Chapter 5: The Maududian Law of Apostasy

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 4

number of born hypocrites in Muslim society. There are two answers

to this question, one deals with the practical aspect, the other with the

principle. In principle there can be no distinction between the born

followers of a religion and that religion’s converts. And no religion has ever made that distinction. Both converts and born followers are governed by the same laws. It is both impossible and a logical absurdity to treat the children of the followers of a religion as kufar

or aliens till they are adults, then give them the choice of choosing or

rejecting the religion (or citizenship, for that matter) of their birth. No

sociciy in the world could manage its affairs in this way.”

Even if we accept the Maududian law that Islam prescribes death for apostasy and that all Muslims except Jamaati Islami are kafir, we cannot treat non-Maududian Muslims as apostates - even according to the Maulana’s own logic. They are ‘born kafir’. The Maulana wants to have his cake and eat it too! Muslims who disagree with the Maududian concept of Islam are first described as both ‘born Mus- lims’ and kafir, because they were brought up by their parents in a kafirana environment. Then they are called apostates because on reaching the age of consent they did not reiect their parents’ Islam in preference to Maududian Islam. A non-Muslim who joins Islam and then recants should be executed because he became Muslim knowing full well there was no escape. Similarly, a non-Maududian-born Muslim should also be treated as an apostate because he did not accept Maulana Maududi’s version of Islam on reaching adulthood. This is the argument which clearly shows the Maulana’s dictatorial, manipulative and intolerant personality. No Muslim, convert or born, is out of his reach. The ordinance in the Holy Qur’an that ‘there shall be no compulsion in religion’ is explained away in the following words:

This means we do not compel anyone to embrace our religion. This is

true. But we must warn anyone who wishes to recant that this door is

impassable to free traffic. If you wish to come, do so with the firm decision that you cannot escape.

A leading scholar of the Ahl-i Qur’an, Ghulam Ahmad Parvez, refer- fing to this Maududian commentary on the verse in the Holy Qur’an, said ‘Maududi Sahib’s Islam is a mouse-trap: the mouse can get into it, but cannot escape.

The central point of the Maulana’s argument is that every religion considers the descendants of its followers as its followers. Therefore, descendants of Muslim parents - even where the parents are practically kafir - will be Islamic property. If a right of ownership has been established over these children, how can they be free to choose another religion on reaching adulthood? In explaining this point, the Maulana seems to have overlooked the following saying of the Prophet® ‘Every infant has an in-born predisposition to be a Muslim, but his parents make him a Jew or a Christian or a Zoroastrian.”? If the central point of the Maulana’s argument is correct, then why confine it to the descendants of Muslims? Why not apply it to those of non-Muslims too, since they, according to the hadith, were also born with a ‘predisposition to be Muslim’? This would give full control of every non-Muslim child to the Maududian government. It makes no difference whether a child is within the Maududian realm or not. While the Maulana seems to have over- looked that hadith quoted above, the force of his logic leads him to this absurdity.

Maulana Maududi has, in fact, reproduced medieval Christianity almost word for word in the Jamaati Islami movement. Commenting on his policy of intolerance, Elisabeth Labrousse, an historian of medieval Christianity, observes: ‘On the individual level, it creates only martyrs or hypocrites.”* Now compare Labrousse’s observation with the following passage from Maududi’s The Punishment of Apostasy in Islam: ‘If he [the apostate] is really so honest in not wishing to live as a hypocrite and really does wish to remain steadfast in his own faith, why does he not present himself for death?”>

Since the Maududian concept of religion is the only way to salvation, the Maulana would not allow the same rights and privileges to the followers of any other religion. The missionary work of other religions would be forbidden in a Maududian state. The Maulana says:

The execution of apostates has already decided the issue. Since we do not

allow any Muslim to embrace any other religion, the question of allowing

other religions to open their missions and propagate their faiths within

our boundaries does not arise. We cannot tolerate it.

But can a kafir propagate his religion among other kafirs? For instance, can a Christian open missions to work among Jews or Hindus? Could Arya Samajists, who do not believe in idol worship and believe in one God, preach to the followers of pantheist Sanatan Dharma? The Maulana says:

Islam can never tolerate that false religions should spread in the

world. How can the missionaries of false religions be given a licence

to spread falsehood and attract others to the fire towards which they

themselves are advancing??”

Maududi himself accepts that Jews and Christians are Ahl-i Kitab (people of the Book). But if they wish to convert idol worshippers, fire worshippers or polytheists to the worship of one God - the God of Moses* and Jesus* - thus bringing them nearer to Islam, they would be forbidden.

In short, the Maulana concedes only that a born kafir cannot be kiiled ifhe does not accept Islam. Butif this is so, why kill a new kafir who has recanted? If a new Kafiris to be punished at all, why the death penalty? Why notexile, or life imprisonment, so that Muslim society may not be disrupted? Here Maulana Maududi, true to St Augustinian logic, explains that the apostate is executed in his own interests. He says:

There are only two methods of dealing with an apostate. Either make him

an outlaw by depriving him of his citizenship and allowing him mere

existence, or end his life. The first method is definitely more severe than

the second, because he exists in a state in which ‘he neither lives nor

dies’ Killing him is preferable. That way both his agony and the agony

of society are ended simultaneously.”

But the punishment to which the Maulana is sentencing apostates is not actually St Augustine’s ‘spirit of love’ persecution. There is a life after death and by killing an apostate, the Maulana is directly consigning him to the fires of hell. By saving an apostate from the temporary agonies of an outcast’s life, the Maulana is sending him to the far greater agonies of hell. Above all, the Maulana is depriving the tragic apostate of the opportunity of repentance and therefore salvation. While a kafir has the opportunity of repenting at any stage in his life, the apostate cannot return to Islam and benefit from the compassion of the Great Forgiver (Al- Ghaffar) and the Acceptor of Repentance (Al-Tawwab).

·

10 of 10 left today