Chapter 3: A Rebuttal of Maududian Philosophy

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3

This was the social background in which Muhammad* was brought up and these were the peuple whom God gave the first opportunity of embracing a persecuted prophet’s faith.

To suggest that these fierce and warlike people - who would sound the battle cry at the drop of a hat - could have been converted by force is to contradict history. Moreover, it demeans the faith of those pioneers who put their lives at stake to defend Is}am at the battle of Badr.

Usayd b. Hudayr, Sad b. Khaythamah, Asd b. Zurahah, Abdullah b. Rawahah, Sad b. Ubadah, Mundhirb. Amir, Bara b. Marur, Ubadahb. as-Sami, Rafi b. Malik and many other Helpers travelled all the way from Medina to Mecca to cmbrace Islam. Even to hint that the sword played a part in their conversion is also to deny historical fact.

While in Christian history it is religion which converts swords into ploughshares,? Maulana Maududi’s interpretation of Islamic history asks us to believe it is the sword which prepares the soil of the soul to receive religion’s seed.!° Was it the Holy Prophet’s* sword or a few verses of the Holy Qur’an which turned Umaz b. Khattab - aswornenemy of Islam - into Islam’s devoted servant?

In the early days of the Prophet’s* persecution, Umar, a headstrong young man of 26, decided to kill the Prophet®, thus wiping out the main cause of division among the Quraysh. On his way to the Prophet’s* house, he met Nuaim b. Abdullah, who sensed his evil intentions and said: ‘O Umar! Go back to the people of thy house! Thy sister, Fatima, and thy brother-in-law, Saeed, have embraced the religion of Muham- mad.’ And, without a single word, Umar went straight to his sister’s house, where a Companion, Khabbab, was reciting the opening verses of the Surah, Ta-Ha (XX). As soon as Umar went in, Khabbab hid in a comer and Fatima hid the pages of the Holy Qur’an in her clothing. But Umar had overheard Khabbab’s recital and attacked both Saeed and Fatima. When Fatima was covered in blood, he softened and asked to see the verses. He read them and exclaimed: ‘How beautiful and how noble these words are!’ And he went straight to Arqam’s house, where the Prophet* was sitting with his Companions. He cried out: ‘O Messenger of Allah! I have come to thee that I may declare my faith in Allah and His Messenger and in what he hath brought from Allah.”

Why is Maulana Maududi so determined to paint a violent picture of Islam? Why are there contradictions in his theory ofjihad? A glance at the Maulana’s background and the conditions under which he wrote his book, Al-Jihad fil Islam, can help us answer these questions.

Syed Abul Ala-Maududi spent his childhood and early youth in Hyderabad (Deccan) where the Nizam still ruled in the style of the great Mughal and where his Hindu prime minister sang the praises of the Holy

Prophet®."' At the crossroads, from north to south and east to west, it was the last stronghold of Mughal - predominantly Muslim - culture in India. In a state where the population was overwhelmingly Hindu (more than 80 per cent) and Muslims were a small minority (just 10 per cent), the ruler though without effective power, still recalled the past glory of Mughal rule. It was an unreal world. The court, with its Paigah nobility, chamberlains, household troops, brocade sherwanis, ceremonial dastar (turban), bugloos (buckle) and gorgeous jewellery, was a reminder of the Delhi Court before it was ravaged by Nadir Shah (1739). There were Arab mercenaries with gilded daggers and long muskets and the regular army with all the paraphernalia of modern warfare. The rajas and maharajahs - some of them reigning over areas larger than the Hindu states of British India - occupied the highest places of honour in the Nizam’s government and were part of a surreal picture of Muslim tolerance and Hindu loyalty.

Though the Hyderabadi culture was recognisably Indian based, it was largely Muslim in shape. ‘Social organisation was still feudal, but not in any sense primitive. It was highly cultivated with a grace of manner, and, above all, a tolerance and mutual respect which could speak volumes to our generation if we could listen.'?

It was in this Hyderabad that the young Maududi’s personality was formed." Sensitive and impressionable, he started his journalistic career in 1918 by joining the editorial staff of the Medina (Bijnore). After working as editor of the Taj Jabalpur) he took over the editorship of AL Jamiyat (Delhi) in 1925. The shuddi movement was at its height and, as mentioned earlier, at this time the young editor of Al-Jamiyat started writing his articles. They were obviously written under the pressure of his day-to-day work and they were all completed within six months.'* Maududi began to write these articles ‘more as a nationalist than a religious zealot’, but on further study of Islamic literature - as much as he could read in six months and without Islamic schooling - he became a religious revivalist.'> Both his articles in Al-Jihad fil Islam and the overall evolution of his own thought were very much piecemeal. He started writing the book as a nationalist Indian'® and, as such, his aim was to prove to the Indian Hindus, and especially to Gandhiji, that Islam was not a religion of violence. In a speech at Jami Masjid, Delhi, the great Indian Muslim leader, Maulana Muhammad Ali Jowhar, said he wished that a Muslim would write a book pointing out that Islam had nothing to do with violence. Young Maududi was among the audience and decided to take up the task.'” So, in the first instalments of his articles, he pointed out to Hindus that Islam was nota religion of the sword. But our author was born and bred in a Muslim kingdom where the Hindu majority was under a Muslim leader.

The writer of two books on the history of Hyderabad'* was steeped in the power of political authority. He soon contradicted his own arguments against the jihad of the sword. This Hyderabadi Muslim was to assert: ‘It is fallacious to say that the sword did not play any role in conversion.’ The young journalist was neither a historian nor a scholar of religion. He could not understand that though Muslim dynasties ruled the Deccan for 600 years, the overwhelming majority of that area remained Hindu. Political power in Muslim hands has never helped conversion to Islam. The author of Jihad fil Islam was just 24 years old. And the Maulana, even at the age of 65, remained ‘superficial’. As Prof. Fazlur Rahman ob- served:

Maududi, though not an alim, was nevertheless a self-taught man of considerable intelligence and sufficient knowledge. ... He was by no means an accurate or profound scholar, but he was undoubtedly like a fresh wind in the stifling Islamic atmosphere created by the traditional madrasas. . . . But Maududi displays nowhere the larger and more profound vision of Islam’s role in the world. Being a journalist rather than a serious scholar he wrote at great speed and with resultant superficiality in order to feed his eager young readers - and he wrote incessantly. ... Not one of Maududi’s followers ever became a serious student of Islam, the result being that, for the faithful, Maududi’s statements represented the last word on Islam - no matter how much and how blatantly he contradicted himself from time to time on such basic issues as economic policy and political theory.'*

The late Mufti Kifayatullah of Delhi held the same opinion. He said: ‘Tknow Maulana Abul Ala Maududi. He has neither learned from nor been disciplined by a scholar of repute. He is very well read but his understanding of religion is weak.”°

The late Maulana Husain Ahmad Madani foresaw the danger very clearly and said:

His pamphlets and books contain opinions which are anti-religious and

heretic, though written with theological trappings. Lay readers cannot

see through these trappings. As a result they find the Islam brought by the

·

10 of 10 left today