Chapter 3: A Rebuttal of Maududian Philosophy
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 5
5 Conversion to a new religion requires commitment and courage, even when honour and life itself are not at risk. Here, acceptance of Islam demanded more than the joining of a religious society: it meant taking up arms in its defence. Since Muslims at this time were unarmed and weak, it was suicide to join them.
6 Self-defence kept the Muslims so busy that very little time was left for spreading the faith.
If our premise is correct, the ending of hostilities should have immediately boosted the spread of Islam. As we shall see, this is exactly what happened. Mecca was conquered in January 630. That, according to the orientalists and enemies of Islam, was the turning-point in Islamic history. If that were true, one could indeed say that the sword had played a role in the spread of Islam. But history tells a rather different story. Hostilities between the Muslims and the pagan Arabs ended with the truce of Al-Hudaybiah™ (March 628). The terms of the truce appeared to be so degrading that ‘Umar could not contain himself, and asked the Prophet*: ‘Why yield we in such lowly wise against the honour of our religion?’ The Meccans thought it was a victory. But it was this respite from armed conflict which gave the Holy Prophet much more time to spread the faith. The extent of his success can be gauged by the 10,000 Muslims who marched to Mecca with him in January 630. Previously, his largest force had been 3000 men. This was the strength of the Muslim army which defended Medina when it was besieged by an army of 10,000 pagan Arabs.?> The additional 7000 men were obviously converted to Islam during the two-year truce. People like Amr b. al-As and Khalid b. Walid were converted at this time. The success of this peaceful penetration by Islam was so great that a puzzled Montgomery Watt counts it ‘among the imponderabilia’ and adds: ‘Foremost among the reasons for this success of Muhammad’s was the attractiveness of Islam and its relevance as a religious and social system to the religious and social needs of the Arabs.° Watt also says, as if directly addressing Maulana Maududi himself:
Had Muhammad not been able to maintain and strengthen his hold on the
Muslims by the sway of religious ideas of Islam over their imaginations,
and had he not been able to attract fresh converts to Islam, the treaty of
Al-Hudaybiah would not have worked in his favour. ... Any historian
whois not biased in favour of materialism must also allow as factors of
supreme importance Muhammad’s belief in the message of the Holy Qur’an,
his belief in the structure of Islam as a religious and political system, and
his unflinching devotion to the task to which, as he believed, God had
called him ... This expedition and treaty mark a new initiative on the part
of Muhammad.”
It is sad to note that while an orientalist puts the Holy Prophet’s* success down to ‘the sway of the religious ideas of Islam’, a leading Muslim of Maulana Maududi’s stature insists that it was through the sway of the sword after the battle of Hunayn that teeming thousands of Arabs accepted Isiam. If these were the people whose souls were cleansed with the blade of the sword, :hen these were also the people who were the first to revolt after the Prophet’s* death. That answer to the Maulana’s argument, however, does not explain the revolt.
In the past travel was difficult. There were no roads and therefore one’s safety could not be guaranteed. It was, therefore, impossible for every Arab to come to the Prophet® to learn about Islam at first hand, nor for the Prophet to visit every region of the peninsula. The Arab custom was that either a tribal delegation would be sent to the Prophet® or a Muslim delegation would be sent to the tribes to deliver the message of Islam. There were discussions and debates, and after every question had been asked the tribe accepted whatever the members of the delegation or the elders of the tribe decided. So there was a large number of converts who had no opportunity of benefiting directly from the Prophet’s® teaching; they had never even seen him. They did not even have the chance to spend time with the Prophet’s** Companions. Religion is a personal experience and is learned especially by example and inspi- ration - things not available to the new converts. Misfortune was com- pounded by the death of the Holy Prophet® soon after their conversion. The Arab horizon was more than a little darkened by the passing away of Muhammad™. We can learn a great deal from that period of history. When people reject the prophet of their time and extinguish his light by force, they are severely punished for it.
One result of that punishment is that most people see the light of iman (belief) when the source of that light is about to be extinguished. Sometimes people only recognise a prophet long after his death. What a punishment! To persecute a prophet while he is alive; to accept him only after he has gone.
Since Maulana Maududi joined the worst enemies of Islam by arguing that the sword played a partin the preaching of Islam, let us re- examine the Prophet’s* life to see if at any stage people were converted against their will.
The division of the Holy Prophet’s* life into two periods, the Meccan and the Medinite, seems logical, but it is in reality an over-simplification. After the Hijrah, the Prophet* and the Emigrants had escaped persecu- tion, but the struggle for survival was not over. It would be more logical to divide the Prophet’s* life into three phases: the first being the time up to his migration to Medina, and the second the time from his migration to the truce of Hudaybiyah, which was also a period of persecution; the third from the truce to the surrender of Mecca. (Though the Muslims were allowed to fight back, they were no match for the pagan opposition. Medina was the only town where Muslims lived, but they did not control it. The three Jewish tribes and the non-Muslim members of the Aws and the Khazraj dominated the town. The size of the opposing armies at the battle of Badr** represented their actual strength. Therefore, this period should be considered an extension of the Meccan period of bitter struggle.) The third period begins with the truce of Hudaybiyah and ends with the surrender of Mecca. It was a period of peace. The Meccan pagans did not attack the Muslims, though a few skirmishes took place with the Jews and some Arab tribes who broke their agreements with the Muslims.
The first period of persecution lasted thirteen years. During that time there was no question of conversion by force. Even the orientalists agree with that. In fact, people accepted Islam in spite of Meccan persecution. Muslims who accepted Islam in Mecca at that time are known as Muhajirs Emigrants) and it is an historical fact that no Emigrant was unwillingly converted.
The Muslims offered armed resistance during the second period of their persecution. A critic might think that during that armed conflict at least some might have been forced into accepting Islam. But the history of the period is fully documented. The majority of Muslims in Medina belonged to two Arab tribes, the Aws and the Khazraj. These were the people who had invited the Holy Prophet* to Medina. When they met him at Aqbah, he said: ‘I make with you this pact on condition that the allegiance you pledge me shall bind you to protect me even as you protect your women and children.’ The Khazrajite chief, Bara, who rose to reply, took the Prophet’s® hand and said:
By Him who sent thee with the truth, we will protect thee as we
protect them. So accept the pledge of our allegiance, O Messenger
of God, for we are men of war, possessed of arms that have been
handed down from father to son.