Chapter 2: The Preaching of Islam: Two Conflicting Views

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3

Some people say that Islam was preached by the sword, but we cannot

agree with this view. What is forced on people is soon rejected. Had Islam

beenimposed on people through oppression, there would have been no

Islam today. Why? Because the Prophet of Islam had spiritual power, he

loved humanity and he was guided by the ideal of ultimate good.'°

The anti-Muslim stance of the Arya Samaj movement is well known. Its founder, Swami Dayanand, was highly critical of Islam and its Prophet* and yet the following statement was made by a Hindu at a meeting sponsored by the Arya Samaj in Lahore. The editor of the Vedic Magazine and a former professor of Gurukul, Kangri Ram Dev, said:

Sitting in Medina, Muhammad Sahib (peace be to him) held the Arabs

spelloound; he filled them with spiritual strength; strength that makes

devtas | gods] out of men... itis incorrect to say that Islam spread with

the force of the sword. It is a fact that the sword was never wielded to

propagate Islam. If religion can be spread by force then let anyone try it

today."

The last sentence of the above passage is a challenge no one would ever accept - not even Maulana Maududi. No sword can change a heart and turn belief into disbelief. There was a long chain of prophets before the Prophet of Islam*® and it is an historical truth that every prophet was opposed by force. Every time a prophet taught the true religion he was opposed by the sword and yet true religion spread and the sword failed to cut it back. If all past prophets and their followers could stand against the sword’s might, how is it possible that Muhammad could have adopted a different approach and taken to the sword - the instrument of

The Preaching of Islam

oppression, not truth? There is no greater injustice than to accuse him of using force to change people’s beliefs.

Another non-Muslim scholar, Dr D. W. Leitz, in rebutting this false charge, based his argument on the Holy Qur’an itself. He said:

All these arguments, advanced to prove that the purpose of jihad was to

spread Islam by force, are contradicted by the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an says that

the purpose of jihad is to protect mosques, churches, synagogues and cloisters.!?

After such a clear defence of the Prophet®, let so-called Muslims who accuse him of wielding the sword answer this question in the Holy Qur’an: ‘Do they not ponder over the Holy Qur’an, or is it that their hearts are locked up from within? (47.25) Maulana Maududi, the author of the voluminous com- mentary on the Holy Qur’an, Tafhim-ul-Quran, must have read this verse many times. Did it not occur to him that interpreting the Holy Qur’an for political purposes might lead the commentator astray? The Maulana then says:

This was the policy which was adopted by the Prophet* and his rightly

guided caliphs. Arabia, where the Muslim Party was first formed, was the

first to be subdued. After this, the Prophet’ sent invitations to all neighbouring countries, but did not wait to see whether these invita- tions were accepted. As soon as he acquired power, he started the conflict with the Roman Empire. Abu Bakr became the leader of the

Party after the Prophet and attacked both the Roman and Persian

Empires and Umar finally won the war.

This is virtually a declaration of war against all non-Muslim neigh- bouring states - they are safe only as long as the Muslim state is weak. Had the above passage been written by a Marxist historian from the Commu- nist Party, one would not have given it a second glance. But it is the considered opinion of a Muslim leader of Maulana Maududi’s stature. As such, it is certainly far more insulting to the Prophet® than all that Muir, Pfander, Smith and other critics of Islam have written. The above passage was translated from the Maulana’s original Urdu. The words: ‘Muslim Party’ were used deliberately by Maududi. He was degrading the Muslim umma to the status of a political party. He was well aware of the difference between the two words, for in another book he said: ‘The other word the Holy Qur’an has used for “party” is wmma.’'* Having dubbed Muslims a politcal party, the Maulana either subconsciously or. more likely, deliberately, equates the Prophet® with a political party leader, assigning to him the morals of a politician. How else can one explain the following passage written by the Maulana?

After this the Prophet sent invitations to all the neighbouring

countries, but he did not wait to see whether these invitations were

accepted or not. As soon as he acquired power he started the conflict with the Roman Empire.

It is amazing that a Muslim scholar could even by implication suggest that the Prophet was guilty of a Hitler-style invasion - Naaudhu billah.'5 The Prophet was the Prince of Peace, not an invader. Maulana Maududi loved political power and, unfortunately, this colours his interpretation of Islamic history. But Islam does not need politics to prop it up. In Bengal, now Bangladesh, Muslims were an infinitesimal minority in the middle of the eighteenth century when the British took over the administration from the Mughals. By the time Bengal became independent in 1947 it had a Muslim majority. Muslims had no political control of the area nor was there any migration of Muslims from northern India during British rule. This increase in Bengal’s Muslim .population was owing to peaceful conversion by travelling sufis, the roving Muslim missionaries and the Imams of the village mosques.

Thomas Arnold’s observation on the subject is significant. He said: ‘Islam has gained its greatest and most lasting missionary triumphs in times and places in which its political power has been weakest.’ Maulana Maududi probably never read the history of Islam in Bengal, Malaysia or Indonesia. He was so enthralled by the Turko-Afghan and Mughal conquests that he never had time to note that the largest Musiim country in the world, Indonesia, never had a Muslim conquerer - that there was no fighting nor any violence there. That was the case also in Malaysia.

The Prophet®* was obviously innocent. He took up the sword only in self-defence and only when oppression became unbearable. Here is what an objective Sikh has to say on the subject:

In the beginning the Prophet’s enemies made life difficult for him and his

followers. So the Prophet asked his followers to leave their homes and

migrate to Medina. He preferred migration to fighting his own people,

but when oppression went beyond the pale of tolerance he took up his

sword in self-defence. Those who believe religior can be spread by force

·

10 of 10 left today