Foreword

The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 2

Remember well that the notion of certain eminent companions being responsible for the disorders in Islam is absolutely false. After a collective study of the accounts of these people it cannot even be imagined that they attempted to destroy and ruin Islam for their personal interests or benefit. Those who have embarked to find causes for the emergence of dissension and discord in Islam within the community of the companions have faltered gravely. The causes of disorder arose from other quarters and the only hope for reaching an accurate conclusion is if they are investigated in these quarters. If the false narrations, which have been spread in relation to that era, are accepted as being true, not a single Companion (ra) can be absolved from having taken part in this disorder and not a single one appears to have stood firmly upon virtue and honesty. This is such an attack upon the truth of Islam, that both foundation and basis are uprooted. Hadrat Masih (as) [the Messiah] states that a tree is recognised by its fruit and due to these narrations, the fruits of the tree of Islam prove to be so bitter that no one would even be prepared to take them for free, let alone at an expense. However, would anyone who has studied the spiritual power of the Holy Prophet (sa) to even the slightest degree, be ready to accept such a notion? Of course not! It is far from reason to presume that such people who lived in the company of the Holy Prophet (sa); were his eminent and devoted Companions; were very near relatives of the Holy Prophet (sa) and all of the other Companions without exception, deviated to such an extent in merely a few years that all of them fell into conflict due to personal interests, not due to religious reasons, and this misfortune shook the very core of Islam. It is unfortunate that although Muslims do not explicitly state that the companions created disorder in order to destroy and ruin Islam, but they have accepted the narrations of such people as being true, who had not fully accepted Islam and had only made a verbal declaration of faith. Then, they have relied on the research of bitter enemies of Islam who were in pursuit of its destruction. Ultimately, therefore, such people concede that the community of the companions was, God forbid, completely devoid of virtue and honesty.

In my exposition, I shall bear in mind not to mention dates so that it is not difficult to understand and the subject does not become confusing. The real objective of this lecture is to familiarise college students with certain events of early Islam. For this reason, I shall also abstain from quoting Arabic quotations insofar as possible and shall describe events in the form of a narrative.

All educated Muslims are probably aware that signs of dissension amongst the Muslims began to prominently emerge in the era of the third Khalifah. Prior to him, in the era of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) and Hadrat ‘Umar (ra), discord never took on a serious nature. The Muslims were so united that both friend and foe believed that it was impossible to divide them. It is for this reason that people generally attribute the discord under discussion to the weakness of the third Khalifah. However, as I shall explain ahead, this is not the case.

After Hadrat ‘Umar (ra), the gaze of all the companions fell upon Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) for the office of Khilafat and thus, he was appointed for this task through the consultation of the eminent companions. He was the son-in-law of the Holy Prophet (sa) and two daughters of the Holy Prophet (sa) were wedded to him one after another. When the second daughter of the Holy Prophet (sa) passed away, the Holy Prophet (sa) said, “If I had another daughter I would marry her to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) as well.” This shows that he held a special rank of honour in the sight of the Holy Prophet (sa). He held a very unique position in the sight of the people of Makkah and was a wealthy man according to the circumstances of Arabia at the time. After Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) accepted Islam, one of the people to whom he particularly chose to preach the message of Islam was Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). The view of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) with respect to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) did not prove false and only after a few days of preaching, he accepted Islam. In this manner, he joined the as-sabiqunal-awwalun or that pioneer group of Islam which the Holy Qur’an has praised in admirable words. The degree of honour and respect that he possessed in Arabia can be understood from the incident that when the Holy Prophet (sa) journeyed to Makkah on the basis of a vision, and the Makkans, blinded by their malice and enmity, refused to grant him permission to perform the ‘umrah, the Holy Prophet (sa) proposed that an esteemed person should be sent to the Makkans to negotiate the matter. When Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) was selected for this, he replied,

“O Messenger of Allah, I am prepared to go, but if there is

anyone in Makkah who can negotiate with the Makkans

then it is Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) because he holds special

regard in their eyes. Hence, if someone else were to go, there

cannot be as much hope for success in him as opposed to if

Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) went.”

The Holy Prophet (sa) also considered this view as being correct and consequently sent Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) for the task. It can be understood from this incident that Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was looked upon with special honour even by the disbelievers.

The Holy Prophet (sa) held a great deal of respect for Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). On one occasion, the Holy Prophet (sa) was lying down when Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) arrived, but the Holy Prophet (sa) remained lying. After some time, Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) arrived, but again, he remained lying. When Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) arrived, he instantly adjusted his clothes and said, “There is a great deal of modesty in the disposition of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra), and it is in consideration of his feelings that I have done this.” He was one of those rare men who had never consumed alcohol and had never approached adultery even prior to accepting Islam. In the country of Arabia, where drinking alcohol was thought to be a source of pride and adultery a daily indulgence, these were qualities which could not be found in more than a handful of people before Islam. Therefore, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was no ordinary man. He possessed very high moral qualities. With respect to worldly rank he was exceptional. He was the foremost in Islam. The Holy Prophet (sa) was very pleased with him. Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) has declared him as being among the six men who, up to the demise of the Holy Prophet (sa), held his utmost pleasure. Furthermore, he was from among the ‘asharah mubashsharah, meaning he was one of those ten men about whom the Holy Prophet (sa) had given the glad tiding that they would enter paradise.

For about six years after he took up the office of Khilafat, no disorder of any kind arose. In fact, people were generally very pleased with him. After this, conflict suddenly arose which steadily grew so large that it could not be stopped by the efforts of any individual. Ultimately, this proved to be extremely injurious for Islam. Thirteen hundred years have passed, but its effects upon the Muslim ummah have not died away to this day.

Now the question is how did this conflict come about? Some have alleged the cause to be Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) while others, Hadrat ‘Ali (ra). Some say that Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) introduced certain innovations in the faith, which caused an uproar among the Muslims. Others assert that Hadrat ‘Ali (ra) secretly conspired to acquire Khilafat and had Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) killed by creating hostility against him so that he could become the Khalifah himself. However, both of these notions are false; neither did Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) introduce innovations in the faith, nor did Hadrat ‘Ali (ra) have him killed or took part in a conspiracy to murder him in order to become the Khalifah himself. In fact, there were other causes for this revolt. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and Hadrat ‘Ali (ra) are completely free from the blemish of such allegations. Both were very holy men. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was the person about whom the Holy Prophet (sa) had said, that he had served Islam to such a great extent that now he could do whatsoever he wished, God would not question him. This did not imply that he would not be held accountable even if he renounced Islam. In fact, it inferred that he had acquired so many qualities and had progressed so much in virtue that it was no longer possible for any of his actions to be in violation of the commandments of Allah the Exalted. As such, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was not a man who would issue an order in violation to the shariah, nor was Hadrat ‘Ali (ra) a man who would secretly conspire to assume Khilafat. As far as I have contemplated and studied there are four reasons for this horrific uprising.

Firstly: the nature of men is generally inclined towards the acquisition of wealth and stature with the exception of those whose hearts God the Exalted has particularly cleansed. Certain people who were not complete in their faith became envious upon witnessing the honour, status, success and authority of the companions. As has been a practice since time immemorial, they began to desire that these companions resign from all their responsibilities of government and hand over positions to them so that others are given the opportunity to exhibit their skill as well. They also disliked that the companions not only held State authority but also received a special share of the riches. Hence, these people continued to burn inside with jealousy. They awaited a revolution by which the government would crumble and fall into their hands, so that they could also demonstrate their talent and skill and gain worldly wealth and stature. In worldly States such ideas may be forgiven to some extent and can even be considered rational at times. This is because firstly, the foundation of worldly States is purely based upon apparent means; and a significant cause in the progress of apparent means is the introduction of new ideas and spirit into the governmental framework as well. This is only possible if old workers vacate their posts freely, leaving space for others.

Secondly: Since a worldly State receives authority in representation of the public it is compelled to respect the public opinion. It is also essential for those voicing the public view to possess substantial involvement in the organization of the works of the state. However, in a religious movement the matter is quite the opposite, where the overriding principle of all principles is to abide by a set law. Furthermore, the interference of one’s personal ideas is strictly prohibited, except with relation to such derivative institutes of the law where the shariah has remained silent. Secondly, religious movements are afforded authority from God the Exalted, and it is the duty of people who control the reins of administration to prevent people from moving out of line in religious matters. Instead of voicing the opinions of people, it is incumbent upon them to shape the views of people into the mould that has been designed by God the Exalted according to the needs of that time.

Therefore, due to not understanding the reality of Islam, such objections would arise in the hearts of those people. They failed to understand that the Islamic Khilāfat was no worldly government, nor were the companions ordinary chiefs of State. On the contrary, the Islamic Khilāfat was a religious administration which was established in accordance with the special injunctions of the Holy Qur’an contained in Suratun- Nur. The companions were those pillars of religion whom God the Exalted had made obligatory to follow in order to advance in spiritual ranks. The companions left their jobs and adopted every type of poverty and destitution, they placed their lives in danger; left the company and love of their close relatives and dear ones; said farewell to their homelands and sacrificed their sentiments and emotions; and adopted the company and love of the Holy Prophet (sa). Some of them had learnt Islam lesson by lesson, spending approximately a quarter of a century as students of the Holy Prophet (sa). Moreover, they strengthened the practical aspect of Islam by acting upon it. They understood the meaning of Islam, its purpose, its reality and how one should act upon its teachings. Additionally, they understood the benefits that could be attained by acting upon it. Hence, they were not kings and members of a worldly government; rather, they were teachers of the very last religion and law of the Seal of Prophets (sa). It was made incumbent upon them to represent Islam through their actions, speech, and conduct, and to imprint its teaching upon the hearts of people and to make them practicing followers. They were not supporters of tyranny; rather, they were supporters of the lustrous law. They abhorred materialism. If it were up to them they would have abandoned the world and sat in places of seclusion, and eased their hearts with the remembrance of God. However, they were compelled by the responsibility which had been laid upon their shoulders by God and His Messenger (sa).

·

10 of 10 left today