Chapter 5: The Maududian Law of Apostasy

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3

edge of Islam or the ability to tell right from wrong. They have

directed neither their moral values nor their thoughts towards Islam.

A Muslim is a Muslim because his father was a Muslim and the faith

is passed from generation to generation. These Muslims have not

accepted this right because they believe it to be right, and neither have

they rejected the wrong because they know it to be wrong. If Muslim affairs are ever handed over to these people and anyone thinks Muslim affairs will be properly run, he’s living in fool’s paradise.'®

He continues:

The process of democratic elections is like churning milk to obtain

butter. If poisoned milk is churned, the butter will be poisonous too. So

people who think that the Kingdom of God [Hukumat-i-Iahiyya] will automatically result if Muslim areas are liberated from the Hindu majority, are wrong. They will end up with a heretic government of

Muslims (Kafirana hukumat].!”

The Maulana is more explicit in the following passage of the same book:

The nation called Musulman is made up of all kinds of rubbish. All types

of characters found among unbelievers are found here. The number of

liars appearing in law courts is no less than in the courts of other nations.

Bribery, theft, adultery, falsehood, in short, there is no form of moral

depravity in which they are second to the unbelievers. [kuffar].'*

These Maududian edicts and injunctions are very comprehensive. However, some may still doubt that these injunctions refer to the ordinary 99.99 per cent of Muslims and that Muslim leadership and intellectuals are exempt from these constraints. But the Maulana made another statement about Muslim leaders and uwiema to maxe it clear that any Muslim who does not accept the Maududian creed has gone astray. The Maulana says:

Western educated political leaders, ulema, and the scholars of Muslim

jurisprudence, all these leaders are as misguided as each other, bothin

their means and their ends. They have lost the path of truth and have wandered blindly into the darkness. Not one of them has a Muslim point

of view.!?

So, according to the Maulana, neither the 99.99 per cent of Muslims nor their religious or secular leaders are on the right path. They have gone astray, their point of view is not Muslim, and all types of criminals found among the kuffar are also found among Muslims. If one were to have dubbed the umma a ‘bunch of apostates’ on hearing this description, Maududi would have replied: ‘You said it.’ He was not in the habit of mincing his words. Referring to those who quit the Jamaati Islami, he said: ‘This is not the path on which to retreat. To retreat means to apostasise.””° If quitting the Jamaati Islami and joining another Muslim group is apostasy, then that other organisation is automatically kafir. So are Muslims who pray for favours at saints’ tombs and also the Shiites, who consider the first three caliphs to be usurpers. It is well known that according to the Maulana - and all the ulema of Deoband agree with him - the mainstream Ahli Sunnat wal Jamaat of India ard Pakistan, known as Brelvis, are kafir.

Whenever the death penalty for apostasy is enforced in a new Islamic

state, then Muslims are kept within Islam’s fold. But there is a danger that

a large number of hypocrites will live alongside them. They will always

pose a danger of treason.

My solution to the problem is this. That whenever an Islamic revo- lution takes place, all non-practising Muslims should, within one year, declare their turning away from Islam and get out of Muslim society. After one year all born Muslims will be considered Muslim. All Islamic laws will be enforced upon them. They will be forced to practice all the fara id and wajibat of their religion and, if anyone then wishes to leave Islam, he will be executed. Every effort will be made to save as many people as possible from falling into the lap of kufr. But those who cannot be saved will be reluctantly separated from society forever [executed]. After this purification Islamic society will start afresh with Muslims who have decided voluntarily to remain Muslims.”"

The Maulana does not tell us under what rules of jihad a law laying down the death penalty for apostasy will be relaxed. In any case this law will be relaxed only at the time an Islamic state is established - a one-off concession. After this period of grace, Muslims who are born kafirs will lose out. The Maulana explains why he is unable to make any exception for these unfortunates. He says:

There is one final question about capital punishment which may

disturb many of us. A non-Muslim who freely embraced Islam then

returned to kufr can be*said to have made a deliberate mistake. He could have remained a dhimmi, so why enter a religion of collective responsibility from which there is no escape? But what of the person

who was born of Muslim parents and who has not embraced Islam?

He is a Muslim by birth. If, on reaching adulthood, he wants to reject

the faith, you threaten him with execution and he remains Muslim; this

would be unjust. And it also provides sustenance to the ever-growing

·

10 of 10 left today