Chapter 7: Punishment For Apostasy
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 5
Considerable doubt prevails regarding this tradition, the chain of narrators and their authenticity. Wherever such disputes arise, the tradi- tion is rejected outright. It should be remembered that these traditions were compiled some three to four centuries after the advent of Islam and that, over a passage of time, memories are prone to error. According to one tradition, the Jew was beheaded upon Muaz’sinstructions.'' In the second tradition, Muaz himself beheaded the Jew.'? When such funda- mental differences occur in a key incident, how can anyone accept the authenticity of these traditions? People may forget what someone said, but if they were eye-witnesses they would at least remember what ultimately happened to the ‘apostate’ in question.
Next we turn to a tradition which has obtained much attention because it is strongly emphasised and relied upon by the school advocat- ing capital punishment for apostacy. This has deliberately been deferred to the end of this chapter so that justice may be done to it without interfering with the general flow of the subject matter.
Before a detailed examination of this tradition, a few words concern- ing the application of certain principles accepted by Islamic scholars throughout the ages would not be out of place. These principles help to resolve controversies concerning the apparent contradiction between the Holy Qur’an and hadith (tradition) on the one hand and some traditions vis-a-vis other traditions.
1. The Word of God stands supreme.
2. This is followed by the actual practices of the Holy Prophet of
Islam*. This is known as sunnah.
3. This is followed by hadith, the words reported to be those of the
Holy Prophet*.
a) If the authenticity of the words of the Holy Prophet* is established unquestionably, the words concerned are words put into the mouth of the Holy Prophet* by God Almighty. Where there is no apparent contradic- tion between the word of the Holy Prophet® and the Holy Qur’an, the tradition may be accepted as authentic.
b) There are no two opinions regarding the accepted fact that whenever any so-called tradition attributed to the Holy Prophet of Islam® contra- dicts any clear injunction of the Holy Qur’an, such a tradition is rejected as false and is not accepted as the word of the Holy Prophet.
c) If such a tradition does not glaringly vioiate any injunction of the Holy Qur’an and there is room for compromise, then ideally an attempt should be made to search for a suitable compromise before the final rejection of the tradition.
d) In attempting to reconcile a tradition attributed to the Holy Prophet* with the Holy Qur’an, it must always be borne in mind that the clear teachings of the Holy Qur’an are not to be compromised for the sake of a so-called tradition, but a genuine attempt is to be made to find an explanation of the tradition. Therefore in all cases of doubt, the tradition is put to the anvil of the Holy Qur’an and judged accordingly. e)Ifthere is no contradiction between the Holy Qur’an and hadith, then their mutual merit of credibility would be determined according to the reliability of the sources and the chain of narrators.
f) Such a tradition will also be compared with other authentic and widely accepted traditions to make sure that the tradition does not conflict with other traditions. g) Lastly, another reliable method of investigating the credibility of a tradition is to study its internal evidence critically. If the contents of the tradition clash with the image of the Holy Prophet of Islam which has emerged from a study of his conduct and bearing throughout his life, then such a tradition would be rejected as a false attribution to the Holy Prophet* or as being against the principles of logic and common sense. In the light of the above principles, let us examine"? the tradition in question.
Tradition
It is recorded in Bukhari that: Ikramah relates that he heard that some Zindeegs were presented before Hazrat Ali whereupon he directed the burning alive of these people. Ibn Abbas stated that had it been him, he would not have ordered this because the Holy Prophet had said that the torment of the fire may only be decreed by God but the Prophet had also said, ‘Slay whosoever changes his religion’'*
This tradition, with some variation, may also be found in Tirmidhi, Abu
Daud, Al-Nasai and Ibn Majah’s compilations.
Contradiction with the Holy Qur’an It is not possible for a fair-minded person to reconcile the following verses of the Holy Qur’an with this tradition:
2.57, 100, 109, 218, 257, 273 22.40 3.21, 73, 86-92, 145 2455 4.83, 138, 139, 146 25.42-4 5.55, 62, 91-3, 99-100 26.117 6.67, 105-8, 126 28.57 7.124-9 29.19 9.11-14 39.30-42 10.100-9 40.26, 27 13.41 42.7, 8,48, 49 15.10 47.26 16.83, 105-7, 126 50.46 17.55 5157 18.30 64.9-13