Chapter 7: Punishment For Apostasy

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3

Worthy that you should fear Him, if you are believers.

14. Fight them: Allah will punish them at your hands, and will humiliate

them, and will help you to overcome them, and will relieve the minds of

the believers of fear and distress. Those who deduce from verses 12 and 13 that the punishment for apostasy is death offer no explanation of the contradiction this creates with numerous other verses. These verses relate to the period after the migration from Mecca to Medina (see verse 3) when the Quraish of Mecca had embarked upon hostilities to wipe out Islam by force.

The advocates of capital punishment for apostasy should remember that these verses refer to idolaters who have broken their pledges and ridicule religion; there is no mention of people renouncing their faith. They have broken their pledge after their firm commitment to it. Those who have become hostile to your religion are the first to initiate hostilities against you. The permission for you to fight them is restricted to their leaders whose covenants are worthless and false. The permission is given in order to stop them from entering into hostile acts against you.

This is the true meaning of these verses which have been miscon- strued by the advocates of capital punishment. There is not even the remotest reference to people who renounce their faith being forced to become Muslims. The same people are discussed in another part of the Holy Qur’an: .

It may be that Allah will bring about amity between you and those with

whom you are at enmity. Allah has the power; Allah is Most Forgiving,

Ever Merciful. Allah does not forbid you to be kind and act equitably

towards those who have not fought you because of your religion, and

who have not driven you forth from your homes. Surely Allah loves those who are equitable. Allah only forbids you that you make friends with those who have fought against you because of your religion and have driven you out of your homes and have aided others in driving you out. Whoso makes friends with them, those are the transgressors. (60.8-10)

Temporary disbelief

Another verse of the Holy Qur’an states: A section of the people of the Book urge some from among themselves: why not affirm, in the early part of the day, belief in that which has been revealed unto the believers and repudiate it in the latter part of the day, perchance they may turn away from their faith. (3.73)

The people of the Book mentioned in this verse are the Jews of Medina.

Theirs was a Jewish tactic to create doubt among the Muslims in the hope that some of them might thereby by beguiled into repudiating Islam. How could it be possible for the Jews to have enacted this plan if death was a penalty for apostasy? Had anyone been executed for commiting this crime, that would have been a deterrent for others who would not follow in their footsteps.

The advocates of the death penalty urge that this verse merely refers to a Jewish philosophy which was never put into practice by them. Even if it was merely a philosophy, this verse is conclusive proof of there being no punishmentin this world for apostasy because the Jews could never have conceived the idea had there been such a punishment. Moreover, it is wrong to say that the idea was a hypothetical case; the books of tradition mention that it was put into practice by twelve Jewish divines of Khaibar and Urainah.*(See also p.65)

All commentaries agree that this chapter of the Holy Qur’an was revealed between the victory of Mecca and the demise of the Holy Prophet*. This conclusively proves that the Jews put it into practice after Islam became firmly established in Arabia. How could the Jews ever think of sucha suicidal and insane strategy if death was prescribed asa punishment for apostasy? How could they encourage Muslims to follow their faith by affirming it during the day and repudiating it at the end of the day if they knew that the Muslims would be executed for changing their faith?

Traditions The advocates of capital punishment for apostasy misconstrue out of all proportion the traditions narrated about the Holy Prophet®. Traditions lend no support to their thesis. On the contrary, there are many traditions which clearly show that there is no punishment for apostasy in this life. However, for the sake of completeness, we set out those traditions which are most often cited by advocates of capital punishment for apostasy. a) Abu Qalabah reports on the authority of Anas that the Holy Prophet* told the people of Akal or Uraynah to go and stay among his she-camels outside Medina. These people killed the keeper of the camels and ran away with the herd. Although it is true that these people had become apostates, their punishment was not a result of their apostasy but of their murder of the keeper of the she-camels. (See also page 34.) b) Whereas Ibn Khatal, who was without doubt one of the four executed on the fall of Mecca, was an apostate, he had also committed the crime of murdering his travelling companion. His execution was, therefore, obviously ordered as a result of his having been convicted as a murderer. (See also page 66.)

c) Another incident is that of Magees b. Sababah who killed an Ansar in revenge for Hisham, his brother, who was accidentally killed during the campaign of Zeeqard. Thereafter, Maqees became an apostate. He was executed on account of the murder of the Ansar. (See also page 67.) Ineach one of the above incidents, the executed person had committed murder. The three people had also happened to renounce their faith, but how can anyone shut his eyes to the murders and attribute their executions to their acts of apostasy?

d) The advocates of capital punishment for apostasy rely heavily ona tradition which mentions the executior of a woman for apostasy. This tradition is most unreliable, to say the least. The truth of the matter is that the Holy Prophet* never ordered the execution of a woman on account of her apostasy. The well-known treatise of jurisprudence, Hedayah, sets out the following:

·

10 of 10 left today