Chapter 2: The Preaching of Islam: Two Conflicting Views
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 2
If one compares all that has been quoted above with the opening quotation of Maulana Maududi’s Al-Jihad fil Islam, one finds the Prophet’s* critics in agreement. Both the Maulana and the orientalists maintained that Islam had a violent nature. Yet, despite this belief, the Maulana believed in Islam while they rejected it. Apart from the wording, there is no difference between paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the quotation from Dr Pfander above and the quotation from Maulana Maududi above. But one shows the respect of a Muslim; the other, the sarcasm of a bitter critic.
The snide remarks of the orientalists about the Prophet of Islam® are as unsurprising as they are hurtful. They are sometimes made out of ignorance, but mostly out of malice. The hostility towards Islam
The Preaching of Islam
colours the objectivity of even the most balanced historian. But most hurtful of all are the writings of Muslims who claim devoutly to follow the Prophet®, yet present him, either through ignorance or arrogance, as a barbarian who wielded the sword to convert and conquer.
Maulana Maududi was not convinced of the inherent beauty of Islam or that it could conquer hearts by its spiritual force alone, either in the past or present. He said:
Human relations and associations are so integrated that no state can have
complete freedom of action within its own principles, unless those same
principles are in force in a neighbouring country. Therefore, Muslim groups will not be content with the establishment of an Islamic state in one area alone. Depending on their resources, they should try to expand
in all directions. On one hand, they will spread their ideology and on the
other they will invite people of all nations to accept their creed, for
salvation lies only in it. [f their Islamic state has power and resources it will fight and destroy non-Islamic governments and establish Islamic states in their place.®
Maulana Maududi supports Sir William Muir’s twisted views of the Prophet® and of Islam. In his biography of the Prophet®, which he wrote to expose ‘the false Prophet of Islam” at the request of Dr Pfander, Sir William Muir said: ‘The sword of Mahomet, and the Coran are the most fatal enemies of civilisation, liberty and truth which the world has yet known.”
The great Hindu leader, Gandhiji, in his earlier days, must have been influenced by a distorted picture of Islam such as this when he said: Islam was born in an atmosphere of violence. At that time its determin- ing force was the sword and even today it is the sword.’ But Gandhiji was an observer of great insight and subsequently he corrected himself and wrote in Young India: ‘The more I study the more I discover that the strength of Islam does not lie in the sword.’
Other Hindus - even Arya Samajists, who made an objective study of Islam - followed Gaadhiji in his ‘discovery’. Pandit Gyanandra Dev Sharma Shastri said:
Biased critics of Islam and especially those who want to provoke Hindu
- Muslim riots in the country say that Hazrat Muhammad after acquiring
power in Medina could not maintain his facade of mercy and kindness.
There he used force and violence and became a murderous prophet to
achieve his life-long aim of power, status and wealth. He fell short of his
own ideal of patience, moderation and endurance. But this is the view of those observers who are prejudicial and partisan, who are narrow-
minded and whose eyes are covered by a veil of ignorance.They see fire
instead of light, ugliness instead of beauty and evil instead of good.
They distort and present every good quality as a great vice. It reflects
their own depravity. . . .
The critics are blind. They cannot see that the only ‘sword’ Muham- mad wielded was the sword of mercy, compassion, friendship and forgiveness - the sword that conquers enemies and purifies their hearts. His sword was sharper than the sword of steel.’
No comment! One only wishes that Maulana Maududi, a follower of the Prophet Muhammad®, had been as fair to the Prophet® as a follower of Krishna® had been. Non-Muslims who have studied the history of Islam have had to admit that the Prophet® was not only magnanimous and kind, but also a paragon of human virtues. Another Hindu, the editor of the Sar Updaish, wrote: