Chapter 8: Mercy For The Universe
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3
At the moment, Deobandi/Ahli Hadith ulema are accusing the Ahmadis of disparaging the Prophet. Little do they realise that in doing so they have created the means of their own destruction. In comparison with mainstream Sunnis, who constitute the majority of Muslims in the subcontinent,'5 Turkey, and many other Muslim countries, the Deobandis/Ahli Hadith and the followers of the Najdi reformer Abdul Wahhab are in a minority throughout the Muslim world (except in Nejd). They are accused of belittling the Prophet. The Deobandi/Wahhabi ulema consider the mainstream Sunnis to be kafir for attributing to the Prophet* qualities which, to say the least, are polytheist. For instance, they say that his body did not cast a shadow because he was filled with light. When Meauud-i-Sherif, popularised by the Turkish poet Suleyman Chelebi of Busra (1410), is concluded with ya Nabi Salam Alaika (peace be with you), the Prophet’s* soul is present at the event, and, therefore, everyone attending should stand to show respect. In the same manner, praying at his tomb, kissing the grillework surrounding it and many other such beliefs and practices of the Sunnis/Brelvis are shirk according to Deobandis. The Wahhabis, having demolished the historical grave- yard of Jannat ul- Baqi, wished to destroy even the dome of the Prophet’s* mosque and were prevented from doing so only by the strong reaction in the Muslim world. For these acts of destruction of graves, tombs and domes, Sunnis all over the world accuse the Wahhabis of denigrating and belittling the Holy Prophet. The Brelvis consider that it was the Deoband scholars Maulana Muham- mad Qasim Nanautwi and Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi, who did not believe in Khatm-i-nabuwatt. In a booklet, Deobandi Maulwiyon ka Iman, Maulana Abdul Mustafa Abu Yahya Muhammad Muinuddin Shafi ‘i Qadri Rizvi Thanwi writes:
O Muslims! Look how this accursed, unholy, satanic assertion has
Qasim Nanautwi does not believe in Khatm-i-nabuwatt, while Maulwi
Rashid Ahmad, Maulwi Khalil Ahmad and other Wahhabi ulema have
declared those who reject Khatm-i-nabuwatt as kafir.
Brelvi-Deobandi polemics - all in the name of protecting the
Holy Prophet*, the very paragon of modesty - have reached such vulgarity that even the mildest examples are offensive. Shourish Kashmiri, a supporter of the Deobandi school, said in his pamphlet ‘Kafir saz Mulla’ that anyone who declares the great leader of Deoband as kafir (unbeliever) is a liar. In the same pamphlet he said that the Brelvi ulema sell religion and the Sharia of the Prophet* to make a living, that they are the born slaves of Lord Clive’s household, the enemies of the Muslim League and Qaid-i-Azam Jinnah. In another pamphlet, he said that these people were even lower than a brick in Maulana Husain Ahmad’s and Syed Ataullah Shah Bukhari’s lavatory.'® The Brelvi reply to these abusive charges was tasteless. They said that the man slandering them and the Holy Prophet had spent his life wandering the red-light districts. ‘The man who called Nehru a prophet is now accusing us of selling the Shari’a of the Prophet*”’, they cried. ‘Why shouldn’t Muhammad Qasim Nanautwi be called a kafir and how can we accept Ashraf Ali Thanwi as a Muslim? Aren’t they the men who said the door of prophethood was open? Aren’t they the pathfinders of the Qadiyanis? Who has taught you how to denigrate Mustafa? Who has taught you unbelief? You have taken your clothes off, have you no sense of decency or modesty? You have created disorder under the name of khatm-i-nabuwwat and spread mischief under the name of peace. You are collecting money under the name of nabuwwat and begging under the name of the Prophet*.”
Another poet, Sayyad Muhammad Tanha, said:
How can you appreciate the high status of Anmad Raza?
Go and smell the stinking underpants of Hindus.
Gold is your prophet, gold is your God
You belong to the party of those who show you gold
You have spent all your life with Kufr
How can you, a Khatri Hindu by caste, join Islam?
O Nimrod, how can you glorify Allah?
Your place is with Hindus, go there and praise
there the name of Hari, Hari.'®
Compare the language, the style and the contents of this Barelvi attack on Deobandi ulema with the tirade of Deobandi scholars against Ahmadis:
1. Ahmadis deny khatm-i-nabuwwat,
2. Ahmadis denigrate the Holy Prophet®,
3. Ahmadis created British imperialism in India;
4. Ahmadis opposed the creation of Pakistan;
5. Ahmadis are opposed to jihad;
6. Ahmadis associate with non-Muslims;
7. Ahmadiyatis a racket in religion’s name.
Both the Ahli-Sunnat wal Jamaat (Brelvi) and Deobandi ulema accuse each other of disparaging the Holy Prophet™. As we saw earlier, the Jamaati Islami described the Ahl-i Qur’an as being worse than the Ahmadis. But the Shias have not been spared either - they have been accused of degrading the status of the Holy Prophet® by claiming that Ali shared the prophethood with him.
The Canadian scholar, Wilfred Cantwell Smith, who visited the subcontinent and closely observed the Muslim society of India and Pakistan, has accused Muslims of ‘a fanaticism of blazing vehemence’. In his book, Islam in Modern India, he says:
Muslims will allow attacks on Allah: there are atheists and atheistic
publications and rationalistic societies, but to disparage Muhammad will
provoke from even the most liberal sections of the community a fanati- cism of blazing vehemence.” This is an incorrect assessment of Muslim temperament. Prof. Cantwell Smith has generalised. Actually, it is the Mullahs and the politically- orientated leadership which recognised: ‘that the feelings of a Musulman are never more easily aroused and his indignation awakened than over a real or fancied insult to the Holy Prophet.?°
No doubt the rich and the poor, the intellectuals, the uneducated, the pious and impious have always been united in the love of the Prophet and considered fana fir-rasul (annihilation in the name of the Prophet®) to be the peak of religious experience. But no Muslim is unmindful that the Holy Prophet’s* highest experience was the miraj, when he, sur- rounded by clouds of angels, soared high into the Divine Presence, where even the angel Gabriel has no access. The power-hungry Muslim leader- ship forgets that the exhortation ‘Muhammad* is the Messenger of God’ is only the second part of the confession of the Muslim faith. The first is: ‘There is no God but Allah.’
There is no way to measure love or respect. Lovers and mystics wrote diwans after diwans and finally devoted their lives to trying to express feelings no language could really convey. The mullahs can scan the poem of love, but cannot understand it. It is no mere accident that the founder of the Ahmadiyyah Movement in Islam was named Ghulam Ahmad*.
What an honour! What a status! What a glory! In the following three couplets he answers those who accuse him of disparaging the Holy Prophet® and critics, like Cantwell Smith, who accuse Muslims of being negligent of Allah’s honour:
After the love of Allah it is Muhammad’s love