Chapter 6: Recantation

Murder in the Name of Allah

RECANTATION

Write down for me the name of everyone who calls himself. a Muslim. Muhammad*

The concept of apostasy, as it existed in medieval Christianity and as expounded by Maulana Maududi, is alien to Islam. There is not even a word for it in the Arabic language. There is no doubt that some early Muslim scholars of law considered recantation from Islam to be a capital offence, but their definition of ‘Muslim’ was so broad that no one calling himself a Muslim could be called a recanter. The Prophet* gave us two definitions of a Muslim. At the time of the first census of Medina, the Prophet* said: “Write down for me the name of everyone who calls himself a Muslim.” On another occasion the Prophet said: ‘Whoever prays as we pray and turns to our Qiblah and eats what we ritually slaughter is a Muslim; he is dhimmar-Allah and dhimmat al-rasul. So do not put Allah in contravention of his dhimmah [responsibility].

But Maulana Maududi and the ulema, supporting dictatorships and autocracies in Muslim countries, have added various qualifications to the Prophet’s* simple definition. In the words of Al-Ghazali (450-505 AH/ AD1058-1113) they have limited: ‘The vast Mercy of God to make paradise the preserve of a small clique of theologians.® The result of their effort has been summed up by the former chief justice of Pakistan, Muhammad Munir, who presided over the Court of Inquiry into the Punjab (Pakistan) Disturbances in 1953. He said:

Keeping in view the several definitions given by the ulema, need we

make any comment except that no two learned divines are agreed on

this fundamental? If we attempt our own definition, as each learned

divine has, and that definition differs from all others, we all leave

Islam’s fold. If we adopt the definition given by any one of the ulema,

we remain Muslims according to the view of that alim, but kafirs

according to everyone else’s definition.‘

Justice Munir’s observation must be read with reference to the Prophet’s* reprimand to Usama b. Zayd. In the raid of Ghalib b. Abdullah al-Kalbi, according to Ibn Ishaq, a man was killed by Usama b. Zayd and another. Reporting this incident, Usama b. Zayd said:

When I and a man of Ansar overtook him and attacked him with our

weapons he pronounced the Shahadah, but we did not stay our hands and

killed him. When we came to the Prophet* and told him what had happened, he said: ‘Who will absolve you, Usama, from ignoring the confession of faith?’ I told him that the man had pronounced the words merely to escape death, but he repeated his question and continued to do

so until ] wished that I had never been a Muslim before that day and that

Thad never killed the man. I asked him to forgive me and promised that

I would never kill aman who pronounced the Shahadah. The Prophet

said: ‘You will say it after me (after my death), Usama?’ and I said that

I would.

The Prophet knew that despite his concern for the lives of Sha- hadah-pronouncing Muslims, they would still be killed by misguided people under Islam’s name. According to the report in the Musnad Imam Ahmad Hanbal, the Prophet® also asked Osama whether he had opened his victim’s heart to check the authenticity of his faith.6 And yet the power-hungry and politically orientated ulema continue to incite igno- rant Muslims to kill their Muslim brothers - Muslims whose viewpoint differed slightly from their own - as if, on opening their hearts, they had discovered the faith of such Muslims was false.

Regarding recantation, the Holy Qur’an uses the word irtadda, which means that no one has the right to declare any other Muslim murtadd. As Imam Raghib Isfahani’ explains, the word irtidad means to retrace one’s steps back to the point from where one came. The word is especially associated with recantation - returning to kufr (disbelief) from Islam, e.g. ‘Lo! Those who tum their backs after the guidance hath been manifested unto them’; (47.26) and ‘whoso of you becometh renegade from his religion’. (5.55)

The Holy Qur’an has used the word ‘ridda’ in the intransitive measure (i.e. iftial) which means that everyone has an option but no- one has been given the right to declare another an apostate. It is a voluntary action and no outside agency can play any part init. Itis this aspect of free will which distinguishes irtidad from the Christian and Maududian concept of apostasy, which we discussed in the last chapter. Apostasy and its punishment requires an external authority, the church or state. It is like execution or, rather, murder. Irtidadis like suicide. One can execute or murder, but no one can ‘suicide’ someone.

Surah Al-Kafirun, revealed in the early pericd of the Prophet’s® ministry, is a direct statement of policy on the subject of freedom of conscience. The Prophet was asked to tell unbelievers there was absolutely no meeting-point between their way of life and his. As they were in complete disagreement, not only with regard to the basic concepts of religion, but also with regard to its details and other aspects, there could not possibly be any compromise between them. Hence, ‘For you, your religion, for me, my religion’. (109.7)

The Prophet was also repeatedly told not to worry if unbelievers were not ready to accept his message. He was not their wakil (guardian). God says: ‘Thy people have rejected the message that We have sent through thee, though it is the truth. Say: “I am not appointed a wakil over you.”* This statement was made in the Meccan period, when the Prophet* and his followers were persecuted. Yet on his arrival in Medina, the statement was exactly the same, even though he now had power. It was, in fact, made even more explicit.

The first Medinite surah in which the subject of freedom of con- science was discussed was Al-Bagarah. The 257th verse of the surah contains the clearest pronouncement on the subject:

There shall be no compulsion in religion. Surely guidance has become

10 von 10 heute frei