Chapter 3: A Rebuttal of Maududian Philosophy
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 6
These were the people who travelled all the way from Yathrib (Medina) to Mecca to offer their swords to the Prophet* and who are now known as Ansar (Helpers).
A few Jews in Medina and a small number of Arabs from outlying towns also became Muslims, but nore of them accepted their new faith under duress or as a result of armed conflict. During this period the spread of Islam in Mecca was relentless and, despite greater persecution, the Meccan Arabs continued to accept Islam. Again, force did not enter into it.
The conversion of prisioners-of-war is the only remotely possible exception. Before we look at it, let us clear up one misunderstanding. The words ghazwah and sariyah do not mean ‘war’ or even ‘armed conflict’. They only mean ‘an expedition’. Scouts, patrols, embassies, rescue parties, the chasing of highwaymen - even a single Companion’s journey to preach - are grouped under these titles. Expeditions were known as sariyah; if the Prophet* himself led them, as ghazwah. For instance, the first expedition the Prophet* led was to Al-Abwa, where his mother was buried. He was accompanied by sixty Muhajirs. The Holy Prophet* stayed there for a few days and signed a treaty of friendship with the chief of the Bunu Damrah. Soon after, the Prophet® had to follow Kurz al- Fihri. As Watt points out, ‘It was an attempt to punish a freebooter of the neighbouring region for stealing some of the Medinite pasturing cam- els.° The expedition, again in the words of Watt, ‘Illustrates the dangers against which he [the Holy Prophet*] had to be constantly on guard.” There were about fifty such expeditions between Hijrah and the truce of Hudaybiyah. Of them, three conflicts assumed the dimensions of full- scale war. Badr, Uhud and Ahzab. In the armed conflict with B. Mustaliq over 100 prisoners were taken, but all of them were freed without ransom. In some minor expeditions where one or two prisoners were seized, they too were released without any conditions. It was at the battle of Badr that seventy-two prisoners-of-war were taken. Two of them were executed for past crimes; the rest were freed after a ransom was paid. That, in some cases, was limited only to teaching the children of Ansar how to read and write.
The third period began with the truce of Hudaybiyah and ended with the surrender of Mecca. Twenty-two expeditions were made during this period. Of them, only three conflicts saw any prisoners-of-war being taken. The Prophet had sent Dihyah b. Khalifah al-Kalbias an envoy to Caesar. On his return journey, Dihyah was robbed of Byzantine presents he was carrying for the Holy Prophet*, by Al-Hunayd and other members of the tribe of Jurham. The Prophet® sent an expedition under Zayd b. Haritha to punish Al-Hunayd and his allies. The prisoners taken in the resulting skirmish were freed after they repented. Bashir b. Sad successfully led an expedition against the Ghatfan, who were in alliance with the Jews of Medina and the pagans of Mecca. A small number of prisioners were taken, but it is not known what happened to them. Similarly, an expedition was sent to punish B. Bani Kilab. A group of B. Uraynah, who lived among the B. Kilab, came in distress to Medina and accepted Islam. As they were suffering from a fever, they were sent to the Prophet’s* pasture grounds to enjoy good food and milk. But, when they recovered their strength, they cruelly killed the herdsmen and stole fifteen camels. They were punished. There was probably a small number of prisoners, but the details are not known.
This rather detailed examination shows that from the Hijrah to the surrender of Mecca, not a single prisoner-of-war was forced to convert. There is no evidence to suggest that the filth of their soul was removed by the blade of the sword. Rather, these prisoners were allowed to return to their paganism.
The final period of the Holy Prophet’s® life began with Mecca’s surrender - or the day of the conquering of hearts. That Islamic victory over the Meccans conclusively proved that the spreading of Islam was not even remotely connected with violence. Not one person was con- verted by force.
Abu Sufyan, the arch-enemy of Islam, who became a Muslim on the eve of the Prophet’s* triumphant entry into Mecca, watched the Muslim army from a vantage point near the city. The Holy Prophet’s® uncle, Abbas, was with him. What Abu Sufyan saw there has been vividly described by Martin Lings:
Troop after troop went by, and, at the passing of each, Abu Sufyan asked
who they were, and each time he marvelled, either because the tribe in
question had hitherto been far beyond the range of influence of Quraish,
or because it had recently been hostile to the Prophet, as was the case with
the Ghatafanite clan of Ashja, one of whose ensigns was borne by
Nuaym, the former friend of himself and Suhayl.
‘Of all the Arabs,’ said Abu Sufayn, ‘These were Muhammad’s bitterest foes.’ ‘God caused Islam to enter their hearts,’ said Abbas. ‘All this is by the grace of God.”#! Was it the sword which converted them? And when the Prophet® enfered Mecca with his 10,000 men, did he avenge the thirteen-year persecution? The idea of settling scores was certainly in the minds of some. When Sad ibn Ubada saw Abu Sufyan he said: ‘O Abu Sufyan, this is the day of slaughter: the day when the inviolable shall be violated: the day of God’s abasement of Quraish.’ When Abu Sufyan repeated to the Holy Prophet* what Sad had said, the Prophet® replied: ‘This is the day of mercy, the day on which God has exalted Quraish.’ A general amnesty was proclaimed. Using the words of Joseph*, as reported in the Holy Qur’an, Muhammads said: ‘Verily I say as my brother Joseph said, this day there shall be no reproach on you. May Allah forgive you. He is the Most Merciful of all those who show mercy.’ (12.93)
Washington Irving, by no means a sympathetic observer of Islam, describes the Holy Prophet’s* entry into Mecca in the following way:
The sun was just rising as he entered the gates of his native city, with the
glory of a conqueror, but the garb and humility of a pilgrim. He entered,
repeating verses of the Holy Qur’an, which he said had been revealed to him at
Medina, and were prophetic of the event. He triumphed in the spirit of a
religious zealot, not a warrior.”
Meccan leaders who opposed the Prophet* with every means at their disposal were not only magnanimously pardoned but also, as even Montgomery Watt admits: ‘Were not forced to become Muslims; they and doubtless many others remained pagan, at least till after Al-Jiranah’.? Maxime Rodinson agrees with Watt: ‘No man seems to have felt under constraint to embrace Islam.’*
Had there been even the remotest hint of conversion by force in our primary sources of hadith or sirah, the critics of Islam would have had a field day. Now compare again the opinions of Irving, Watt and Rodinson with what Maulana Maududi said on the subject: “When every method of persuasion failed, the Prophet* took to the sword. That sword removed evil and mischief and the filth of the soul.’
The conquest of Mecca will be engraved on the pages of history for ever. That day will continue to absolve the Prophet* - the Mercy for Mankind - from charges of violence and force which Maulana Maududi has imputed to him. That a non-Muslim orientalisi, Stanley Lane-Poole, should have to put right Maududi’s mistake is a tragedy of great magni- tude which should sadden the heart of every Muslim. Lane-Poole says: