Foreword

The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 13

The emergence of this disorder also clearly establishes that the actual opposition of these people was against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and not his governors. For in the beginning, it was he against whom the rebels desired to incite the people. However, when they noticed that no one would join them in this; rather, they would begin to oppose them, these people began to incite the public against the governors. The fact that the rebels were heading for Madinah with a large party also proves that they did not harbour good intentions for Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). Furthermore, their needlessly killing the freed slave of Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra), demonstrates that in order to fulfil their ends these people felt no hindrance in committing any crime whatsoever.

It appears that by now these people had begun to perceive that if there was even a slight delay, the Muslim people would come to learn of the gravity of their mischief. For this reason, they were deeply concerned in attaining their objective in whatever way and as quickly as possible. However, with his wisdom, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) dismissed their excuses once again. He appointed Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari (ra) as the governor and immediately informed the people. Their hopes had already been frustrated when Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra) returned and informed the people of Madinah of their motives. Their plans under deliberation of suddenly occupying Madinah, were frustrated and they were forced to turn back. Now, with the appointment of Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari (ra) as the governor, their objections had been completely done away with because these people desired his appointment as governor for some time.

When Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari (ra) came to know of his appointment as the governor of Kufah, he gathered everyone and said:

“O people! Never set out for such works again, and adopt

unity and obedience. Act patiently and refrain from haste

because now an Amir is amongst you i.e. I have been

appointed as the Amir.”

Upon this, these people requested him to lead them in prayer but he refused saying, “No, this will never happen.”

He went on to state:

“I shall not become your Imam until you affirm complete obedience to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and declare that you will accept his orders.”

Upon this, the people promised that they would show complete obedience to him in the future and accept his orders. It was only then that Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari (ra) led them in prayer. Similarly, Hadrat Abu Musa (ra) told them:

“Hearken! I have heard the Holy Prophet (sa) say, ‘At a time when people are under an Imam, anyone who rises up to create disaccord among them and to scatter their community, should be executed, whoever he may be. The Holy Prophet (sa) has not stipulated the condition of the Imam being equitable. In other words, you cannot say that Hadrat ‘Uthman is not just; for even if this is accepted as being true, your action is still unwarranted because the Holy Prophet (sa) has not stipulated the condition of justice.

66. Tarikhut-Tabari, vol. 5, p. 142, Dhikrul-Khabari ‘An Ijtima‘ihim Li- Dhalika Wa Khabarul-Jur‘ati, Published by Darul-Fikr, Beirut, 2002 edition [Publishers]

67. * Sahih Muslim, Kitabul-Imarah, Babu Hukmi Man Farraqa Amral- Muslimina Wa Huwa Mujtami‘un, Hadith No. 4796

Instead, the Holy Prophet (sa) has merely stated that there

should be a ruler over the people.”

These were the views of those people who had spent their entire lives in the service of Islam and who had heard the teachings of Islam directly from the lips of the Holy Prophet (sa). Moreover, they had received an attestation of approval by acting upon these teachings in his presence. What to talk of praying behind these rebels, they did not even desire to become their Imam in prayer and considered them liable for capital punishment. Can it be said about such people that they were a part of the conflict in the era of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) or that Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and his governors were usurping the rights of the citizens? Similarly, in light of these events can it be accepted that these rebels were creating disorder on their behalf. Of course not! In fact, this rebel party was bent upon creating disorder out of its jealousy towards the community of companions and these people hid their heartfelt views. Their real objective was the destruction of the Islamic government and this objective could not be achieved without moving Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) aside. Not catching on to their deception, certain ignorant or faithless Muslims, joined them as well either out of their selfishness or simplicity.

After the appointment of Hadrat Abu Musa Al-Ash‘ari (ra) as governor, there remained no reason for these people to create disorder. However, the real instigators of this conflict could not have been pleased with all their efforts going to waste in this manner. Hence, written correspondence began and it was decided that a few people from all the provinces should set out towards Madinah in the form of delegations. There, they should deliberate as to the future course of action, and certain questions should also be posed to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) so that these discussions may be publicised in all directions and people may become convinced that the allegations levelled against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) have been proven beyond doubt. After deciding the matter they all left their homes and headed for Madinah. When they reached close to Madinah Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) learnt of their arrival. He sent two men to enquire about them and ascertain the real purpose of their arrival, and then report back to him. The two of them left and met this caravan outside Madinah. During the course of discussion these people revealed to the two informants their state of affairs. The two of them asked whether anyone from the people of Madinah was with them. This treacherous group replied that there were three people in Madinah and besides them, they did not have a fourth supporter. The two enquired, “Then what is your intention?” They replied:

“Our intention is to go to Madinah in order to speak to

Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) regarding certain matters which we

have already instilled into the minds of people. Then

we will return to our towns and tell everyone that we

raised many objections against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and

established their validity, but he has refused to abstain

from these things and did not repent. Then we will leave,

under the pretence of going for hajj and besiege him upon

reaching Madinah. If he steps down from Khilafat, then

well and good, otherwise we will kill him.”

Both of these informants returned with a full report of their findings and briefed Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). Upon hearing their state of affairs, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) began to laugh and prayed to God the Exalted, “O Allah! Save these people from going astray. They will be ruined if You do not save them.” Then, regarding the three men from among the people of Madinah who were with the mischief-makers, he said:

·

10 of 10 left today