Chapter 6: Recantation

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 5

Bernard Lewis makes it quite clear that Riddah ‘represents a distor- tion of the real significance of events by the theologically coloured outlook of later historians’. He goes on to say:

The refusal of the tribes to recognise the succession of Abu Bakr was, in

effect, not a relapse by converted Muslims to their previous paganism,

but the simple and automatic termination of a political contract by the death of one of the parties. The tribes nearest to Medina had in fact been converted and their interests were so closely identified with those of the umma that their separate history has not been recorded. For the rest, the death of Muhammad automatically severed their bonds with Medina, and the parties resumed their liberty of action. They felt in no way bound

by the election of Abu Bakr in which they had taken no part, and at once

suspended both tribute and treaty relations. In order to re-establish the

hegemony of Medina, Abu Bakr had to make new treaties.

Ali was assassinated in 661. With him went the concept of a Muslim ruler who combined the functions of head of state and of religion. The dynastic reign of the Ummayyads (661-750), the political rulers of Islam, began with Muawiyah. They had none of the religious outlook of the pious caliphs and were regarded more or less as secular kings. As guardians of the sharia the ulema came to occupy a position comparable in many ways to that of the clergy after the conversion of Constantine. Like the clergy in medieval Europe, they were respected for learning and piety and their support was sought to legalise the political power of a despot or unpopular ruler. They also acted as the leaders of the opposition and tried to influence political power rather than assume it themselves.

Political and social revolts were now justified in religious terms and dynastic struggles over political power soon hardened into deep rifts in religious doctrine. Kharijism and Shiism, the two main movements that split off from the main body after the assassination of the third caliph, Uthman (644), originated during a struggle for succession. Kharijites were the first Muslims to suggest that a grave sinner no longer remained Muslim. They were also the first to proclaim jihad against Muslims who, according to them, were not true believers, and originally belonged to Ali’s party; they left him, however, over a disagreement about arbitration between him and Muawiyah, intended to settle their differences arising out of Uthman’s murder. They said: ‘judgement belongs to Allah alone’ and not to human tribunals. Kharijites were key figures in the develop- ment of dogma. They were particular about a Muslim’s qualifications and his attitude towards his fellow men, Muslim or non-Muslim. This group was the first distinct sect to appear in Islam, and was also the first to reject the principle of justification by faith. They maintained that a grave sinner no longer remained a Muslim and could not re-enter the faith; instead, he should be killed with his family. They considered all non-Kharijites to be outlaws and non-Muslim. As we saw earlier, the Prophet* knew the munafiqun of Medina and their leader, Abdullah b. Ubayy, and yet he took no action against him. He did not judge the quality of a Muslim’s faith.

The Kharijites conflicted directly with the teaching of the Holy Qur’an and the sunnah of the Prophet®. Their declaration that ‘judgement belongs to Allah alone’ (la hukma illa lillah)® was in total contradiction to the sunnah. The Prophet™ appointed Sad b. Muadh as hakam to decide the fate of the Jewish tribe of B. Qurayzah and his sentence was carried out.* Commenting on the Sahih Muslim report of Sad’s judgement, Al- Nawawi (d. AH127/AD676) said: ‘In their disputes Muslims are al- lowed to resort to tahkim’>* In fact, if two Muslim groups are at war, it is the duty of other Muslims to make peace between them. The Holy Qur’an says: ‘All believers are brothers, so make peace between brothers, and be mindful of your duty to Allah that you may be shown mercy.’ (49.11) Declaring Muslims to be ‘disbelievers’ and then pun- ishing them just because their standards are different from the standards of a certain religious authority - takfir - is alien to Islam. The

Prophet himself defined a Muslim as one who declares faith in the Unity of Allah and the prophethood of Muhammad™.** This is the only definition by which a Muslim can be judged. Discussing the subject of takfir, Bernard Lewis says:

Even open rebellion did not automatically involve takfir. In 923 the

chief Qadi ibn Buhal refused to denounce the Carmathian rebels as

unbelievers since they began their letters with invocations to God and

the Prophet and were therefore, on the face of it, Muslims. The Shafi’i

law insists that the sectarian, even in revolt, is entitled to be treated as

a Muslim; that is to say, his family and property are respected, and that

he cannot be summarily despatched or sold into slavery once he

becomes a prisoner.>”

Takfir® was, however, founded by jurists. As we saw earlier, it was a Kharijite excuse for denouncing Ali. But having adopted this Kharijite innovation, the jurists could not arrive at an agreed defini- tion of a Muslim.

To comb 1300 years of Islamic history to find the number of Muslims executed because of their conversion from Islam would prove futile. There were unsuccessful attempts to execute Maimonides in Cairo,® the Maronite Amir Yunis in Lebanon,” and to persecute Rashid-ud-Din in Tabriz," but such instances were very rare. In Mughal India, there is only one recorded case. A Portuguese friar had embraced Islam and then reverted to his former faith. He was executed at Aurangabad.” The reasons for his execution were political, not religious. The friar was under strong suspicion of spying for the Portuguese under the cover of Islam.

Jadd ibn Dirham was put to death on the orders of Hisham b. Abd al- Malik in Kufa or Wasit in 124 or 125AH/AD746 or 747. He was accused of having advanced the Mutazili doctrines of the created Qur’an and of freewill. In 167 or 168AH/AD788 the Iraqi poet Bashir b. Burd was accused of zandagah, beaten and thrown into a swamp in Batiha. Al- Husain b. Mansur al-Hallaj was executed in 309AH/AD930 for blas- phemy because he claimed to have substantial union with God (hulul). Shihab-ul-Din Yahya al-Suhrawardi was put to death on the orders of Al-Malik al-Zahir (578AH/AD1199). His crime was to regard all that lives, moves or has its being as truth and he even based his proof of God upon the symbol of light.

The seventeenth-century martyr was Muhammad Said Sarmad. Born of Jewish parents at Kashan, Sarmad was a rabbi before embracing Islam. A great Persian poet, he was a monist and denied the existence of matter. He was executed in the reign of Aurangzib (reigned 1658- 1707). His mazar (tomb) which is opposite the Jami Masjid in Delhi, attracts daily hundreds of Muslims, offering flowers and Fatihah.

In Afghanistan, two Ahmadis were executed for accepting the claim of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad* of Qadian to be the Promised Messiah: Sahibzadah Abdul Latif, who performed the coronation ceremony of Amir Habib Ullah Khan, was stoned to death in 1903 and Maulwi Nimat Ullah in 1924. Both were given the chance of renouncing the claims of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad*, but they refused.

·

10 of 10 left today