Chapter 7: Punishment For Apostasy
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 4
The Holy Prophet® forbade the killing of women for apostasy, because
the principle of punitive regulations is that in such cases the penalty
should be left for the hereafter, as a penalty imposed in this life would
contravene the purpose of apostasy, being a trial calling to account what pertains to God alone. This can be departed from only when the object in view is to restrain the person concerned from continuing hostilities
(during times of war). As women, by their very nature, are not capable
of fighting, a woman apostate cannot be punished in any case.
Strangely enough, scholars like Maududi, who might be supposed to be fully aware of serious flaws in the reliability of these traditions, still adhere to weak traditions which have been rejected by most eminent Muslim scholars. e)The incident of Abdullah Bin Sad has already been quoted on page 66. Haa there been any penalty in the Holy Qur’an for apostasy, the Holy Prophet’s* words to the effect that no one is above the law would be a clear reminder of his strict observance of God’s laws. If death was the punishment for apostasy, how could the Holy Prophet™ disobey the commandments of God?
Companions
We have observed that neither the Holy Qur’an nor any reliable traditions of the Holy Prophet* lend any support to those who advocate capital punishment for apostasy. But those advocates have some other tricks up their sleeves. It is necessary to examine their remaining arguments at greater length. Those arguments are based on the opinions of the Companions of the Holy Prophet®, and not directly on his own personal judgement. Let it be known at the outset that observations or opinions of Companions® can only be a commentary; they have no right to be treated with as much respect as an injunction of the Holy Qur’an. At best they can only be regarded as an opinion.
a) The incident of the widespread apostasy in relation to the payment of zakathas been discussed (pages 69-72). The Abs and the Zubyan were the tribes which initiated hostilities by attacking Medina. Hazrat Abu Bakr fought them before the return of Osama from his expedition. The apostates were the aggressors. They not only refused to pay zakat, but also took up the sword against the Muslims. Thus they rebelled against the Islamic state, slaughtered the Muslims amongst them by burning some alive and mutilated those they had killed.? Those who advocate execution for apostasy on the authority of this incident are either ignorant of the facts or deliberately seek to mislead people by playing down the killing of innocent Muslims by the rebels.
b) The advocates then pose the question that if there was no punishment for apostasy, why was Musailmah the imposter not left alone? The truth is that Musailmah aspired to political power. He had accompanied Abu Hanifa and offered to the Holy Prophet* his submission subject to his being nominated as his successor. The Holy Prophet* told Musailmah that he would not yield him even a twig of a date palm tree. Musailmah retumed and claimed that half of Arabia belonged to him. He sent a letter to the Holy Prophet in which he claimed: ‘Ihave been appointed your partner in authority.’ The Holy Prophet® responded by quoting to him verse 129 of chapter 7 of the Holy Qur’an.‘ After Musailmah’s claim of prophethood, he captured Habeeb b. Zaid, a Companion of the Holy Prophet, dismembered him limb from limb, and then burned his re- mains. The advocates of capital punishment ignore this gruesome murder and claim that apostasy was the only crime attributable to Musailmah. Had he not commited murder, would ke have been killed for the crime of apostasy alone? Was he not brought to justice for the murder and for the mayhem and disorder which he created in the land? There is not the slightest shred of evidence that having heard of Musailmah’s rejection of his prophethood, the Holy Prophet* condemned Musailmah to death or exhorted any of his Companions to kill him. Having failed to find evidence of any specific condemnation by the Holy Prophet*, Maulana
Maududi had to seek recourse in a wish which the Holy Prophet* is said to have expressed during his dying moments, that Musailmah should be done away with. Had there been such a wish, it is impossible for us to believe that the Holy Prophet’s*® first successor, Hazrat Abu Bakr, would have ignored it and not sent an expedition in compliance with the wish of the Holy Prophet*. Why did Hazrat Abu Bakr wait until the time when Musailmah himself took the offensive and openly rebelled against the Muslims? We find that Musailmah mustered a force of 40,000 warriors of Banu Hanifa alone when he fought Khalid b. Walid. Musailmah initiated hostilities and moved against Medina. It was only then that Hazrat Abu Bakr gave orders to march against him on account of his rebellion and his gruesome murder of Habeeb bin Zaid.>
c) Another incident cited is that of Tulaiha, another pretender to pro- phethood. Again, he was not just a pretender but had murdered Ukasha b. Mohsin and Thabit b. Aqram Ansari. Before Khalid b. Walid com- menced battle with him, he sent an emissary to Tulaiha to agree peace terms and avoid bloodshed. The advocates of capital punishment over- look the fact that if there had been capital punishment for apostasy, there was no point in sending an emissary offering forgiveness to Tulaiha.® d) A similar case is that of Aswad Anasi who raised the standard of rebellion with his apostasy. He killed the Muslim governor of Yemen, ‘Shahr b. Bazan, forcibly married his widow and made himself ruler of Yemen. When the Holy Prophet* learned of his rebellion, he sent a letter to Muaz b. Jabal and the Muslims to oppose Aswad Anasi, who was subsequently killed in a skirmish with the Muslims. (News of his death arrived one day after the demise of the Holy Prophet*.)’
e) Similarly, Laqbeet b. Malik Azdi became an apostate and claimed to be a prophet. He expelled Jafar and Abad who had been appointed as functionaries in Oman.’ He, like all these claimants to prophethood, had no concern with religion. He had his own political axe to grind. His search for political domination was through open rebellion against the Islamic state he lived in, so the question of apostasy is irrelevant here. Let us suppose for a moment that all these people had not recanted their faith but had merely rebelled against the Muslim state. The state would have had to take the step of quelling the rebellion; for the crime of creating disorder in the land, the Holy Qur’an prescribes capital punishment. That punish- ment is not for apostasy.
f) The advocates of capital punishment for apostacy cite also the case of Umm Qarfah, a woman who became an apostate during the time of
Hazrat Abu Bakr. She had thirty sons whom she constantly exhorted to fight the Muslims. She paid the price for her treason and for her complicity in murder, not on account of her apostasy.”
g) The case of Hazrat Ali fighting the Khawarij is often cited. The Khawarij created disorder in the land, killed Muslim men and women, the governor appointed by Hazrat Ali, his female slave, and also Ali’s emissary.!° (This incident has been discussed on p.70.)
h) Reference needs to be made to the appointments of Muaz b. Jabal and Abu Musa Ashari, each as governor of a part of Yemen. As they were about to leave, the Holy Prophet* instructed them: ‘Make things easy for people and do not put them into difficulty. Talk to them cheerfully and not in a manner that might repel them’ One day Muaz came to meet Abu Musa Ashari and noticed a person sitting there who had been secured with a rope. When Muaz enquired about this he was told that that person was a Jew who had become a Muslim and then became an apostate. The narrator adds that for the past two to three months the Muslims had reasoned with him in order to persuade him to become a Muslim but to no avail. Muaz declared that he would not dismount until the person had been executed and observed that this was the judgement of God and His Messenger. This last remark indicates no more than his personal opinion of what he understood to be the Will of God and His prophet. Such opinions carry no weight in law unless they are completely substantiated by references which verify the claim. (This principle is elaborated subsequently in this chapter.)
Now let us examine the reliability of this tradition. Muaz’s remark contradicts the instruction of the Holy Prophet* to make things easy for people and not in a manner which might repel them. To place reliance on one tradition without investigating Muaz’s understanding of Islam on a key issue where human rights are involved is sheer absurdity.