miracle and a marvel. God Almighty does not speak of them in the Noble Qur’an in praiseworthy terms; He holds them liable to punishment, as in one place, He says:
Meaning: These people emphatically swear that if they see some Sign they would certainly come to believe. Tell them, the Signs are with God Almighty. And you do not know that they would never come to believe even if they were to see the Signs. Again, He says:
Meaning: It would not be of any benefit to come to believe on the day when the Signs will be shown, and the one who comes to believe only after seeing a Sign, would not benefit from that belief.
Again, He says:
Meaning: The disbelievers say, ‘When will the Signs appear and when will the promise be fulfilled?’ So, tell them that I have no power in this matter, neither for good nor for evil for my own self, except as God wills. There is an appointed time for every people which can never be averted.
Letter to Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan 383
And then again, God says to His Messengers (as):
Meaning: If (O Messenger, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) the aversion of these disbelievers bears heavy on you, you might, if you have the power, dig a passage into the earth, or scale the very heavens with a ladder, and bring forth some Sign for them. Had God so willed, He would have guided all those who ask for a Sign. Therefore, be not of the ignorant people.
Now, all these verses show that in the time of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, the disbelievers used to demand Signs. Indeed, they would even swear oaths that they would come to believe; but, in the eyes of Allah, glorified be His eminence, they merited punishment, and their demands were absurd. Indeed, Allah, His eminence be glorified, says very clearly that the faith of someone who comes to believe after seeing a Sign is not acceptable [to God]. The verse: