Foreword
The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 5
Hence, he was forced to move on from Syria with regret and despair. Thus, he turned towards Egypt, but prior to leaving Syria he instigated another mischief.
Abu Dharr Ghifari (ra) was an extremely pious and righteous man from among the pioneer Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa). From the moment that he accepted Islam, his steps only advanced forward in the love of the Holy Prophet (sa). He remained in the company of the Holy Prophet (sa) for a long period in time. Everyone possesses a unique disposition. Thus, upon hearing the admonition of the Holy Prophet (sa) that a believer should remain detached from the world, according to his own disposition, he viewed the accumulation of wealth as being unlawful and abhorred riches. He would also admonish others not to accumulate wealth and to distribute whatever they possessed amongst the poor. He had always held fast to this habit. Even in the era of Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, when the Muslims became affluent, he held the same view. When Ibni Sauda’ was passing through Syria, he noticed an extreme ebullience in his nature against wealth and his desire for the poor, as well as the rich, to distribute their wealth. Thus, upon travelling through Syria, he met with Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra), who resided there at the time, and said to him:
“Look at the injustice, Mu‘awiyah (ra) refers to the riches of
baitul-mal as being the wealth of Allah, although the
funds of baitul-mal are not the only wealth that belongs
to Allah; everything belongs to Allah the Exalted. Then
why does he declare these funds to be the wealth of Allah in particular? Only, so that he may usurp the right that
Muslims have over these funds and after neglecting their
share, so that he may devour this wealth himself.”
Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) was already actively engaged in exhorting that the affluent should distribute all their wealth among the poor because the true abode of comfort for the beleivers is the hereafter. He was absolutely unaware of the mischief and motive of this person. As a result, he fell victim to his deception and actually began to think, that it was wrong to refer to the funds of baitul-mal as being the wealth of Allah, because there was a danger of the usurpation of wealth. In this manner, Ibni Sauda’ took revenge from Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) for not affording him an opportunity to develop a stronghold in Syria. Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) went to Mu‘awiyah (ra) and admonished him, “You refer to the wealth of Muslims, as being the wealth of Allah!” To this, he replied:
“O Abu Dharr! May Allah the Exalted have mercy on
you, are we not all the servants of Allah? Is this wealth
not the wealth of Allah? Is all creation not the creation of
Allah the Exalted? Is true authority not in the hands of
God?”
In other words, when the servants belong to God and it is His authority which reigns supreme then how would the rights of people be neglected by calling this wealth, the wealth of Allah? The rights which God the Exalted has fixed shall be given to His creation according to His command. This reply was so profound that Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) was completely speechless. However, since he possessed special fervour in this regard and Ibni Sauda had planted a doubt in his heart, out of caution, he advised
Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) to refrain from using this term. Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) replied:
“I shall never say that these funds are not the wealth of
Allah, but from now on, I shall refer to them as the wealth
of the Muslims.”
When Ibni Sauda’ found this tactic to prove somewhat effective, he approached other companions and tried to provoke them. However, they were reclusive in nature like Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra). They were aware of this person’s mischief. As soon as Abu Darda’ (ra) heard his words, he said, “Who are you to say such seditious things? By God, you are a Jew!” Left disappointed by such, he approached the chief of the ansar, ‘Ubadah bin Samit (ra), an intimate Companion of the Holy Prophet (sa), and made certain mischievous statements. He apprehended him, took him to Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) and said, “This is the man who sent Abu Dharr Ghifari (ra) to you.” When Ibni Sauda’ was confronted with failure in Syria, he left for Egypt, but his words ignited a new zeal in Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra). He began to admonish the Muslims with even greater passion than before that all of them should distribute their wealth amongst the people. It was not correct for Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) to assert that no one should accumulate wealth. The reason being that the companions never hoarded wealth, rather, they always distributed their wealth in the cause of Allah. Invariably, they were definitely affluent, but this does not constitute the hoarding of wealth. The hoarding of wealth is only an applicable term when a person does not support the poor, and does not pay charity and alms. Even in the time of the Holy Prophet (sa) some of his companions were rich. If they had not been well-off, how could Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) have afforded to provide ten thousand soldiers provisions of travel at the time of the ghazwah of Tabuk. The Holy Prophet (sa) never reprimanded such people. In fact, some of them were very dear to the Holy Prophet (sa). Hence, being affluent was no crime; instead, it was in direct accordance with the prophecies of the Holy Qur’an and Hadrat Abu Dharr, may Allah be pleased with him, was mistaken in this regard.
However, whatever the case may have been, Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) was adamant in respect of his own view. Nonetheless, it is also worthy of mention that although he would exhort people in light of his own view, he never took the law into his own hands. The commandments of the Holy Prophet (sa) forever remained under his consideration. However, the people in whose company he would sit and express these views were unacquainted with his virtue and piety and took his statements in a different light. Finally, the end result of these views was that certain poor people began to extend oppressive hands towards the affluent in an attempt to take their own rights from them by force. These people complained to Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra), who then submitted the matter before Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) issued an order for Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) to be sent to Madinah with honour and dignity. As per this instruction, Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) arrived in Madinah. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) inquired from him, “Why do the people of Syria complain against you?” He replied, “I differ with them because firstly, the term ‘wealth of Allah’ should not be used; secondly, the affluent should not accumulate wealth.” Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) explained:
“Abu Dharr (ra), it is my duty and mine alone to fulfil the
responsibility that Allah the Exalted has laid upon me.
It is also my obligation to enforce the subjects to discharge
their responsibilities, to encourage them to serve religion
and to be moderate. However, it is not my task to compel
them to abandon the world.”
Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) submitted, “Then allow me to go somewhere else, because Madinah is no longer appropriate for me.” Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) responded, “Will you abandon this abode and adopt one that is inferior to this?” He replied, “The Holy Prophet (sa) told me that when the population of Madinah extends as far as Sal‘, do not stay in Madinah.” To this, Hadrat ‘Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him, responded, “Then carry out the instruction of the Holy Prophet (sa).” After giving him some camels and two slaves, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) bid him farewell, but stressed that he should not completely sever his ties with Madinah and continue visiting every so often. Abu Dharr (ra) always acted upon this guidance. This was the fourth conflict which arose. Although Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) was used as an instrument, the fact of the matter is that neither did he hold the same views as the rebels, nor was he aware of their mischief. Despite a difference of opinion, Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) never set out to take the law into his own hands. He continued to obey the government to such an extent that in consideration of his special circumstances, even though the Holy Prophet (sa) had instructed him to leave Madinah at a certain time in order to save him from trial and suffering, he did not deem it appropriate to even act upon this command without first seeking permission from Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). Moreover, when he left Madinah and settled in Rabdhah and the local tax collector asked him to become the Imam in congregational prayer, he refused saying, “You are the governor here, thus, it is you who is best suited for being the Imam.” This demonstrates that he had no objection in being obedient to governors, nor did he view anarchy as being permissible.
The simplicity of Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) becomes clearly evident from the fact that even after being deceived by Ibnus- Sauda’, when he would argue with Mu‘awiyah (ra), that the funds of baitul-mal should not be called the wealth of Allah and even after submitting a complaint to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) as well, he constantly continued to use the same term in his own speech. Once, after this conflict, when he was in Rabdhah a caravan arrived. The people of the caravan enquired from him, “We have seen your companions and they are incredibly affluent, but why are you living in such a state of poverty?” He gave them the following response:
“They possess no right over the wealth of Allah, (i.e. the
funds of baitul-mal) which I also do not possess.”
Similarly he would also refer to the Abyssinian governor of that area as:
“A servant of the wealth of Allah.”