Chapter 5: The Maududian Law of Apostasy

Murder in the Name of Allah

THE MAUDUDIAN LAW OF APOSTASY

Surely, this is a reminder; so whoever wishes may take the way that leads to his Lord.

Qur’an, 76.30

In our domain we neither allow any Muslim to change his religion nor allow any other religion to propagate its faith. Maulana Maududi!

Maulana Maududi’s desire for political power knew no bounds. The law of apostasy which he evolved was an extension of his dictatorial and intolerant personality - it had nothing to do with Islam. Dr Israr Ahmad, who worked closely with Maududi, said that Maududi borrowed the principles of his movement from Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and the Khairi brothers and the style of his presentation from Niyaz Fatehpuri. But he was so egocentric that he never acknowledged that his ideas came from anyone but himself?

Similarly, the Maulana’s ideas on apostasy, though originating from an interpretive error of early Muslim jurisprudence (figh) are, in fact, based on medieval Christianity. The Deoband schooi,? which was on one hand collaborating with a predominantly Hindu political organisation - the Indian National Congress - and on the other fighting a rearguard action against the shuddi campaign, provided the gloss to Maududi’s thoughts on the subject. The influence of Marxist writings, which the Maulana seems to have read when a young and impressionable editor, is markedly noticeable in his thinking. The Tahrik-i Jamaati Islami is a curious blend of medieval Christian practices, Deobandi/Wahabi intol- erance and Marxist incitement to disruption.

As we saw in the first chapter of this book, the concept of religious liberty is not evolutionary or lineal - it is a cyclical phenomenon. Whenever one of God’s prophets or a religious reformer appears, he is opposed. He is accused of dividing the community and breaking tradi- tional conformity. He is pilloried as an apostate. Ultimately a prophet always succeeds in establishing religious freedom. The true faith spread by this religious freedom is hardened in rigid dogma, which actually results in the loss of the right to dissent.

On his last visit to the Temple, Christ*® said: ‘Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and unto God the things that are God’s.’ (Mark 12:17) This very clear statement separates religious belief from political authority. However, within a year of obtaining political authority (312), the Christian Church was torn by schism. For more than 300 years Christians had been persecuted and flourished, and yet, soon after Con- stantine’s conversion, the Church was confronted with monastic seces- sion, Donatist schism and Arian heresy. Throughout the history of the Christian Church, heresy, or deviation from orthodoxy, has been a matter of deep concern. It invariably involves the very concept of deity, the divinity of Christ’s.

If Christ was divine in an absolute sense, yet distinct from God, there

were two Gods and Christianity was a form of ditheism, not monotheism.

On the other hand, if the filial relationship were literally interpreted, then

God the Father would be the progenitor of God the Son. But the logic of

this relationship meant that Christ would not be fully God, since there

must have been a time when he ‘was not’ and God the Father alone existed.‘

Orthodox Christians held Christ** to be identical in being (homousi- nous) to God the Father, while Arius (c. 256-336) considered him only similar in being (homoiousios) to Him. Then there was the question of his mother. Nestorious (died c. 45 1) declared that Jesus** was two distinct persons, one human, one divine; and that Mary* was the mother only of the human, not the divine Christ®*. It would be better, therefore, to call her the mother of Christ*’. The orthodox doctrine is that Mary’ is the true mother, not of the Godhead itself, but of the incarnate legos, or Word of God, containing both the divine and the human natures of Christ*>

The first ecumenical Council of the Church met in 325 in Bithynian Nicea and issued a creed on the mystery of the Trinity. The unrepentant Arius was anathamatised by the council and exiled by Emperor Con- stantine. The emperor also ordered that all Arius’s books should be burned and their possession should be punished by death.

The cycle of religious liberty which began with Jesus of Nazareth* came full circle when Justinian (483-565) prescribed the death penalty for apostasy. The penalty became part of the codification of Roman law in ADS35. :

It is a tragic twist of fate that freedom of conscience was snuffed out by the very Roman Christians whose newly converted forefathers were burned to provide fire and fun in Nero’s Rome (AD64). As long as Christians were persecuted by non-Christian political authorities, Chris- tian writers defended religious liberty. But once the imperial throne was won over to Christianity, the Church looked ‘with the same hostile eye upon individualism in belief as the state upon secession or revolt’.® By the middle of the fifth century things that were and still are God’s were rendered unto Caesar. Political authority had become the right arm of the Church. In the course of his campaign against the Donatists, St Augustine (354-430) argued: ‘There is a righteous persecution which the Church of Christ inflicts upon the impious. She persecutes in the spirit of love. . . that she may correct . . . that she may recall from error. . . [taking] measures for their good, to secure their eternal salvation.”

In 385 a Spanish bishop, Priscillian, was accused of preaching Manicheism and universal celibacy. He denied the charge, but was tried, condemned and burned at the stake with several companions.

Martin Luther (1483-1546), the German leader of the Protestant Reformation, concurred with his Roman Catholic predecessor, Au- gustine, and said: ‘The clergy had authority over conscience, but it was thought necessary that they should be supported by the State with absolute penalties of outlawry, in order that error might be exterminated, although it was impossible to banish sin.”

But it was the French Protestant theologican John Calvin (1509-64) who really inspired Maulana Maududi.

He [Calvin] wished to extend religion by the sword and reserve death as

the punishment of apostasy. . . . Catholics should suffer the same

penalties as those who were guilty of sedition, on the grounds that the

majesty of God must be as strictly avenged as the throne of the king?

While the inspiration came to the Maulana from Calvin, the rationale was provided by the English thinker Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) in his book, Leviathan. Since the power to work miracles is one of the signs of a true prophet, and, according to Hobbes, the days of miracles were over, there was no possibility of guidance by a prophet or through divine inspiration. The sovereign alone had civil or religious authority. He alone had the power to make law, ‘For whosoever hath a lawful power over any writing, to make it law, hath the power also to approve or disapprove the interpretation of the same.”°

10 von 10 heute frei