Chapter 4: Prophets and Troopers A Study in Contrast
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 2
But they were not appointed keepers over them. (83.30-4)
The verses quoted above explain why the Maulana would not follow the path of the reformers sent by God. People laugh at reformers and say: ‘Look at these people whose only weapon is persuasion! They are so weak we can crush them whenever we wish; and yet they claim to win people over by their reasoning and advice.’ So the Maulana rejected peaceful argument and said instead:
Anyone who wants to uproot mischief and disorder from this world and wants to reform mankind should realise that he cannot do so by mere sermonising and counselling. It is useless. He should rise against the government of false principles, he should seize power, remove the wrongdoers from authority and set up a government based on sound principles and just administration.
But the Maududian method of reform, which is modelled on Marx- ism, is not the divine way of saving mankind. In God’s plan, persuasion is so important that, even in an age of general moral decline, only pious believers ‘who exhort one another with truth and steadfastness’ (103.4) will succeed. Even a cursory glance at history will reveal that for spiritual and moral revolutions God asks his servants to win ove the people with truth and patience. Patience and prayer are the integral part of religious revolution and they should continue to be exhorted till God’s promise is fuifiiled. It is foretold that ‘the [pleasing] end is for the righteous’ (7.129)
All God’s messengers have followed this method of religious reform, one which is totally opposed to the Marxist use of force. The Holy Qur’an preserves the account of many prophets and evangelists. According to this divine account, Noah’s*s instrument of revolution was persuasion and Abraham’s* was also. It was the instrament of Shuaib* and Saleh*. Lot*s was also sent as a counsellor and so was Moses*. Jesus** caused a revolution with his sermons. And, above all, the Seal of the Prophets, the leading reformer of all time, our Master Muhammiad® was sent to bring about a universai spiritual revolution with nothing but persuasion and reasoning. But the Maulana not only ignores this tradition of God’s holy messengers; he also contradicts it in the following words: ‘Anyone who wants to uproot mischief and disorder from this world and wants to reform mankind should realise that he cannot do so by mere sermon- ising and counselling. It is useless.’
Let us compare this Maududian dictum with the unbroken tradition of God’s messengers. When Noah’s* people accused him of spreading ‘manifest error’, he replied:
O my people, there is no error in me, but I am a Messenger from the Lord
of the world. I deliver to you the message of my Lord and give you sincere
advice, and] know from Allah what you do not know. (7.62-3)
This is God’s account of Noah’s® ministry. According to the Mavdudian dictum, Noah® should have said: ‘I am the Messenger of God and I shall impose upon you, whether you like it or not, a body of righteous men who will take away your power.’
When the people of Ad told Hud* he was lost in foolishness, he did not say: ‘Do not be deceived and consider me a fool because of the harmlessness of the advice; you are not seeing the real me. In fact, lam an oppressor and one day I will seize power from the hands of those who have rebelled against God and give it to my own, righteous, people.’ Indeed, he did not. Instead, he followed the tradition of the prophets and said:
O my people, there is no foolishness in me, but I am a Messenger from
the Lord of the worlds. I deliver to you the messages of my Lord and I am
to youa sincere and faithful counsellor. (7.68-9)
The people of Thamud, like those of Ad, rejected Saleh** and accused him of all sorts of things. But, following Noah* and Hud*, he told them: ‘O my people, I did deliver the message of my Lord unto you and offered you sincere counsel, but you love not sincere counsellors.’ (7.80)
And then God sent Lot*s, whose followers also made no attempt to seize power from the misguided, and continued to reason with them till they were punished. Before the appointed punishment came, Lot® and his followers left their homes with God’s permission. And then came that morning about which tyrants have always been admonished: ‘Hopeless will that morning be for those who have been warned.’ (37.178)
The seventh chapter of the Holy Qur’an continues with the story of the misguided people and the messengers* of God who tried to reform them. After telling the story of Lot*, the Holy Qur’an tells us how Shuaib* reasoned with his arrogant people and pleaded with his cruel tormentors. When all his advice was rejected, he turned away and said: ‘O my people. indeed, I deliver to you the messages of my Lord and give you sincere counsel. How, then, should I sorrow for a disbelieving people?’ (7.94)
The Holy Qur’an, which for Maulana Maududi and all Muslims is the Word of God, tells us that all God’s messengers give sermons and advice and when these are rejected, they cry and pray before their Lord. They have an unshakeable belief in their message and, instead of seizing power from their enemies, they continue to offer love and kindness. They reason gently, impart advice with humility and leave the result to God. He alone is the Lord and He bestows the earth on whoever He pleases. The wishes of all His messengers are epitomised in Moses” words: ‘O Lord, send down on us steadfastness and make us die as men who have surrendered to Thee.’ (7.127) Moses* advised his people, ‘to seek help from Allah and wait in patience and constancy’ (7.129) and told them that the ‘Earth belongs to Allah; He gives it as a heritage to whoever He pleases’. (7.129) It is not for righteous men to seize power by force. All that we know is that ‘the end is best for the God-fearing’. (7.129)
After Moses*s, Jesus*, too, spent his life exhorting and counselling and never considered seizing power. Finally, the chief of all prophets, Muhammad® was sent as an exhorter and counsellor to invite the poeple to be virtuous, not as a kind of a policeman or a soldier. God named him ‘admonisher’ and said: ‘Remind them, for thou art an admonisher. Thou hast no authority to compel them.’ (88.22-3)