Foreword

The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 10

These people went and returned after having performed their investigation and all of them reported that it was peaceful everywhere and that Muslims were living their lives in complete freedom; no one was infringing upon their rights and the governors were acting with equity and justice. However,

‘Ammar bin Yasir was delayed and no news came from him. I will mention why ‘Ammar bin Yasir was delayed later on, but first I would like to mention something about this investigative committee and the significance of this investigation. The reason being that the true reality of this disorder becomes clearly evident by fully understanding the specifics of this delegation. The first thing that is worthy of attention, is the stature of the three leading members of this delegation who returned to submit their reports. The status of the people carrying out this investigation demonstrates the significance of the investigation. If such people had been dispatched as part of this delegation, who desired something from Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and his deputies, or who, on account of their low and insignificant spiritual and worldly status may have feared the governors or harboured greed, it could be suggested that these people refrained from disclosing the truth on account of their greed or fear. However, such an allegation cannot be levelled against them. Furthermore, by selecting these people to perform this task, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) has furnished clear evidence of his pure intention. Usamah (ra), the one sent to Bashrah, was not only the son of Hadrat Zaid (ra), who was first among those who believed, but was also from among the closest and dearest ones of the Holy Prophet (sa). He was the very person upon whom the Holy Prophet (sa) conferred the position of being commander-in-chief of the magnificent army that he was prepared during his final illness. He also positioned eminent companions like Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) in subordination to him. This selection by the Holy Prophet (sa) was not merely an act of encouragement. In fact, later events established that he was capable of achieving great feats. The Holy Prophet (sa) displayed so much love for him that spectators would be unable to differentiate whether he loved him more or Hadrat Imam Hasan (ra). Muhammad bin Muslim, who was sent to Kufah, was also from among the most venerable companions. He was looked upon with great reverence amongst the companions and was very influential.

‘Abdullah bin ‘Umar (ra), who was sent to Syria, is among those who require no introduction. He was among the foremost Muslims who pledged their allegiance. He was so great in his piety and righteousness that on account of this particular merit, even the most prominent companions displayed a special respect for him. After Hadrat ‘Ali (ra) if the sight of the companions and other noble men fell upon anyone for succession to Khilafat, then it was him. However, he had made it a practice to remain secluded from the world. He possessed such indignation for those things that were deemed sacred in religion that on certain occasions, he even vehemently debated ‘Umar bin Al-Khattab (ra). Hence, in speaking the truth, he was an unsheathed sword. His appointment for Syria was a most perfect appointment. Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) had long been the governor of Syria and held a position of great awe upon the residents there. Due to his intelligence, investigating his administration was not the task of an ordinary person. It was futile to send anyone else to this region and no one would have been satisfied with the investigation of such a person. However, his excellence in faith, indignation for Islam, farsightedness, righteousness and piety were such merits, before which even Mu‘awiyah (ra) could not dare to utter a word. In his presence the awe of Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) could not influence anyone.

Therefore, the people who were sent to carry out this investigation were magnificent and neutral people and no one can raise an objection against their findings. The unanimous verdict of these three companions along with the rest of those who were sent to other countries that there was absolute peace and security, no sign of injustice and tyranny, and governors were acting with complete equality and justice; and if they were liable to be blamed then it was only inasmuch that they compelled people to remain within boundaries, was such a verdict which leaves no room for doubt. It is clearly evident that all this disorder was the result of the mischief of a few transgressors and the instigation of ‘Abdullah bin Saba. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and his representatives were free from all objections.

In truth, this entire disturbance was the result of a secret conspiracy hatched by the Jews. They were joined by certain Muslims who were attracted to the desire of the world and had left their faith. Neither were the provincial governors to blame for this, nor were they the cause of this disorder. Their only fault was that they had been appointed by Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and the fault of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was that he was holding fast to the rope of Islamic unity despite his old age and physical weakness. He was carrying the burden of the Muslim ummah upon his shoulders and was concerned for the establishment of the Islamic shariah. He would not allow the rebellious and tyrannous to oppress the weak and helpless according to their desire. As such, the following incident testifies to the truth of this fact. When the same rebels held a meeting in Kufah and they began to discuss how disorder may be created in Muslim affairs, everyone unanimously gave the opinion:

“By God, no one can dare to raise their head, so long as the

reign of ‘Uthman (ra) prevails.”

It was the very person of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) himself which prevented rebellion. It was necessary to move him aside in order for these people to freely achieve their goals.

Earlier, I explained that ‘Ammar bin Yasir, who had been sent to Egypt, did not return. There was a delay in receiving news from him to such extent that the residents of Madinah thought that he may have been killed. However, the fact of the matter was that due to his simplicity and unfamiliarity with politics, he had fallen into the clutches of the rebels, who were disciples of ‘Abdullah bin Saba. As ‘Abdullah bin Saba was present in Egypt himself, he was not oblivious to the fact that if this investigative committee reported a state of peace and security throughout the land, everyone would turn against them. The decision to send this delegation had been made so suddenly that he was unable to make arrangements in other provinces. However, it was easy for him to make arrangements in Egypt. He welcomed ‘Ammar bin Yasir as soon as he arrived in Egypt and began to describe the weaknesses and cruelties of the governor of Egypt. ‘Ammar bin Yasir was unable to safeguard himself from the enchantment of his words. Instead of carrying out an unbiased investigation, he did not even approach the governor of Egypt, nor did he carry out an ordinary investigation. On the contrary, he went along with this group of rebels and began to raise objections with them.

‘Ammar bin Yasir is the only person from among the companions about whom it is categorically proven that he became entrapped in the snare of rebels. Aside from him, no other prominent Companion participated in such an act. If anyone from among them has been implicated, such a notion has been refuted by other narrations. There was a particular reason for ‘Ammar bin Yasir (ra) being deceived. As soon as he arrived in Egypt, he happened to meet a group of eloquent and well-spoken people who appeared to be reliable; they began to complain to him about the governor of Egypt with great skill. Coincidently, the governor of Egypt was a man who had once been a bitter enemy of the Holy Prophet (sa). At the victory of Makkah the Holy Prophet (sa) had commanded that he should be killed even if he was to be found in the vicinity of the Ka‘bah. Even though the Holy Prophet (sa) later forgave him, his former opposition had left traces of dislike upon the hearts of certain companions, which included ‘Ammar (ra). Therefore, upon hearing complaints against such a person, ‘Ammar (ra) was very quickly influenced and accepted all the allegations that would be levelled against him as being true. Whilst capitalising on natural sentiment, the Saba’is, i.e., the supporters of ‘Abdullah bin Saba, would highlight this particular issue as a means against the governor. The goodness of intention and sincerity of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) may be gauged from the fact that despite all the delegations giving a verdict absolving the governors, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) valued this single view to such extent that he wrote a letter to all the various regions. The contents of this letter was: “Ever since I have become the Khalifah I have acted upon enjoining equity and forbidding evil and my relatives do not hold a superior right to ordinary Muslims. However, I have come to know from certain residents of Madinah that the governors beat people and hurl abuse at them. For this reason I make an open announcement by way of this letter that whomsoever has been sworn at or beaten in secrecy, should meet me in Makkah Mukarramah on the occasion of hajj. In return for any injustice done by my hand or by my governors, retribution may be sought from me and my representatives, or if such a person wills, he may forgive us. Allah the Exalted Himself rewards those who give sadaqah [i.e., those who forgive].

When this brief but painful letter was read out upon the pulpits throughout the land, the Muslim world was shook from end to end. Listeners helplessly burst into tears and everyone prayed for Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). Everyone expressed displeasure towards these transgressors who were attacking and causing grief to a man who held sympathy for the Muslim ummah and carried its burden.

Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) did not cease at this; he especially summoned his governors in order to answer for the allegations which had been levelled against them. When all of the governors had come together, he inquired of them, “What is the reason for these allegations being levelled against you? I fear that they may be true.”

In response to this, they all submitted:

“You have sent reliable people and discovered that no

injustice is being perpetrated, nor is anything being

committed in violation of the shariah. Furthermore, the

reliable people you dispatched inquired of the state of

affairs from all the people. Not a single person came before

them and claimed that these complaints were valid. What

room, then, is there for doubt? By God, these people have

not spoken the truth nor have they acted with the fear of

·

10 of 10 left today