Foreword
The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 9
When these people left Damascus, they abandoned their plan of going to Kufah, since the people who lived there were already familiar with their mischief. They also feared that they would suffer harm there; hence they went towards Jazirah. The governor of this region, ‘Abdur-Rahman, was the pious son of the renowned general who had left behind a shining legacy of courage and bravery for the whole world, i.e., Khalid bin Walid. When he learnt of their arrival, he immediately called for them and said:
“I have heard of your state of affairs. May Allah ruin me if I am unable to reform you. You are aware that I am the son of that man who removed the disorder of apostasy
and emerged victorious from great difficulties. I shall see
whether you are able to talk to me in the manner that you
spoke to Mu‘awiyah (ra) and Sa‘id (ra). Listen here! If you utter
a word of mischief to someone here, then I shall give you a
punishment that you will never forget.”
Having said this, he confined them and ordered them to always remain with him. When he would go on journey, he would take them along with him on foot and he would inquire:
“How do you feel now? Punishment is the remedy of a
person who is not reformed by virtue. Why do you not
speak now?”
These people would express remorse and seek repentance for their mischief. After some time had elapsed, ‘Abdur-Rahman bin Khalid bin Walid thought that they had been reformed. As such, he sent a person from among them by the name of Malik to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) in order to beg for forgiveness. He came before Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and repented and expressed remorse and asked forgiveness for himself and his companions. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) forgave him and inquired as to where he desired to live. Malik replied that now he wished to stay with ‘Abdur- Rahman bin Khalid. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) granted him permission and he returned to ‘Abdur-Rahman bin Khalid.
His desire to stay with ‘Abdur-Rahman bin Khalid indicates that his heart had certainly been cleansed at the time. If not, he would not have desired to return to such a man, who would not tolerate mischief for even a minute. However, later events substantiate that his repentance was only temporary and the opinion of Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) was correct, in that these were foolish people who were only good for being used as weapons.
In the meanwhile, ‘Abdullah bin Saba had not remained idle. Quite the contrary, for some time, he had adopted the strategy of dispatching agents to various regions and thus, spread his views. Without a shadow of doubt, this was a man of extraordinary intelligence and judgement. The orders he would give to his agents shed ample light on the framework of his mind. Whilst dispatching his representatives, he would advise them:
“Do not be hasty in disclosing your views to people at once;
rather, exhort and advise them first. Recite to them the
injunctions of the shariah. Enjoin goodness and forbid
evil. When the people observe this manner of admonition,
their hearts will be drawn towards you. They will listen
to you with enthusiasm and will begin to trust you. Only
then present your particular views skilfully; they will
accept them very quickly. Moreover, be cautious not to
speak against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) at the very outset; rather,
incite people against his representatives first.”
The purpose behind this was that since the people held a special religious attachment with Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra), they would become enraged upon hearing words against him. However, they would accept statements against governors as this would not move their religious sentiments. In this manner, when their hearts would turn black and the obstinacy that results from joining a certain party would develop, then it would also become easier to incite them against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra).
This person realised that whenever the shortcomings of provincial governors were mentioned, the wise would refuse to accept them, because these people knew that they were false and unfounded based on their own observation; and widespread uproar would not arise throughout the country. Therefore, he undertook another dangerous scheme. Instead of defaming the governors of various regions in their own jurisdictions, he ordered his representatives to write the failings of governors to other provinces, because the people of other regions would easily accept such statements due to their unfamiliarity with the circumstances of that area. According to this proposal, the rebels of all the various regions would write false complaints and cruelties of their local governors to the sympathetic people of other towns. These people would then read such letters to others and many of them would be convinced of their truth due to being unaware of the circumstances in foreign lands. They would feel grieved at the thought that their brethren were afflicted by extreme difficulties in such and such land. At the same time, they would also be grateful that by the grace of Allah their own governors were kind and they were at ease. However, they were unaware that the people in other provinces believed themselves to be in a state of comfort and others in difficulty, and they were thankful for their own condition and felt concern for the state of others. Since the people of Madinah were receiving correspondence from all four fronts, those among them who considered these letters as being true would think that perhaps atrocities were being perpetrated in every province and hardships were befalling the Muslims. Hence, the deception of ‘Abdullah bin Saba proved to be very effective and by this means he managed to gain thousands of sympathetic people who would have been difficult to find without such a scheme.
When this disturbance exceeded all bounds and even the noble companions began to receive letters of complaint against governors, together, they approached Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and submitted, “Are you not aware of what is taking place outside Madinah?” Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) replied, “The reports that I receive indicate nothing but peace and tranquility.” The companions responded that they were receiving letters of such and such subject matter, and this should be investigated. At this, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) sought their counsel as to how the investigation should be carried out. According to their proposal Usamah bin Zaid (ra) was sent to Basrah, Muhammad bin Maslamah to Kufah, ‘Abdullah bin ‘Umar to Syria and ‘Ammar bin Yasir to Egypt, in order to investigate the state of affairs and report whether the governors were actually treating the citizens unjustly, oppressing them and usurping the rights of people. In addition to these four, he also dispatched some others to various lands so that they could provide a report of the conditions there.