Chapter 5: The Maududian Law of Apostasy

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 2

Heresy, in Hobbes’s view, was private judgement and action contrary to popular belief as laid down by the sovereign:

It is not the intrinsic error of the judgment that makes the heresy punish-

able, but the private rebellion against authority. To make loyalty tothe

commands of conscience the ruling principle would sanction all private men to disobey their princes in maintenance of their religion, true or false."!

According to Hobbes, this is subversion.

There is no apostasy without heresy and no heresy without dogma. The Christian dogma was carefully spelled out in the Athanasian Creed, which says: ‘That we worship one God in Trinity, and Trinity in Unity; Neither confounding the Persons: nor dividing the Sub- stance.’

Itisin this tradition of medieval Christianity, and not of Islam, that Maulana Maududi developed the original ideals of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and the Khairi brothers’ Hukumat-i-Iahiyya (Kingdom of God).'* St Augustine, Martin Luther, John Calvin and Thomas Hobhes provided him with the non-Islamic concepts of orthodoxy, dogma and heresy - and also with the rhetoric of intolerance.

Even the orientalists, who never miss an opportunity of criticising Islam, agree there is no dogma and heresy in Islam. Goldziher says:

The role of dogma in Islam cannot be compared to that which it plays in

religious life of any of the Christian Churches. There are no Councils and

Synods which, after lively controversy, lay down the formulae, which

henceforth shall be deemed to embrace the whole of the true faith. There

is no ecclesiastical institution, which serves as the measure of orthodoxy;

no single authorised interpretation of the holy scriptures, on which the

doctrine and exegesis of the church might be built. The Consensus, the

supreme authority in all questions of religious practice, exercises an elastic, in a certain sense barely definable jurisdiction, the very concep- tion of which is moreover variously explained. Particularly in unanimity what shall have effect as undisputed Consensus. What is accepted as

Consensus by one party, is far from being accepted as such by another.!?

The contemporary Jewish orientalist, Berard Lewis, who would never be accused of being pro-Muslim, observes:

What matters was what people did - orthopraxy, rather than orthodoxy -

and Muslims were allowed on the whole to believe as they chose to do,

so long as they accepted the basic minimum, the Unity of God and the

apostolate of Muhammad, and conformed to the social norms.’

True Islam had ceased to be the inspiring force for Maulana Maududi. Having introduced the concepts of heresy and apostasy he could not escape from Calvin’s logic which prescribed ‘death as the punishment of apostasy’. But the Maulana had the audacity falsely to attribute the authority for this punishment to the Holy Prophet. The Maulana wrote a pamphlet on the subject in which he confidently quoted Abu Bakr’s military action against the rebel tribes as a proof that there was a death penalty for apostasy. Before discussing this, one ought to quote the Maulana’s writings to show how heavily he was influenced by his Christian models.

But first, in summary, to the Christian fathers of medieval Europe, recantation from Christianity was punishable by death and the only acceptable definition of Christianity was theirs. Similarly, the punish- ment for recantation from Islam was death and the only definition of Islam was the one the Maulana or his successors laid down. It is clear that under a Maududian government, the Maududian ruler would decide who was and who was not a Muslim. What would that decision be? The Maulana’s writings are quite clear.

According to Maududi, Ahmadis are apostates and a ‘non-Muslim minority’. But Ahmadis are not the only heretics - the Ahl-i-Quran, the followers of Mr Parvez’s school of thought, are also heretics. They are kafir and apostates. In fact, their heresy is far more serious than that of the Qadiyanis. The following order of banishment given by Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi, who had not yet renounced the Maududian teaching - and was still considered the right-hand man of Maududi - was published in the Tasnim, the official organ of the Jamaati Islami:

Some people advise that since there is no possibility of the promulga-

tion of the Islamic Sharia, the government of this country [Pakistan]

should be formed on the principles laid down in the Holy Qur’an. If, by this, these people mean that the Sharia is confined only to the Holy Qur’an and that other rules are not Sharia, then it is clearly heresy. This heresy is similar to that of the Qadiyanis, in fact, much more serious.'> This verdict is clearly against the Ahmadis and the Ahl-i-Quran. To discover whether ‘heresy’ and consequent apostasy is confined to only these two groups needs a closer look.

According to Maulana Maududi’s writings, anything not Maududian is heresy. The Maududian teachings are like the Athanasian Creed and any deviation from them is kufr. The Maulana says:

Ninety-nine point nine per cent of the Muslim nation has no knowl-

·

10 of 10 left today