Foreword

The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 12

How ironic is it that the people who were demonstrating rage and raising allegations against the Khalifah of the time - the foremost in faith and the son-in-law of the Holy Prophet (sa) - were those who had themselves abandoned the obligatory prayers. Is it possible that indignation for Islam should only manifest itself within the faithless? If a shortcoming or something in contradiction with the shariah truly existed in Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) or his governors, then the people who would have expressed their anger against this would have been ‘Ali, Talhah, Zubair, Sa’d bin Waqqas, ‘Abdullah bin ‘Amr, Usamah bin Zaid, ‘Abdullah bin ‘Abbas, Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari, Hudhaifah bin

Al-Yaman, Abu Hurairah, ‘Abdullah bin Salam, ‘Ubadah bin Samit and Muhammad bin Maslamah, may Allah be pleased with all of them, not Yazid bin Qais and Ashtar.

The messenger reached Jazirah with the letter and handed it over to the people who had been exiled from Kufah. When they read it, except for Ashtar, all the others disliked it as they had already witnessed the influence of ‘Abdur-Rahman bin Khalid. However, as for Ashtar, who had gone to Madinah in order to seek forgiveness from Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra), was unable to keep his repentance intact and immediately set out for Kufah. When his friends saw that Ashtar had left for Kufah, they became frightened that ‘Abdur-Rahman would not believe them and think that all of this had taken place on their suggestion. So, out of this fear, these people fled as well. When ‘Abdur-Rahman bin Khalid bin Walid learned of this he sent his men in pursuit of them, but they were unable to apprehend them. One manzil after another, Malikul-Ashtar reached Kufah in no time. He deemed it against his honour to enter the city empty handed. This person, who came from Jazirah to meet his companions, having covered two manzils at a time as if they were one, began to announce his arrival from Madinah. In order to incite the people, he began to say:

“I have just left behind Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra), who I

accompanied for a distance of one manzil. He openly says,

‘I will stain the chastity of the women of Kufah,’ and he

also says, ‘The properties in Kufah are the wealth of the

Quraish.’ Furthermore, he boastfully recites the following couplet:

Meaning, ‘Noble women shall fall to trial because of me! I am a man so powerful as if from among the Jinn.’” The ordinary masses lost their senses due to his statements and they believed everything that he said. Fury instantly surged forth. The wise and learned tried their utmost to convince them and said, ‘This is deception, do not be mislead,’ but who could tame the public outrage; no one paid heed to them. A man stood up and announced:

“Whoever wishes to request the dismissal of Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra), the governor of Kufah, and the appointment of another governor, should immediately join Yazid bin Qais.”

People rushed out upon hearing this announcement and no one remained in the mosque except for the learned and noble, and those who were in authority. ‘Umar bin Al-Juraid was the acting governor for Sa‘id in his absence. He began to deliver an exhortation to the remaining people and said:

‘O people! Remember the favour of God the Exalted upon us when we were enemies. He united your hearts and you became as brothers. You were on the brink of a pit of destruction and God the Exalted saved you from it. So do not cast yourself into the affliction which God the Exalted has saved you from. Do you not recognise the truth and come to its doorstep after having accepted Islam, receiving divine guidance and in the presence of the sunnah of the Holy Prophet (sa)?’

Qa‘qa‘ bin ‘Amr (ra) responded:

“You desire to stop this disorder through admonition, but do not hope of this. Nothing but the sword can stop these disturbances and the time is not far when even the sword will be unsheathed. At that time, these people will cry like lambs and wish that this era should return again but God the Exalted would not bestow this favour upon them again until the Day of Judgment.”

The public gathered outside the town, faced Madinah and began to wait for Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra). When he came before them, they said to him, “Turn back; we are in no need of you.” Sa‘id replied: “What is the wisdom behind so many people gathering and coming out for this purpose? In order to stop one person, why were a thousand men needed? It would have sufficed you to send a man towards the Khalifah and a man towards me.”

After saying this he spurred on his mount and returned to Madinah in order to warn Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra), while these people were left astonished. Shortly thereafter, they spotted one of his servants and killed him.

Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra) reached Madinah and informed Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) of the entire conflict. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) asked, “Have they risen up against me?” Sa‘id replied, “They make it seem as if a new governor is being requested.” He inquired, “Who do they ask for?” He replied, “They prefer Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari.”

Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) said:

“I appoint Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari (ra) as the governor of

Kufah. By God, I shall give these people no opportunity to

raise an objection or allow them to find fault. In response

to their statements I shall demonstrate patience as per the

commandment of the Holy Prophet (sa), until the time that

they desire arrives, i.e., the removal of ‘Uthman.”

This conflict disclosed that these people did not even slightly refrain from speaking lies and falsehood.

The fleeing of Malikul-Ashtar from Jazirah under the pretence of coming from Madinah, levelling a false allegation upon Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra), and attributing disgraceful and selfconcocted things towards him, were not matters which could allow the true motives and secret intentions of the rebels to remain hidden. In fact, this evidently demonstrates that these people were completely oblivious to Islam. Islam does not permit falsehood, does not advocate deception and slandering is a grave crime in Islam. However, these people, who apparently professed love and indignation for Islam, told lies and slandered others; and all the while they felt no shame in doing so. Hence, their hue and cry against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was sufficient proof of the fact that this commotion was not on account of any real shortcoming; rather, it was the result of being distanced from Islam and irreligiousness.

The second conclusion which is derived from this incident is that these people did not possess even a single legitimate complaint against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and his governors. For if a complaint truly existed, what need was there for them to fabricate lies? The invention of false complaints alone is sufficient evidence of the fact that these people had no real complaint. As such, we see that before the arrival of Ashtar when Yazid held a gathering, only a few soldiers participated at the time. When Qa‘qa‘ prohibited them, they became afraid and put off their gathering. However, we see that within the very same month after being influenced by the lies of Ashtar a large segment of the public had joined these people and set out from Kufah in order to stop Sa‘id and request the appointment of another governor. This is testimony to the fact that initially, people would not be easily deceived by the rebels because they had no means to incite them. When Ashtar managed to invent a means, which was enough to spark the people’s indignation, a section of the public fell into this trap and joined them.

·

10 of 10 left today