Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights
a
l y y a Commu n i ty.
�'Hon1e-rule can nerer be of benefit to lndirt unless it be of a federal fypr/·
His Holiness Hazrat
Mirza Bashir-ud-Din Mahmud Ahmad.
Snpplcruent
Printed by S. K. Dutt M.Sc., at the Protiva Press, 38-2, Wellington Street, Calcutta.
,vhich is included at the encl of thi� book.
Secretary to His Holinrs.� the Khalifatul-Jlasih II
for Literature and Research Trork.
r. Did the Nehru Committee represent Al l-In di a?
All-Muslim Parties confe r ence a t Sim la.
Muslim Demand
Demands of the Lahore Mus1im l.eague
A Federa l Government.-
l Rep
tation.-So parat e Electora t
Provinces. -Minorities Lan gu a
o
Religiou
Propa
gan
Constitution and Amendmen t ther e of .
3. Demands of the (:a]cutta Muslim League . . .
4. Muslim Demands in the Nehru Report
Form of Government.- Special Repr e s en ta
Provinces, Beluchistan and Si.iidh.-Th
e
o
the Constitution.
Subjects
5. Can Details be left over till the Attainment of Dominion Status
What is Dominion Status.-The Mussal mans and the Conncils.-The use of Force.
The Help of Foreign Powers.-British Intervention not Possible.
6. Do Minorities Need Special La\VS ?
Causes of Friction hetween Majorities and Minorities.-Proteotion of Minorities in · Europe -Mere Uniformity of Laws is no sufficient safeguard for Muslims.-No Pro tection of Minorities in· the Nehru-Report.
7. Muslim Demands and the Nehru-Report
Pages
The Need for Special Safe-guards.
Fate of Muslim Majorities in Bengal and the Punjab.-Avantages of Federal Govern m'ent.-Federal Government not detrimental to any Community.-Federal Government no Bar to Progress.·•-Form of Federal Government in India.
Subjects Pages
9. Demand for three N e\v Muslim Provinces (Detailed Study-contd.) ... ... 97
Muslim Demand Reasonable.-M uslim Demand infringes Nobody's Right -Political Aspect of the Demand.
Reservation of Seats on Population
-Nehru Committee's Objections.-District Board Elections.-A Wrong Study of
Board Elections.
Government (Detailed Study-contd.)... 143
Increased Representation involves no Injustice to Others.-Allotments of Seats not
nal Tension.
Subjects
I 3. Protection of Culture and
Study-contd.)
Pr0per Enforcement of Law.-•Future of Great Britain.-Amendment of the Consti tution.
I 4. Duty Before us
Right of Franchise.-Foreign Relations.
The Jumaa.-The Muslim Law.-High Court Judges.-N ative States.
Pages
For the word "there" at page 74 in line 10 read "later on"
In !he na,110 of .Jllal,, the Beneficent, the J,{erciful. He alcnc is the Helper.
Did the Nehru Committee Represent All-India?
� HE first question we have to ask in dealing with the
Report is • ·was the Nehru Committee a representa tive body and are its deliberations entitled to the same consideration as the report of an All-India Committee?'' And the answer is furnished by the Report itself. It is abundantly clear from the Report that the aforesaid com mittee is not in any sense entitled to be regarded as a body representative of the country.
From the Report it appears that All-Parties Confer ence at Bombay appointed this Committee on May 19, J 928; and what this self-styled All-Parties Conference was, and how it came into being, may be further read in the Report itself.
The Report says that in view of the increasing difference between the Hindus and the. Muslims, the Na tional Congress which met in Gauhati in December, 1926, Passed a resolution calling upon '' the Working Com mittee to take immediate steps in consultation with Hindμ and Mussalman leaders to devise means for the remov�l of the present deplorable differences between Hindus and Mu s sa