Foreword
The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 7
In Egypt, which was the real headquarters, even greater havoc had been wreaked. Not only had ‘Abdullah bin Saba instigated political insurgency in this region; rather, he was also ruining the religion of people. However, he did this in a manner that people who were ignorant of faith would consider him very sincere. As such, he would preach saying:
“It is strange that various Muslims hold the belief that
the Masih [Messiah], on whom be peace, would return to the world again. Yet, they do not believe that the Holy
Prophet (sa) would be raised again. However, Allah the
Exalted states in the Holy Qur’an:
‘He Who has made the teaching of the Holy Qur’an binding on
you will most surely bring you back to the place of return.’” Many of his followers accepted this teaching of his and became convinced of the [physical] re-advent of the Holy Prophet (sa) on earth, despite the fact that the Holy Qur’an strongly rejects the return to earth of those who have passed away. However, it is possible that in order to honour the name of such a person, Allah the Exalted raises some else after having endowed him the morals and attributes of that person. However, this concept is at complete odds with the belief of reincarnation or the return of a person [to earth]; this is an obvious and clear fact. In addition to this belief of raj‘at, ‘Abdullah bin Saba began to preach that thousands of prophets had passed and every prophet possessed a wasi; thus, the wasi of the Holy Prophet (sa) was Hadrat ‘Ali (ra). If the Holy Prophet (sa) was khatamul-anbiya’ then Hadrat ‘Ali (ra) was khatamul-ausiya’. Then he would say, “Who can be more unjust than a person who attacks the wasi of the Holy Prophet (sa) and snatches his right?”
Therefore, aside from the political strategies that this person employed in order to create rift in Islam, he had instigated a religious disorder as well. Furthermore, he was also conniving to corrupt the beliefs of Muslims, but took precautions to ensure that people considered him to be a Muslim.
In this state of affairs, three years elapsed and this mischievous group continued to carry out these secret conspiracies. This party continued to multiply in number. However, in this three year period no significant incident transpired except that two residents of Madinah Munawwarah named Muhammad bin Abi Bakr and Muhammad bin Abi Hudhaifah, began to take part in this disorder to some extent as well. Muhammad bin Abi Bakr was the younger son of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) and except for the fact that he possessed the distinction of being the son of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), he held no religious merit. Muhammad bin Abi Hudhaifah was an orphan who had been brought up by Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). However, after reaching an age of maturity, he played a prominent role in the uprising against Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra). I shall explain why shortly hereafter. In the fourth year, this conflict took on somewhat of a terrifying state and its originators thought that now it was appropriate to openly express their views and to wipe out the awe of the State. Consequently, in this regard as well, Kufah was first to advance.
As I have already mentioned, Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra) was appointed governor of Kufah after Walid bin ‘Utbah. From the outset he had adopted the custom of only allowing noble townsmen to come into his company. However, at times, he would also hold an open gathering when men of all types would be allowed to come into his company. One day, they were sitting in such a gathering when the subject of the generosity of Hadrat Talhah (ra) came under discussion. Someone said that Hadrat Talhah (ra) always acted with extreme generosity. In response to this Sa‘id happened to utter the words:
“He possesses a great deal of wealth, and so he is charitable;
if we also possessed such wealth, we too, would demonstrate
such generosity and munificence.”
A young man naively said:
“If only such and such property, which once belonged to
the royal treasury and had been kept for the benefit of
ordinary Muslims, had been in your possession. ”
At this, a few men who belonged to the party of rebels and were waiting for an opportunity to arise so that they could express their views, began to express their anger. They asserted that the person had made this statement on the indication of Sa‘id, the governor of Kufah; so that a pathway could be paved in order to usurp this wealth. As such, they stood up and began to beat this person right before Sa‘id. When his father stood up to assist him, they thoroughly beat him as well. Sa‘id continuously attempted to restrain them but they did not even pay heed to him; and beat the two until they both fell unconscious. When the public received news that certain people had committed such an act of mischief in the very presence of Sa‘id, they gathered outside his house armed. However, the perpetrators begged and pleaded Sa‘id for forgiveness and asked for his refuge. How could the generosity of an Arab, and then a one from the Quraish, possibly bear to refuse the plea of an enemy for refuge at such an occasion. Sa‘id stepped out and said to the public, “A few people fell to confrontation; the matter is of no significance and everything is now in order.” Everyone returned to their homes, and once again these people began to feel at ease. When Sa‘id was certain that the perpetrators were out of danger, he let them go. Then he addressed the people who had been beaten and said:
“As I have already given these people refuge, do not publicise
their crime, or I shall be disgraced. Rest assured, however,
that they shall not be allowed in my company again.”
The rebels had already succeeded in their real objective i.e. to create disturbance in the Islamic administration. Now, they had began to openly criticise Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and Sa‘id in their homes. The public was greatly offended by this behaviour and complained to Sa‘id saying:
“These people are causing mischief in this manner. They
criticise Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) and you, and seek to uproot
the unity of Islam. We cannot tolerate this; please resolve
the matter.”
He replied, “Inform Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) of all the events yourself and the matter shall be dealt with in accordance with his instructions.” All the noble people informed Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) of the events, who ordered Sa‘id that if the leaders of Kufah unanimously agreed, these people should be exiled towards Syria and sent to Amir Mu‘awiyah. Then, he wrote to Amir Mu‘awiyah (ra) saying:
“A few people, who are openly bent upon creating disorder,
shall come to you from Kufah. Make preparations for
their subsistence and devise a plan for their reform. If they
improve and reform themselves, then treat them with
compassion and overlook their faults, but if they persist in
mischief then punish them.”
This order of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) was based on immense wisdom because on the one hand, their living in Kufah would provoke the public’s anger, who was fully aware of their mischief; and there was a danger of them being incited and causing them harm; on the other hand, it was also injurious because these people were residents there and possessed a degree of influence. If they had continued to live there, they would have become a means for misguiding many others. However, this verdict was issued at a time when much benefit could not be expected. If Ibni ‘Amir, the governor of Basrah, had also sought advice from Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) regarding Ibnus-Sauda’ and a similar instruction had been given for him, perhaps latter events may have turned out differently. However, the state of the Muslims at the time demanded that such should be its fate and destiny; and so it occurred.