Chapter 3: A Rebuttal of Maududian Philosophy

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 4

Holy Prophet repugnant; the Islam which has been followed by the

Ummat-i-Muhammadiya for the last 1350 years.??

In one of his letters, Maualana Qari Muhammad Tayyab wrote:

‘Having read Maududi Sahib’s writings I have concluded that he did not acquire the disciplines of Muslim legal philosophy and mysticism. He cannot write on them with authority.”

The late Maulana Ahmad Ali Lahauri also wrote in the same vein:

Maududi Sahib wants to present a ‘New Islam’ to the Muslims. And

Muslims will not accept a ‘New Islam’ unless the old Islam, which they

have followed for the last 1,350 years, is not fully destroyed and it is

proved that Islam has become irrelevant and impractical.”

Maulana Maududi, as we have seen, was neither an historian nora religious scholar. he was essentially a journalist and he had the two basic qualities of a journalist: a good command of the Urdu language and the ability to write quickly. The Al-Jamiyat was a bi-weekly at that time and he had to write his column on jihad within two or three days, in addition to editing his newspaper. Having no background in research and no time for it then, he mistook the battle of Hunayn (30 January 630), which came soon after the submission of Mecca (11 January), as a turning-pointin Islamic history. Since Islam’s enemies were decisively beaten at Hunayn, the Maulana concluded that it was this victory and the political power gained through it which helped the conversion of the whole of Arabia to Islam. Maulana Maududi is not alone in drawing this conclusion. The orientalists, who see no moral or spiritual force in Islamic teachings and are unable to understand the great miracles performed by our Holy Prophet,* have always put Muslim expansion down to force. The orien- talists divided the life of the Prophet into two sections, the first the period of Meccan persecution and second the period of conquest after his migration to Medina. Our young journalist, Abul Ala Maududi, with his superficial knowledge of Islamic history, accepted this apparently sim- plistic but, in reality, very clever division of the Holy Prophet’s* life.

Armed conflict, war and threats of war were forced constantly on the Prophet.* After he migrated to Medina, the pagans of Mecca and the Jews of Medina, encouraged by the hypocrites, busily plotted against Islam. They inspired hatred against Muslims and worked pagan Arabs up to a fever pitch against the Holy Prophet®. All the defensive actions the Muslims were forced to take obstructed the Prophet’s* basic mission. Muslims needed peace but, as our examination will show, that peace was deliberately disturbed to prevent them from spreading the new faith.

1 Islam’s enemies used every means of communication against Islam. For the Arabs, poets were historians, genealogists, satirists, moralists and founts of wisdom.”* The poet was the ‘kindler of battle> and ‘the journalist of the time’2® The Ansar (the Muslims of Medina) were accused of dishonouring themselves by submitting to an outsider. Asma bint Marwan of Umayyah b. Zayd composed verses taunting and insult- ing Medinite Muslims. She said:

Cowards”’ of Malik and Nabit

And cowards of Awf and Khazraj

You obey a stranger who does not belong to you

Who is neither a Murad nor a Mad’hij”*

Do you - when your own chiefs have

been murdered - hope inhim

Like the greedy people looking towards

acooking pot of meal soup?

Is there no man of honour among you who will

take advantage of an unguarded moment

And cut off the gulls’ hopes??? The centenarian poet of Khazrajite class, Abu Afak, taunted the Medinites with the following verses:

Ihave lived a long time, but I have

never seen

Either a house or gathering of people

More loyal and faithful to

Its allies, when they call on them,

Than those of the Children of Qayla*”

as a whole.

The mountains will crumble before they submit.

Yet here isa rider come among them

who has divided them.

(He says) ‘This is permitted, this is

forbidden’

To all kinds of things

But if you had believed in power

And in might, why did you not follow

Tubba?! Tubbas were south Arabian kings of great reputation. Abu Afak, in effect, asked the Ansar, ‘Once you resisted Tubba, now what has happened to you that you have accepted the claims of a Meccan refugee?’ While Asma and Abu Afak were putting the Ansar to shame, the Jewish poet Kab b. al-Ashraf®, enraged by the Muslim victory at Badr, went all the way to Mecca to rouse the Quraish against the Holy Prophet. He played on the Arab weakness for vengeance:

Badr’s mill ground out the blood of its people. At events like Badr you should weep and cry. The best people were killed round their cisterns. Don’t think it strange that princes were left iying How many noble, handsome men,

The refuge of the homeless, were slain,

Liberal when the stars gave no rain.>>

2 The vendetta, as we have observed earlier, was one of the pillars of pre- Islamic Arab society. So, whenever a pagan combatant was killed by a Muslim in armed conflict, his heirs took an oath to avenge his death and the whole tribe accused Islam of his death. The fact that conflicts were initiated by pagans themselves was conveniently forgotten.

3 The Holy Prophet’s* mission was restricted to a small area of Arabia because of the general hostility to him. Missionaries could not take the message of Islam to the whole of the peninsula.

4 Many Arabs had accepted Islam, but fear of war made them afraid to declare their new faith.

·

10 of 10 left today