Foreword
The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 4
On one hand, wars ensued, while earlier influences also remained in the hearts of people. When a state of peace prevailed to some extent and initial enthusiasm also subsided, it was then that this religious weakness began to show its colours. The enemies of Islam capitalised on this opportunity and mobilised in order to create mischief. Hence, this disorder was not the result of any action of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). As a matter of fact, had these conditions developed in the time of any Khalifah, disorder would have emerged. The only fault of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was that he was elected to the office of Khilafat at a time when his involvement in creating disorder was no greater than that of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) or Hadrat ‘Umar (ra); and who can say that this conflict was the result of a weakness on the part of these two holy men? It does not cease to amaze me as to how certain people assert that these disorders were the result of a weakness of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). Hadrat ‘Umar (ra), who could not have even imagined that Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) would become Khalifah, had already identified the root cause of this conflict in the era of his own Khilafat. He then warned the Quraish in this regard with strong words. As such, it is written that Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) would not allow the senior companions to go forth for war and if they sought his permission he would say, “Is the jihad which you performed alongside the Holy Prophet (sa) not sufficient?” Once, when the companions finally complained, he said:
“I have grazed Islam just as a camel is grazed. First, a camel is born, then it becomes a calf. Then it grows two
teeth, then four teeth and then six. Then it grows canine
teeth. Now, what can be expected for one whose canine
teeth have grown except for weakness. Listen! Islam has
now reached its perfection. The Quraish desire that they
should take all the wealth for themselves, while others
are deprived. Hearken! Until ‘Umar bin Al-Khattab is
alive, he shall hold the Quraish by their necks so that they
do not fall into the fire of disorder.”
It appears from this statement of Hadrat ‘Umar (ra), that even in his own era, he noticed the views billowing in the minds of people that the companions received a greater share. For this reason, except for a few companions, without whom the armies could not be managed, he would not allow the companions to go forth for jihad so that people would not be put to trial due to the Companions receiving a double share. Moreover, he felt that Islam had now reached the pinnacle of its success and after this, only the danger of its decline remained, not a hope of further progress.
After having mentioned this much, I shall now relate the sequence of events which shed light on the reality of the conflicts that arose in the time of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra).
I have already mentioned that in the beginning of the Khilafat of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) we see no sign of disorder for up to six years. Quite the contrary, it appears that people were generally pleased with him. In fact, it is ascertained from history that in this era he was even dearer to the people than Hadrat ‘Umar (ra). Not only was he dear to the people, in fact, they were in awe of him. A poet of that era testifies to this fact in his poetic verses, in the following words:
“O rebellious people! Do not loot and devour the people’s
wealth in the reign of ‘Uthman (ra); for Ibni ‘Affan is he
whom you have experienced. In accordance with Qur’anic
injunctions, he executes those who pillage; he has always
been a guardian of the injunctions of this Holy Qur’an;
he is the one who teaches the people to act upon these
injunctions.”
However, after six years, we see a campaign in the seventh year; and this was not directed against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra); rather, it was directed against the companions or against various governors. As such, Tabari narrates that Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) took full consideration of the rights of people. However, those people who did not enjoy the distinction of being the foremost pioneers in Islam did not receive the same level of honour as the early and pioneer Muslims did in gatherings; nor did they receive an equal share in rule and wealth. Over time, some people began to criticise this superiority and deemed it to be an injustice. However, these people feared the Muslim masses and out of their fear that the people would oppose them, they would not express their views. Instead, the practice which they had employed was to secretly incite people against the companions. When they came across an uneducated Muslim or a freed Bedouin slave, they would open up their book of complaints. Consequently, either out of ignorance or due to their own desire for position, certain people would join them. Gradually, this group began to multiply and reached a large number.
When disorder is about to arise, its contributing factors also begin to accumulate in an extraordinary manner. On the one hand, those of a jealous disposition were beginning to grow incensed against the companions. On the other hand, the zeal for Islam, which is usually present in the hearts of all those who convert from other religions, began to decline amongst these new Muslims, who had neither lived in the company of the Holy Prophet (sa), nor had they received an opportunity to spend a great deal of time with those who had been in his company. As a matter of fact, as soon as they accepted Islam, it was their presumption that they had learned everything. As soon as this Islamic fervour lessened, the control which Islam possessed over their hearts also began to fall weak. They, once again, began to enjoy committing the sins that they had once indulged in before they became Muslims. When they were punished for their crimes, instead of reforming themselves, they became bent upon the destruction of those who were administering these sentences. Ultimately, they proved to become the cause of creating a great rift in the unity enjoyed by Islam. The centre of these people was in Kufah. However, the strangest thing to note is that an incident took place in Madinah itself, which demonstrates that in that time, some people were as unfamiliar with Islam as the ignorant people of today who live in the remotest areas. Himran bin Abban was a person who married a woman during her ‘iddat. When Hadrat ‘Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him, learned of this, he was displeased at him; not only did he order a separation, but also exiled him from Madinah to Basrah. This occurrence demonstrates how certain people began to perceive that the mere acceptance of Islam authorized them as being scholars of Islam. They did not feel a need for further research. Perhaps, due to an influence of various views, related to believing in unlawful things as being permissible, they deemed it a futile act to follow the shariah. This is a sole event and perhaps in Madinah, which was the centre of Islam, there was no one else who was as ignorant as he. However, in other cities, there were some who continued to advance in sins. Hence, it is ascertained from the circumstances of Kufah that a band of youths had taken root for the purpose of robbery. It is written that once they proposed robbing the house of a person named ‘Ali bin
Haisuman Al-Khuza‘i. They broke into his house at night, but he learned of this and came out with a sword. However, when he saw a large party he raised a hue and cry. At this, the group said, “Quiet! Or we shall wipe out your fear with a single blow,” and they killed him. During this time, the neighbours had become alert; they gathered around and apprehended the robbers. A Companion named Hadrat Abu Shuraih, may Allah be pleased with him, who was a neighbour of this person and had witnessed the whole incident from over the wall of his house, testified that, in fact, these people had killed ‘Ali. Similarly, his son also testified. The matter was submitted to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) in writing and he sentenced all of them to death. Hence, Walid bin ‘Utbah, who had been appointed as the governor of Kufah by Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) in those days, executed all these robbers in an open plain beyond the gate of the city. Apparently, this seems to be an insignificant event, but if one studies the conditions of that time, this was not an minor incident. With the progress of Islam, the rate of crime died out completely. People were at such peace that they did not even fear sleeping with open doors. Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) had even stopped his governors from making security posts outside their offices. Although, the intention of Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) in this was to facilitate the people in submitting their complaints to governors with ease, this order could only have been carried out until an extreme level of peace prevailed. This incident was also especially worthy of note because the children of various powerful and influential people, who possessed control in their respective spheres, were involved in this robbery. As such, this was not an ordinary crime; in fact, it was the foreshadowing of a great revolution. What else could this have been an indication towards other than the fact that the control of Islam upon the hearts of people who were unfamiliar with the religion of Islam was beginning to diminish? They were reverting to their old habits once again. Not only the poor, but even the rich were rising up to gain back their lost glory through murder and bloodshed. The Companion, Hadrat Abu Shuraih (ra), gathered this very well; he instantly sold his wealth, etc., and leaving Kufah, returned to Madinah along with his family. His having left Kufah, due to this event, is sufficient evidence that this distinct account was an indication towards the dangerous events of the future. In these very days, another disorder began to emerge as well.
‘Abdullah bin Saba, was a Jew, also known as Ibnus- Sauda’ on account of his mother. He was a resident of Yemen and was an extremely evil person. Upon witnessing the growing success of Islam, he became a Muslim with the objective of somehow creating rift among the Muslims. In my view, it is this very mischievous person around whom the disorders of this era revolve, and who was in fact a driving force in this respect. It seems as if his inclination towards mischief was ingrained in his very nature. It was a habit for him to conspire secretly and he was highly skilled in identifying such people who could serve his motives. He would speak to everyone according to their dispositions and instigate vice in the veil of virtue. It is for this reason that even sincere people would fall victim to his deception. He became a Muslim in the first half of the Khilafat of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and toured all the Muslim States in order to personally gain insight as to the circumstances of each region. However, it was impossible for him to fulfil his ends in Madinah Munawwarah. At the time, Makkah was completely disconnected from politics. Apart from the capital – Basrah, Kufah, Damascus and Fustat were the political centres at the time. First he visited these places. He adopted a practice, whereby, he searched for such people who had been punished and were therefore displeased with the State. He would visit them and stay at their residence. First, he went to Basrah and stayed with Hakim bin Jabalah, a robber who was under house arrest. He began to gather people of his own mentality and formed a party. As this was only the beginning of his mission and he was also a clever man, therefore, he would not speak openly; rather, he would call people towards mischief through subtle indications. Moreover, as was his long-standing custom, he continued his practice of admonition and exhortation as well. As a result of this, people began to develop reverence in their hearts for him and they began to accept his words. When ‘Abdullah bin ‘Amir, the governor of Basrah, came to know of this, he asked him how he was doing and enquired as to why he had come. At this, he sent a reply saying, “I am a person from ‘the
People of the Book’ who has fallen in love with Islam and wishes to stay under your protection.” Since ‘Abdullah bin ‘Amir had already discovered the true state of affairs, he did not accept this plea and said, “The information I possess about your state of affairs is in contradiction to what you claim, so leave my city.” Accordingly, he left Basrah and travelled towards Kufah. However, before leaving, he managed to leave behind the seed of disorder and rebellion and aversion towards Islam.
In my opinion, this was the very first political error that took place. Instead of exiling him, if the governor of Basrah had imprisoned him and established a charge against him, perhaps this disorder may have remained there suppressed. The very intention behind Ibni Sauda’ leaving his home was to inflame a fire of disorder and sedition by touring the whole of the Islamic Empire. His leaving Basrah was precisely in accordance with his objective. Upon reaching Kufah, he began to repeat the schemes he had undertaken in Basrah. Ultimately, he was exiled from here as well, but before moving on, he had managed to sow the seed of his mischief here as well, which later grew into very large tree. On this occasion, along with his exile, the political error that took place initially was committed once again. From Kufah he went to Syria, but was unable to find an opportunity to gain a foothold there. Here, Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) was managing the affairs of State with such excellence that neither was Ibni Sauda’ able to find such people amongst whom he could develop sway, nor could such people be found who could serve as his deputies.