Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 2

mans,

a nd to submit their report to the All

India Con g res s Co mm ittee not later than the 31st March, 1927

In

co

with these directions the Working

Commit tee he ld conferences with Hindu and Muslim

leader

On

e

1927, some prominen t M

us

ea

togeth e

r in Delhi and put forward

er

t ain pr o posal s for the solution of the Hindu-Muslim

ere

nces

sum an

e

uss a

r epared to a gree to joint elector -

a

e

prov

ded:

(i

into a sep arate province. (i

Pr ovinces ard Baluchistan wer e

ea

e

on

the same footin g as the other pro-

ces.

(ii

i)

e

resen

a

s in accordance with the

pu

(i

v)

e

Cen tra l Le gi slature Muslim representa-

a s n o t to be les s than one-third.

e

di

aft

er

the publication of th

the Congr

e

Work ing Comm

record;d its appr ec

at

on o

the Mus

alma

towal"

e

proposa

e

ecte

La

er

tee met apin

ie

tion with other political parties and councillors, draft .a Swaraj Constitution and that in the preparation thereof it should invite suggestions from all the political, labour, commercial, and communal organisations. The Congress was shortly followed by the Liberal Federation which in a resolution, in addition to expressing its approval of the Moslem proposals, proposed a joint conference of the representatives of all communities to be called immediate ly in order to arrive at a settlement in the light of the Mos�em proposals. After this the Muslim League also in a meeting resolved that the League Council should ap point a sub-committee to co-operate with the Congress Working Committee in drafting a constitution for India in which the interest of the Muslim community will have been adequately safeguarded.

While the Liberal Federation and the Muslim League passed the aforesaid resolutions, the Congress Working Committee, as directed by the Congr,�ss, invited to a con ference various bodies, of which the All-India Muslim League and the Khilafat Committee were the only two Muslim organiastions as against four Parsee Associations and three States' Subjects' Conferences. According to the Nehru-Report, most of these bodies sent their dele gates and the conference which was held at Delhi, lasted from 12th February till the 22nd of the same month. The MusJim League Council hastened to signify its disap proval of the resolutions passed at the Joint Conference, and thus the All-Parties Conference ceased to be re presentative of India and became a purely Hindu body. The Leagu•� Council went a step further. In another resolution it insisted that its delegates should press the representatives of various organisations to accept the Calcutta League Resolutions, and it explicitly laid down �hat the delegates should, before taking part in the fram ing of the constitution, report to the Council the progress made in this direction. Thus, the League in a plain rnanner debarred its representatives from taking part in the committee that had undertaken to frame a constitu tion for India. The Nehru-Report admits that this deci sion of the Muslim League Council placed the Nehru Committee in a difficult position inasmuch as the dele gates of the League, in view of the resolutionst could not take part in the deliberation upon the report unless and until the resolutions of the League had been accepted in full, or unless the Council itself had issued instructions anew. Under the circumstances, the All-Parties Confer ence had to re-assemble on March 8,-the persons attend ing the meeting have not been mentioned in the report and two sub-committees were formed,-one to consider the question of the separation of Sindh, and the other to investigate the question of representation.

The report of the committee appointed on the 22nd February could not be taken up for consideration be cause the delegates of the Muslim League refused point blank to discuss it. The conference, thereupon, ordered its publication and adjourned its sitting till 19th May, 1928. During this time the Hindu Mahasabha met in April and vehemently opposed certain demands of the Muslim League.

The All-Parties Conference again met in Bombay on May 19, but as the conditions prevailing hardly warranted a unanimous decision, it was proposed to form a small sub-committee to investigate the problems. Accordingly a sub-committee, consisting of Sir Ali Imam and Mr. Shuaib Kureishy (Muslims), Messrs. Annie and Jayakar (Hindu Mahasabha), Mr. Pardhan (Brahmins), Sardar Mangal Singh (Sikhs), Sir Tej Bahadur Sapru (Liberals),

Mr. Joshi (Labour ), Mr. S. C. Bose and Pandit

l\tlotilal Nehru, ( nine in all-7 Hindus and 2 Muslims ) was duly constituted. From the report it appears that

Sir Ali Imam for reasons of health could not be present at more than one sitting. Thus, Mr. Shuaib Kureishy was left alone to represent the Moslem interests.

The facts related above have been quoted from the Nehru-Report itself. As regards others of a more secret nature, I need take no notice. They are receiving due publicity at the hands of some Muslim Leaders. The facts I have chosen to advert to are sufficient for my pur pose. They are sufficient to prove that the Nehru Com mittee did not represent the whole of India. It consisted merely of a handful of men assembled at their own sweet will, most of them self-styled leaders. Neither were all the provinces represented, nor all the different communities. As an instance I might easily cite the case of our own community. Throughout these negotiations our community was never consulted although our com munity though small in number yet far exceeds the Parsees in numerical strength, and commands an All India status. We possess powerful organisations in at least three provinces, namely, Bengal, the Punjab and N. W. F. Provinces, in addition to a fairly big population in Behar, the U. P., Madras, and Sindh ; while smaller numbers may be found aU over the country. Above all, we are an organised people, and yield not even to the foremost Hindu Associations in India in the matter of registered membership and organisation. The members of the All-Parties Conference will in vain plead that we are only a religious community. True, our community has the same platform both for religion and politics, and finds the arrangement more effective, but that is no reason why we should have been deprived of our legi... timate rights. But for the time, let us leave alone the case of our community.

The actua1 work of the Nehru Committee began some where in 1928, some time after the Muslim League had split up into two divisions-the Lahore, and the Calcutta Sections. From the Nehru--Report, it does not appear that efforts were made to secure the representation of the Lahore Section nor is it in evidence anywhere that any

attempt was made to seek the co-operation of the provincial branches of the League, while as a matter of fact the communal problem assumes hideous proportions only in questions relating to the provinces and not to the country as a whole. Therefore, the participation even of both the sections of the League could not have been deemed adequate. The conclusion is obvious. The so called All-Parties Conference could not justify its name, so long as all view-points were not fully represented on it.

·

10 of 10 left today