Chapter 6: Recantation

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 2

distinct from error, whosoever refuses to be led by those who transgress

and believes in Allah has surely grasped a strong handle which knows no

breaking. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing. This is the confident declaration of a prophet who has organised an wnma in a town where his power is supreme. Lest the subject of jihad be misunderstood, Muslims are told that true virtue lies in good works and good faith (255-258) and the Majesty of God is called to mind in the Throne verse (256). The commandment of ‘no compulsion in reli- gion’ comes immediately after the Throne verse. Readers of the Holy Qur’an might have thought God wanted Muslims to spread Islam by force, because of its call to fight the umma’s enemies and to offer special sacrifices to Allah. So the verse tells Muslims in no uncertain terms not to resort to violence in the name of conversion. The importance of this verse can be gauged from a hadith quoted in Jami of Tirmidhi. He said that the peak of the Holy Qur’an is Al-Bagarah and that Satan shall not enter the house of anyone who recites ten verses of this chapter (i.e. the first four verses, the Throne verse, the two verses which follow it - 257-258 - and the last three verses).

This principle of no compulsion was reiterated after the victory of Badr (3.21) and again in Al-Ma ‘idah, which is the last revealed surah. Now that Muhammad’s® authority was fully established, not only in Medina but also in Mecca, it was vital to emphasise that the Prophet’s* only role was to convey the word of Allah. ‘Obey Allah and obey the Messenger, and be on your guard, but if you turn away, then remember that the duty of our Messenger is only to convey the message clearly.’ (5.93) And finally: ‘The Messenger’s duty is only to convey the message. And Allah knows what you reveal and what you hide.’ (5.100) Religious belief is a personal matter. It is God alone - not the state or the religious authorities - who knows what one reveals to God or what one hides.

This verse leads to the subject of munafiqun - the hypocrites. The term munafiqun describes those inhabitants of Medina who had outwardly accepted Islam, but whose belief was suspect for various reasons. There are many references to them in the Holy Qur’an, but in four passages they are defined as murtadd (recanters). The first reference is in Surah Muham- mad. This is a Medinite surah which briefly describes the aims of war according to Islam. It says that while believers welcome a revelation calling on them to fight for Allah, munafiqun feel as if they are being led to their slaughter. In this way, true believers are separated from those whose faith is shallow or false. It goes on to say:

Surely those who turn their backs [artaddu] after guidance has become

manifest to them, Satan has seduced them, and holds out false hopes to

them. That is because they said to those who hate what Allah has revealed, ‘We will obey you in some matters’ and Allah knows their

secrets. (47:26-27)

The verses quoted above mention no punishment for these people.

The next reference to the munafiqun is in the Surah Al-Munafiqun, which was revealed towards the end of 6AH/AD628. The surah exposes the infidelity and dishonesty of the munafiqun and condemns their open profession of faith as false and treacherous. This was a public reprimand:

Allah bears witness that the munafiqun are liars. Their faith is a pretext

so that they may turn people away from the way of Allah. Evil is that

which they practice. That is because they believed and thereafter disbe-

lieved; so a seal was set upon their hearts and they have no understanding.

... They are the enemy, so beware! .. . it is the same for them whether

thou ask for forgiveness for them or not. Allah will never forgive them,

surely Allah guides not a rebellious people. (63.2-7)

The last two references to the munafiqun are in one of the last revealed surahs, Al-Taubah: ‘Offer no excuse. You have certainly disbelieved after having believed. If We forgive a group of you, a group shall We punish, for they have been guilty.’ (9.66) Those to be forgiven are obviously such of the munafiqun who repented and became sincere Muslims. As regards those who are to be punished, one verse further down we read: ‘Allah promises the munafiqun - both men and women - and the disbelievers the fire of hell, wherein they shall abide. It will suffice them. And they shall have everlasting punishment.’ (9.68) And, finally:

They swear by Allah that they said nothing, but they did say the word

of disbelief and did disbelieve after they had embraced Islam. . . . So if

they repent, it will be better for them, but if they turn away, Allah will

punish them with a grievous punishment in this world and the hereafter. And they shall have neither friend nor helper in the earth.

(9.74)

The Prophet* knew that Abdullah b. Ubayy b. Salul was the leader of the munafiqun, but he took no action against him. On the contrary, the Prophet® prayed for him when he died. Umar b. al-Khattab is reported to have said:

When the Prophet* went and stood by the dead body of Abdullah b. Ubayy and was about to pray, I asked him: ‘Are you going to pray over God’s enemy?’ The Prophet® smiled and said: ‘Get behind me, Umar. I have been given a choice and | have chosen. It was said to me: ‘Ask pardon for them or ask it not. Even if you ask pardon for them seventy times God will not pardon them’ If I knew that by asking pardon more than seventy times he would be forgiven, I would do it.’ Then he prayed over him and walked with his dead body and stayed at his grave until he was buried.'°

Freedom of conversion is the acid test of ‘no compulsion in religion’. It cannot be a one-way freedom - the freedom to enter Islam, but not to leave it. There are ten direct references to recantation in the Holy Qur’an: one in the Meccan surah of Al-Nahland the remaining nine in the Medinite surahs. In none of these verses is there the slightest hint of capital punishment for those who recant.

One of the Holy Qur’an’s most explicit statements on recantation is the 143rd verse of Al-Bagarah. The Qiblah was changed from Jerusalem to Mecca in the second year of Hijrah. Ibn Ishaq reports:

And when the Qiblah was changed from Syria to the Kabah, Rifaa b.

·

10 of 10 left today