Chapter 4: Prophets and Troopers A Study in Contrast

Murder in the Name of Allah

PROPHETS AND TROOPERS A Study in Contrast

Remind them for thou(O Prophet) art an admonisher. Thou art not at all a warder over them. Qur’an, 88.22 -3

It [Jamaati Islami] is not a missionary organisation or a body of preachers or evangelists, but an organisation of God’s troopers. Maulana Abul Ala Maududi!

The picture of Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam* painted by nineteenth- century orientalists has been examined in the previous chapter. It was a picture of a fanatical warricr riding out of the Arabian deserts with a drawn sword in one hand and the Holy Qur’an in the other, offering his helpless victims a choice between the two. The harshness of this picture, popular- ised by Edward Gibbon? has now been toned down by modern oriental- ists. Even the well-known Jewish scholar, Bernard Lewis, with his dry British humour, had to admit that the picture, ‘Is not only false but also impossible - unless we are able to assume a race of left-handed swords- men. In Muslim practice, the left hand is reserved for unclean purposes, and no self-respecting Muslim would use it to raise the Holy Qur’an.”

But there is one ‘self-respecting’ Muslim, Maulana Maududi, who clutched his drawn sword in his right hand, irrespective of its lack of relevance to the teachings of the Holy Qur’an and the practices of the Holy Prophet®.

The Maulana claims to be a loyal follower of the Prophet, and, as such, one would expect him to talk admiringly of his Master. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. But how can he see defects in his Lord which even Islam’s modern enemies reject? There are three answers to this question.

1 That the Maulana’s claim to be a loyal follower of Islam is false. In view of what the Maulana wrote in Al-Jihad fil Islam and his other works, the reader may reasonably be led to believe that the author is not even remotely concerned with the teachings of the Holy Prophet® and that his claim to be a loyal follower is false. That would be a very serious charge. Since I belong to a sect which has been falsely accused of showing disrespect to the Holy Prophet‘, I would be the last to doubt the Maulana’s loyalty to our Lord and Master, Muhammad - may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

2 That the Maulana’s sense of values has been confused, so he has as much difficulty in telling good from evil as a colour-blind person does in telling red frcm green.

3 That the Maulana is obsessed - obsessed with a desire for poiitical

power and authority. Obsession has been defined as ‘A persistent or

recurrent idea, usually strongly tinged with emotion, frequently involv-

ing an urge towards some form of action; the whole mental situation

being pathological.’

Pierre Janet found that an obsessive person was scrupulous, ever- conscientious and stricken by a sense of worthlessness.° Elton Mayo has summarised Janet’s and his own characterisation of obsessives in these terms: ‘They are the experts in arduous rethinking of the obvious - they substitute an exaggerated precision in minor activities for that activity in major affairs of which they are or feel themselves to be incapable®

The Maulana’s childhood memories and adolescent experiences in Hyderabad, as we have seen earlier, led him towards one source of behavioural control - political power. Kurt Lewin has observed that if an individual’s behaviour is to be understood, it must be in terms of his life-space - one has to relate the individual] to his environment over the course of time and at the particular moment. Lewin’s field of interest is thus:‘the life-space, containing the person and his psychological envi- ronment.” Woodsworth and Sheehan elaborate Lewin’s thecry and say:

The psychological (or behavioural) environment is, of course, the en-

vironment as perceived and understood by the person, but more than

that, it is the environment as related to his present needs and quasi- needs. Many objects which are perceived are of no present concern to him and so exist only in the background of his psychological environ- ment. Other objects have positive or negative ‘valence’ - positive if they promise to meet his present needs, negative if they threaten injury.

Objects of positive valence attract him, while objects of negative

valence repel him.’

Psychology is not an absolute science and it is still evolving, but Maulana Maududi’s ‘obsession’ seems to fit the theory we have dis- cussed. That is not to say, of course, that there might not be another explanation of his obsessive behaviour. Whatever the explanation, the Maulana’s vision has undoubtedly been blurred by obsession. He trips and, at times, stumbles into paths which have been traversed before him by the enemies of God. It is this obsession which causes him to support capital punishment for those who switch religions.* This punishment has always been demanded for prophets and their followers who change from their traditional religion. It is the same obsession which impels him to put a sword into the Holy Prophet’s* hand and, in doing so, to support those enemies of Islam who paint a gory picture of Muhammad. Since per- suasion and force are mutually exclusive, the Maulana adopts the sword as a means of reform and rejects reasoning as a method of conversion. Persuasion and reasoning are difficult tasks of which he is or feels himself to be incapable. They entail sacrifice and long suffering in the face of opposition, as the Prophet’s** Meccan life showed. So the Maulana rejects them as objects of negative valence. Force through political power seems to meet his present needs, so he adopts it and relates it to the Holy Prophet’s* life with a process of arduous thinking.

When I refer to the Maulana’s obsession, I do not mean to show him any disrespect, although, by putting a sword into the hands of my Lord and Master Muhammad* he has shown disrespect to the Prophet® and all he stood for. Reviewing Israel Shenker’s book, Coat of Many Colors, a collection of essays on Judaism, Hugh Nissenden says: ‘Mr Shenker dramatises his obsession in a way that makes the history of his people accessible and illuminating to everyone." J only wish the Maulana could put his obsession to good use. Instead, he justifies force, not only as legitimate, but also as an essential method of reform. He says: ‘It is not possible that they [the enemies of Islam] would sacrifice their interests in the face of persuasion and reasoning. All that one can do is to acquire political power'! and force them to stop their mischief.”?

This method of reform seems to be effective and also easier than persuasion, which requires patience and persistence in the face of ridicule, rebuffs and snubs. It is so easy to convert people by force. There is no comparison between the two methods. One is easy and quick; the other difficult and time consuming, requiring the patience of Job*. All reformers have had to endure ridicule and rejection. This is how the

Qur’an describes their lot:

Those who were guilty used to laugh at those who believed; and

when they passed by them, they winked at each other. When they

came back to their families, they exulted over them; and when they saw them they exclaimed: ‘These indeed are the lost ones.’

10 von 10 heute frei