Foreword
The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 14
“As for ‘Ammar, he is angry because he attacked ‘Abbas bin ‘Utbah bin Abi Lahab and he was reprimanded for this. Whereas Muhammad bin Abi Bakr has turned arrogant and thinks that no law is binding upon him and Muhammad bin Abi Hudhaifah is putting himself in trouble for no reason.”
Then Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) called the mischief-makers and gathered the companions of the Holy Prophet (sa) as well.
When everyone had gathered, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) informed them of the whole affair. The two informants also stood by as witnesses and gave their testimony. Upon this, all the companions gave the following verdict:
“Execute these people because the Holy Prophet (sa) has said, ‘May the curse of Allah be upon such an individual who calls people towards his own obedience or the obedience of another, at a time when there is an Imam who is present. Kill such a person whoever he may be.’”
Then, they reminded everyone of the words of Hadrat ‘Umar (ra):
“I do not deem the execution of any such person permissible for you in which I do not have a part.”
In other words, no one may be executed unless there is an indication from the government. Upon hearing the verdict of the companions Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) stated:
‘No, we will forgive them and accept their pleas. We will counsel them with all our efforts and we will not oppose anyone so long as he does not clearly violate the law or express disbelief.’
Then Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) said:
“These people have mentioned certain things which you are aware of as well. However, their plan is to debate with me on these issues so that they can return and say, ‘We engaged in a debate with ‘Uthman regarding these matters and he has been defeated.’ These people allege that whilst on journey, I offered the prayer in full but the Holy Prophet (sa) used to perform qasr whilst on journey. However, it was only in Mina where I offered the prayer in full and even that was due to two reasons: firstly, because I owned property there and I had married there; secondly,
69. A shortened version of the obligatory prayer, which is offered as such in certain circumstances. [Publishers]
because I came to know that in those days people had converged for the hajj and the uneducated from among them would begin to say that the Khalifah only offers two rak’at so there must only be two rak’at in the prayer. Is this not true?”
The companions replied, “Yes this is correct.” Then Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) said:
“The second allegation that they raise is that I have introduced the innovation of establishing public pastures, although this is a false accusation. Pastures were established before me. They were introduced by Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) and I have only made them more spacious due to the growing number of camels which are given in alms. Then, the land designated for public pastures is not the wealth of anyone. I have no benefit in this; I have only two camels, whereas at the time when I became Khalifah I was more wealthy then all the Arabs. Now I only have two camels which I have kept for hajj. Is this not true?”
The noble companions affirmed, “Indeed, it is.” Then Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) said:
“They say that I appoint comparatively young men as governors, even though I only appoint such individuals as governors who posses virtuous attributes and manners. Holy men before me appointed even younger people as governors than those appointed by me. Far more objections were raised against the Holy Prophet (sa) for appointing
Usamah bin Zaid as the General of an army than are now
being raised against me. Is this not true?”
The companions responded, “It is true. These people raise objections before the people but hide the real events.” In this manner Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) stated all the objections one by one and refuted them one after another. The companions emphatically persisted that they should be executed, but Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) did not agree and released them. Tabari states:
“The rest of the Muslims were adamant on having them
executed but Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) could not be convinced in
any way to punish them.”
This incident shows the various types of falsehood and deception which would be employed by the mischief-makers. In that era, when the press and means of transport were not as developed as today, it was very easy for these people to mislead the uneducated. In reality, however, these people had no legitimate reason to rise up. Neither did the truth support them nor did they speak the truth. All their endeavours were founded upon lies and falsehood. It was only the mercy of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) that was saving them, otherwise, the Muslims would have torn them to pieces. The companions could not have ever tolerated that the peace and security which they had achieved by sacrificing their lives be done away with in this manner by the mischief of a few wicked people. They could see that the Islamic state would crumble if these people were not promptly punished. However, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was an embodiment of mercy and he desired, in any way possible, for these people to be rightly guided so that they would not die in a state of disbelief. As such, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) would show leniency towards these people and looked upon their actions of manifest rebellion as a mere intention to commit rebellion, and would put off their punishment.
This incident also illustrates that the companions greatly detested these people. The reason being that firstly, the mischiefmakers stated themselves that only three people of Madinah were with them and no more. If other companions were also on their side, they would have named them as well. Secondly, the companions demonstrated through their actions as well that they abhorred the actions of these mischief-makers; and looked upon their deeds as being in violation of the shariah to such extent, that in their view, no punishment lesser than execution was acceptable. If the companions supported these people or the people of Madinah held the same views as the mischiefmakers, they would not have needed any further justification or excuse; and would have killed Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) there and then, and elected another person for the office of Khilafat in his stead. However, we observe that instead of these people being successful in killing Hadrat ‘Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him, their very own lives became endangered by the unsheathed swords of the companions. It was only due to the favour and kindness of the very same gracious and compassionate person—whom they sought to murder and against whom they had instigated an outrage—that they were able to safely escape. One is astonished at the malice and unrighteousness of these mischief-makers, for they did not derive the slightest benefit from this incident. Each and every one of their allegations was amply refuted and all their objections were proven to be false and unfounded. They witnessed the mercy and compassion of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and the soul of every individual bore witness to the fact that the likes of such a person cannot be found on the face of the earth at this time. However, instead of repenting for their sins, being ashamed of their cruelties, feeling remorse for their trespasses and refraining from their mischief, these people began to burn even more in the fire of rage and fury. They considered their being rendered speechless a disgrace and the forgiveness of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) as being the result of their good planning. As such, they returned whilst devising strategies to fulfil their remaining plan in the future.