Chapter 2: The Preaching of Islam: Two Conflicting Views

Murder in the Name of Allah

THE PREACHING OF ISLAM: TWO CONFLICTING VIEWS

1 When every method of persuasion (over 13 years of preaching) had failed, the Prophet* took to the sword . .. that sword removed evil and mischief, the impurities of the heart and the filth of the soul. The sword did something more. It removed their blindness - they could see the light of truth - and it also cured them of their arrogance; arrogance which prevents people from accepting the truth ... stiff necks and proud heads bowed with humility.

Maulana Abul Ala Maududi

Muhammad preached Islam with a sword in one hand and the Holy Qur’an in the other. Prof. Wilfred Cantwell Smith

2 The critics are blind. They cannot see that the only sword Muhammad wielded was the sword of mercy, compassion, friendship and forgiveness - the sword that conquers enemies and purifies hearts. His sword was sharper than the sword of steel.

Gyanandra Dev Sharma Shastri

These are two conflicting views about the way in which the message of Islam was conveyed to the world. Critics, especially ovientalists, claim that the wars the Prophet of Islam* fought were offensive wars and that people were converted by force. According to objective historians, however, this view is not upheld by the facts. The Prophet did not use force to preach and all the battles he fought were defensive. The expansion of Islam was due to the Prophet’s® spiritual and moral power. Nevertheless, the view that Islam was spread by force is, unfortu- nately, held by some Muslim leaders. They, like the orientalists, divide the life of the Prophet® into Meccan and Medinite periods. They maintain

The Preaching of Islam

that at Mecca he was weak and powerless, hence that compromising and submissive attitude of peaceful co-existence. Then, having gained some power at Medina, he resorted to the sword, according to this school of thought.

Had he not done so there would have been no spiritual revolution in Arabia and Islam would not have spread. The late Maulana Abul Ala Maududi! was a leading proponant of this view. In his book. Al-Jihad fil Islam, the Maulana says:

The Messenger of Allah® invited the Arabs to accept Islam for 13 years.

He used every possible means of persuasion, gave them incontrovertible

arguments and proofs, showed them miracles and put before them his life

as an example of piety and morality. In short, he used every possible

means of communication, but his people refused to accept Islam.

It grieves my heart to quote the rest of this passage but it needs to be set out.

When every method of persuasion had failed, the Prophet* took to the

sword.

That sword removed evil mischief, the impurities of evil and the filth of the soul. The sword did something more - it removed their blindness so that they could see the light of truth, and also cured them of their arrogance; arrogance which prevents people from accepting the truth, stiff necks and proud heads bowed with humility.

Asin Arabia and other countries, Islam’s expansion was so fast that within a century a quarter of the world accepted it. This conversion took place because the sword of Islam tore away the veils which had covered men’s hearts.”

The above statement is doubly unfortunate because it was made by a Muslim scholar who claimed to be mizaj-shanasi-Rasul, the one who found himself in complete harmony with the mind and heart of the Prophet®, so much so that he acquires a measure of authority in explain- ing the true meanings of the words and deeds of the Prophet - aclaim which, if accepted, would give the claimant as much or more right to represent than the Holy Prophet* enjoyed vis-a-vis his understanding of the Word of God. This means that the Maulana’s understanding is tragic beyond words - it has been made by a Muslim leader and repeats a baseless assertion of Islam’s enemies. It is the biased orientalists who accused the Prophet of converting people by force. The Maulana’s phraseology appears to glorify Islam, but in reality it endorses the accusation of the European critics of Islam. R. Dozy said: ‘Muhammad’s generals preached Islam with a sword in one hand and the Holy Qur’an in the other.’ Smith asserted that it was not the generals but the Prophet* himself who ‘preached with a sword in one hand and the Holy Qur’an in the other’. George Sale wrote: “When the followers of the Prophet increased in number he claimed that God had allowed him to attack the unbelievers so that idolatry be destroyed and true religion be established.’

The Revd Dr C. G. Pfander, who was actively engaged in missionary work among Indian Muslims during the latter part of the nineteenth century, provoked great unrest by writing controversial tracts to expose, as he put it, ‘The false Prophet of Islam’. In one such tract he said:

1. For 13 years Muhammad preached his new religion in conciliatory

terms and with great patience.

2. Now (in Medina) he became Al-Nabiyyu bis-Saif , ‘The sword-

wielding Prophet’, and since then Islam’s strongest argument has been

the sword.

3. If we study the behaviour of Muhammad’s* followers we notice that they thought it was not necessary for them to follow a religious and moral code. God demanded from them only’one thing: that they should fight for God with swords, arrows, daggers and sabres to continue to kill?

And after this introduction the Revd Dr Pfander concluded: “You have to choose between Jesus, Word of God, and Hazrat Muhammad, son of Abdullah; between one who devoted his life to acts of piety and one who dedicated his life to the sword.”

Aloy Spranger, Henry Copey and many other critics of Islam fol- lowed the same line of attack on both Islam and the Prophet*. Washing- ton Irving went a step further, printed on the title page of one of his books is an imaginary painting of the Prophet* with a sword in one hand and the Holy Qur’an in the other.*

10 von 10 heute frei