Chapter 6: Recantation

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 6

Muhammad Mahmud Taha was executed in the Sudan in 1985. He believed the Medinite part of the law in the Holy Qur’an was no longer applicable.

Significantly, the Ottoman sultan, though the head of a religious empire and caliph of all Muslims, did not order the execution of Baha Ullah (1817-92) for irtidad. Baha Ullah declared himself to be the Promised One, foretold by Bab,*? and founded Bahaism as a religion. Bahaism was and is totally different from Islam. It declares that the arrival of Baha Ullah makes the Holy Qur’an and the teachings of Muhammad - may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him - out of date. Baha Ullah was jailed in Akka (Acre) near Haifa, then in Palestine, now Israel. But when Sabbatai Zevi (1627-76), a Jewish mystic, proclaimed himself the Messiah in 1648, the Shaykh-ul-Islam of the Ottoman Empire ordered his execution. He was arrested, recanted from his claim simply to escape death, and embraced Islam. Baha Ullah claimed to be a new manifesta- tion of God and left Islam, but was not executed despite his apostasy because he was not a danger to law and order in the Ottoman Empire.

As we have already seen, the concept of apostasy is alien to Islam and there is no punishment in this world for recanting. But the ulema who appeared before the Court of Inquiry, constituted under the Punjab Act I of 1954 to enquire into the Punjab disturbances of 1953, asserted that ‘apostasy in an Islamic state is punishable by death’. They were:

Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyad Muhammad Ahmad Qadri, President,

Jamiat-ul-Ulamai-Pakistan, Punjab; Maulana Ahmad Ali, Sadr Jamiat-

ul-Ulama-e-Islam, West Pakistan; Maulana-Abul Ala Maududi, founder

and ex-Amir-i-Jamaati Islami, Pakistan; Mufti Muhammad Idris, Jami

Ashrafia, Lahore, and member, Jamiat-ul-Ulamai-Pakistan; Maulana

Daud Ghaznavi, President, Jamaati Ahl-i-Hadith, Maghribi Pakistan;

Maulana Abdul Haleem Qasimi, Jamiat-ul-Ulamai-Islam, Punjab; and

Mr Ibrahim Ali Chishti.*

Commenting on this assertion, the Court of Inquiry observed: According to this doctrine, Chaudhri Zafrullah Khan must be exe- cuted if he has not inherited his present religious beliefs, but has elected of his own free will to be an Ahmadi. And the same fate should befall Deobandis and Wahabis, (including Maulana Muhammad Shafi Deobandi, member, Board of Talimat-i-Islami attached to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan, and Maulana Daud Ghaznavi) if any one of the ulema (shown perched on every leaf of a beautiful tree in the fatwa (Ex. D.E. 14) were the head of such an Islamic state. And if Maulana Muhammad Shafi Deobandi were the head of the state, he would exclude those who have been pronounced by Deobandis to be kafirs from Islam. He would then execute them, if they came within the definition of murtadd, namely, if they had changed and not inherited their religious views.

The genuineness of the fatwa (Ex. D.E. 13) by the Deobandis (which says that Ithnashri Shias are kafirs and murtadds) was ques- tioned in the course of our inquiry. But Maulana Muhammad Shafi examined the subject from Deoband and received from the records of that institution the copy of a fatwa signed by all the teachers of the Darul Ulloom, including Maulana Muhammad Shafi himself. The records say, in effect, that those who do not believe in the sahabiyyat of Hazrat Siddiq Akbar and who are qazif of Hazrat Aisha Siddiga and have been guilty of tehrif of the Holy Qur’an, are kafirs. This opinion is also shared by Mr Ibrahim Ali Ghishti who knows and has studied this subject. He thinks the Shias are kafirs because they believe that Hazrat Ali shared the prophethood with our Holy Prophets. He refused to answer the question of whether a Sunni who changed his views and agrees with the Shias is guilty of irtidad, thus deserving death. Accord- ing to the Shias, all Sunnis are kafirs and Anl-i-Quran - persons who consider hadith unreliable and therefore not binding - are also kafirs. So are all independent thinkers. The net result is that neither Shias nor Sunnis nor Deobandis nor Ahl-i-Hadith nor Brelvis are Muslims. And that, if the government of the state is run by a party which considers the other party to be kafirs, then any change from one view to another must result in the death penalty.

It does not take much imagination to judge the consequences of this doctrine when it is remembered that no two ulema have ever agreed before us on the correct definition of a Muslim. Indeed, if all their definitions are taken in total, the grounds on which soineone may be indicted for apostasy would be too numerous even to count.

10 of 10 left today