Chapter 8: Mercy For The Universe
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 2
Revile not those to whom they pray besides Allah, lest they wrongfully
revile Allah through ignorance. Thus unto every nation have We made
their deed seem fair. Then unto their Lord is their return, and He will tell
them what they used to do. (6.109)
Respect, honour, love and esteem for someone come from the heart. Force can shut mouths, create terror and result in disrespect and irrever- ence. This is why the Holy Qur’an takes a positive view in matters of the heart.
As regards respect for the Holy Prophet, the Holy Qur’an says:
Lo! Allah and His angels shower blessings on the Prophet. O ye who
believe! Ask blessings on him and honour him with a worthy salutation.
Lo! Those who malign Allah and His Messenger Allah hath cursed them
in this world and in the next and hath prepared for them the doom of the
disdained. And those who malign believing men and women undeserv-
edly, they bear the guilt of slander and manifest sin. (33:57-59)
The Holy Qur’an is very clear about sabb. It asks Muslims not to scorn even the false gods of unbelievers and it does not lay down any punishment for those who show disrespect to the Prophet* - for them, God has prepared the ‘doom of the disdained’.
And how did the Excellent Exampler® treat those who reviled him? Let us return to the leader of the munafiqun, Abdullah b. Ubayy. After the battle of Al-Mustaliq (6AH/AD737), while the Holy Prophet* was staying by the watering-place of Al-Muraysi, an unpleasant dispute took place between the Muhajirs and Ansar. A hired servant of Umar, Jahjah b. Masud, and Sinan b. Wabar al-Juhani, an ally of Ansar, began fighting. According to Ibn Ishaq: The Juhani called out: ‘Men of Al-Ansar!’ and Jahjah called out ‘Men of the Muhajirun!’ Abdullah b. Ubayy b. Salul was enraged. With him were some of his people, including Zayd b. Arqam, a young boy. He said: ‘Have they actually done this? They dispute our priority, they outnumber us in our country. Nothing is more apt for us and the vagabonds of Quaraish than the ancient saying, “Feed a dog and it will devour you.” By Allah, when we return to Medina the most honourable will drive out the meanest.’ Then he went to his people and said: ‘This is what you have done to yourselves. You have let them occupy your country and you have divided your property among them. Had you only kept your property from them they would have gone elsewhere.’ Zayd b. Arqam heard this and, when he had disposed of his enemies, went and told the Prophet*. Umar, who was with him, said: ‘Tell Abbad b. Bishr to go and kill him.’ The Prophet** answered: ‘What if men should say Muhammad kills his own Companions? No, but give orders to set off.” The Holy Prophet* was, of course, greatly upset. The tribal appeal of Juhani to Ansar and Jahjah’s call to ‘the men of Mahajirun’ reminded him of the Day of Buath and the war of Basus, which lasted forty years. Had Abdullah b. Ubayy succeeded the Ansar, the Muhajirs would have gone back to their tribal wars. The message of Islamic unity, which changed these disunited tribes into a mighty Arab nation, would have been lost forever.
The Holy Prophet* was so upset that he gave orders to move, although, as Ibn Ishaq reports, ‘This was at a time when the Prophet* was not used to travelling.”! Referring to this incident, the Holy Qur’an says: They [the Munafiqun] say: ‘When we return to Medina the one most honourable shall surely drive out the meanest.’ True honour belongs to Allah, to His Messenger and believers; but the hypocrites know it not. (63.9) When Abdullah, son of Abdullah b. Ubayy, heard of this affair, he went to the Prophet* and said: Ihave heard that you want to kill Abdullah b. Ubayy for what you heard about him. If you must, order me to do it and I will bring his head, for Al- Khazraj know they have no man more dutiful to his father than L [am afraid that if you order someone else to kill him, I could not bear to see his executioner walking around and might kill him. I would therefore be killing a believer for an unbeliever and I would certainly be damned.’ The
Prophet® said: ‘No, but let us deal kindly with him and make much of his
companionship while he is with us.”
Muslim rulers, who understood why the Holy Prophet treated Abdullah b. Ubayy and other hypocrites and Jews as he did, have been extremely reluctant to create false martyrs in the process of protecting the honour of the Prophet* (Namus-i-Rasul). In Cordova, between 850 and 859, a group of Christian zealots was formed under the leadership of Eulogius. The members of this group were determined to denounce the Holy Prophet® publicly and to accept martyrdom. The gadis of Cordova, however, refused to oblige them and jailed them instead. Will Durant reports one such incident:
Isaac, a Cordovan monk, went to the gadi and professed a desire for
conversion; but when the judge, well pleased, began to expound Moham-
medanism, the monk interrupted him: ‘Your Prophet’, he said, ‘has lied
and deceived you. May he be cursed, who has dragged so many wretches
with him down to hell!’ The gadi reproved him and asked had he been
drinking? The monk replied: ‘I am in my right mind. Condemn me to death.’ The gadi had him imprisoned, but asked permission of Abd-ur
Rahman II to dismiss him as insane.>
Shaykhul Islam Ebus’u’ud Effendi, chief mufti of the Ottoman Empire during the reign of the Sultan Suleyman the Magnificent, allowed the death penalty, but only for habitual and public defamers of the Holy Prophet. Shaykhul Islam went out of his way to insist that execution should not be ordered lightly. He clearly wished to avoid frivolous and malicious prosecutions and laid down that an offender could not be treated as habitual ‘merely on the word of one or two persons’. The habitual character of the offender had to be proved to the authorities by impartial (begharaz) Muslims, who had no axe to grind. But there was an important rider to this which showed that though Shaykhul Islam Ebussuud issued a fatwa without any or in the Holy Qur’an hadith authority, he knew the punishment of sabb was Allah’s alone. The fatwa was issued, probably under political pressure, because he nullified its entire effect by stating that unbelievers were not held guilty for declaring ‘that which constitutes their disbelief’: that is, for rejecting Muhammad’s* prophetic mission.
The quality of a Muslim’s faith and the measure of respect he holds for the Prophet* cannot be legally defined. Conversely, an unbeliever can neither be forced to embrace Islam nor to honour its Prophet® at gun- point. This is why God has prescribed no punishment for irtidad or sabb in this world. Despite the disparaging words uttered by Abdullah b.
Ubayy at the watering-hole of Al-Muraysi, the Holy Prophet* did not punish him.
The punishment of these two offences is easily exploited by politi- cally orientated ulema who would debase religious causes by using them for materialist purposes and exploit religious belief for their own ends."