Chapter 4: Prophets and Troopers A Study in Contrast

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3

But the Maulana insists that he and his followers ‘are not a body of religious preachers and evangelists, but an organisation of God’s troop- ers so that they “may be a witness against mankind’”. (2.144) The task of these ‘troopers’ is to use force to wipe out ‘injustice, mischief, disorder, disobedience and exploitation from the world’.'*

God tells the greatest of his prophets: “We have not appointed thee a keeper over them, nor art thou over them a guardian’. (6.108) But Maulana Maududi reserves for himself and his followers not only the authority of a policeman, but also the powers of a magistrate. It is surprising that God did not give the Prophet, His greatest reformer, temporal authority over the hearts of unbelievers, but gave it instead to Maulana Maududi and his followers. The Holy Prophet® - the embodi- ment of mercy and compassion - prayed hard that he should become instrumental in showing the path of righteousness to all mankind. But God answered: ‘Will thou, then, take it upon thyself to force people to become believers?’ (10.100) As far as believers are concerned, God told the Holy Prophet®: ‘And if Allah had enforced His will, they would not have set up gods with Him. And We have not made thee as keeper over them, nor art thou over them a guardian.’ (6.108)

In contrast to the established conduct of all the messengers of God mentioned in the Holy Qur’an by name or in general, Maulana Maududi gave himself the authority to oppress and compel God’s servants so that the Jamaati Islami could eradicate injustice, mischief, disorders, disobe- dience and exploitation from the world’.!5

The Maulana’s ambition of seizing power knew no bounds: he would go to any lengths to achieve it. He was totally obsessed with political authority and considered that the worship of God had been prescribed to train Muslims to usurp power and rule the world. For him, worship had no spiritual purpose. It was not a religious experience, a meeting ground between man and his Creator, but a ritual of self-discipline. God says: ‘I have created Jinn and men that they may worship Me.’ (51.57) The world was created for the worship of God. Worship was not created for any other purpose. But the Maulana insists:

The prayers (salat), fasting, charity (zakat) and pilgrimage have been

prescribed to prepare and train us for this purpose (jihad). All the

governments in the world give their armies special and specific training, their police and civil service too. In the same way, Islam also trains those

who join its service - then requires them to go tojihad and establish the

government of God.!*

No religion in the world preaches such a materialistic concept of worship. But even the worship of God can become nothing more than an army drill for a person who is obsessed.

Ambition is impatient by definition, but of all ambitions power mania brooks least delay. So the Maulana would not take the straight path - it was too narrow and too long for him. And Marxism, too, will not take the long and hard route of democracy to liberate the oppressed. Instead, it adopts violence to try to overthrow the elected government of the day. The Maulana’s method of reform is no different from the Marxist ideology of violent struggle. The Maulana says: ‘Stand up to reform people wherever you can. Try to replace wrong principles with correct ones. Snatch away executive and legislative powers from those who do not fear God.!”

It is surprising that a journalist of Maulana Maududi’s long political experience could not understand the principle that governments should not be overthrown by force, whatever the reason. To break this basic rule is to destroy law and order. The fires of civil war would consume the very fabric of society.

Firstly, no party can be its own judge and decide its intentions are good. Secondly, even if those intentions are good, the opposition parties cannot be condemned out of hand. It is inconceivable that every member of the opposition is cruel, unjust or evil, while every member of “God’s troopers’ is pious, God-fearing and free from greed and lust. The fact is that parties which start the work of reform with high-flying claims are the ones which soon become greedy for pawer, their good intentions burned up by the flames of greed. The Maulana himself explains how uncontrol- lable is the desire for power:

As everyone knows, power is such a dangerous demon that the very

desire of it is accompanied by an all-consuming greed. Man eagerly

looks forward to owning earthly treasures and controlling his fellow creatures so that he may exercise absolute power over them.'®

One problem in uttering such uncontrolled rhetoric is that even an experienced journalist like Maududi forgets the inherent contradictions within his writings. If the very thought of power can bring a dangerous change of heart, what guarantee is there that the ‘upright’ members of the Jamaati Islami would not be corrupted by absolute power? No doubt these ‘upright’ men have undergone the ‘civil service training’ pre- scribed by God, i.e. Islamic worship (prayers, fasting and zakat), but this ‘service training’ is not restricted to the Jamaati Islami. Ahmadi worship is not accepted as Islamic worship, according to Maulana Maududi, but what about Brelvi and Deobandi worship? Is Shiite worship not Islamic worship? Would anyone say that the prayers offered by Ahli Qur’an are non-Islamic? If so, why should not these Muslim sects ‘rise against governments based on false principles, seize power, remove the wrong- doers and establish a government based on sound and just administra- tion?’ ‘False’, ‘wrongdoers’, ‘sound’ and ‘just’ are relative terms. What is false according to the Jamaati Islami may not be false according to the Deobandis. What is sound and just according to the Deobandis may not be sound and just for the Brelvis. Then, what about non-Muslims? They, too, have their own views about what is right and wrong. If their views were no different from those of Muslims, they would have queued to join Islam. Would they also have had a right to overthrow the government of the day?

Good intentions or reform projects cannot become an excuse to overthrow governments. There are such vast differences in the defini- tion of ‘uprightness’ between different political parties that if all these differences were accepted, no party could be considered ‘upright’. For instance, according to the Maulana, the Ahmadiyyah Movement has no connection with Islam; the British government created it to divide the

·

10 of 10 left today