Foreword
The Outset of Dissension in Islam, Part 6
This demonstrates that he would use this term himself as well. Furthermore, the fact that he could not help but uttering this phrase again and again testifies to the fact that this was a general figure of speech among the companions. However, Hadrat Abu Dharr (ra) forgot this due to the deception of Ibnus-Sauda’.
This disorder, which is best described as a Bolshevik conflict, could not succeed in Syria due to the strategic planning of Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra). Nevertheless, in different forms, this view managed to spread in other regions and served as an aid in the work of Ibnus-Sauda’.
Ibnus-Sauda’ left from Syria and arrived in Egypt. This was the place that chose to make the centre of his scheme because it was very far from the capital. Secondly, the companions did not visit it as often as other areas. For this reason, the local people were comparatively less familiar with religion and more willing to take part in conflict. The deputy of Ibnus-Sauda’, who was a resident of Kufah and shall be mentioned later on, was exiled a short period after these events. When asked, in reply to the enquiry of Hadrat Mu‘awiyah (ra) as to the state of the members of this new party in different countries, he said:
“I have been in correspondence with them, and it was I
who guided them, not they. The people of Madinah are
the keenest in creating disorder, but they are the least
capable. The people of Kufah raise objections on trivial
matters, but they are not afraid of committing grave sins.
The people of Basrah attack together, but scatter when they
flee. No doubt, it is the people of Egypt who are the most
fit for mischief, but their shortcoming is that they become
regretful soon after.”
After this, describing the situation of Syria he said, “They are the most obedient to their chiefs and most disobedient to those who mislead them.” This is the opinion of Ibnul-Kawwa’ who was a member of the party of Ibnus-Sauda’. This establishes that Egypt was the most suitable place where Ibnus-Sauda’ could setup camp. When his shrewd eye of mischief caught sight of this, he selected this as his place of residence and made it a centre of disorder. It was no time before a party had gathered around him.
Now, headquarters of mischief had been established in every city. With great skill and intelligence, Ibnus-Sauda’ began to recruit such people who had either been sentenced, were relatives of such people, or were not content with their condition for one reason or another. He would express his view to such people according to their respective dispositions in order to gain their sympathy. Madinah was safe from mischief and Syria was completely free from it as well. There were three centres where the material for conflict was being prepared, i.e. Basrah, Kufah and Egypt. Egypt was the headquarters. However, Ibnus-Sauda’ had kept himself hidden behind veils, just like the experienced and philosophically minded anarchists of that era. He was the spirit behind this entire scheme but others had been pushed to the forefront. Due to being nearby and on account of the political superiority which Basrah and Kufah enjoyed at the time, the people of these two cities appear to be at the forefront of this revolution. However, if one looks closely, the pages of history clearly indicate that the reins of all these schemes was in the hands of Ibnus-Sauda’, who lived in Egypt.
I have already mentioned that a party of men robbed the house of ‘Ali bin Haisuman Al-Khaza‘i in Kufah and then killed him, after which these murderers were executed at the gate of the city. The fathers of these young men were extremely shocked by this and desired to seek revenge from Walid bin ‘Utbah, the governor of that region. They waited eagerly for an opportunity to seek revenge. These people became an excellent weapon for the rebels, and fully utilised them. In order to seek revenge from Walid, they appointed spies so that they could find a shortcoming in Walid and inform them. The spies had to report something, so, one day, they came and relayed that Walid meets with a Muslim friend Abu Zubair, who was previously a Christian, and drinks alcohol. The rebels rose up and began to announce to the whole city that this was the state of their governor. The fervour of the masses is, after all, uncontrollable. Upon hearing this, a large party joined them and they all besieged the house of Walid. There was no door as such and everyone recklessly entered through the mosque (the door to his house opened into the mosque) and Walid only came to know of them when they were standing right before him. Upon seeing them, he became perplexed and quickly hid something away under the bed. They thought that they had caught the thief red handed and the secret had now been revealed. Without uttering a single word someone promptly slipped his hand under the bed and pulled out the object. When they caught sight of it, they noticed that it was a tray with the food of the governor of Kufah and a bunch of grapes placed on it, which the Governor had hidden only in the embarrassment that such a small quantity of food had been presented before the Governor of such a wealthy province. At this, all of these people were left confounded and they turned on their heels in utter shame.
They began to reproach one another for committing such a grave crime and for having discarded the commandments of the shariah due to being deceived by a few mischievous people. In his embarrassment, Walid buried the matter and did not inform Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) of this incident. However, ultimately, this mercy of his, which he expressed to undeserving people, proved to be seriously detrimental for him and also for his deputy after him. Instead of being moved by his mercy, the rebels felt even more humiliated and began to connive for the destruction of Walid with even greater fervour than before. They went to Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) as a delegation for the dismissal of Walid. However, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) refused to dismiss the governor without crime. When these people returned they began to gather all such people who had been sentenced and collectively deliberated as to how, by hook or by crook, Walid could be disgraced. Two people named Abu Zainab and Abu Muwarri‘, took it upon themselves to devise a scheme and actively began to sit in his gatherings. One day they found an opportunity when no one else was around and Walid had gone to sleep in the men’s section, which was partitioned from the ladies section only by a sheet. The both of them slowly removed his ring and ran towards Madinah claiming to have seen Walid drunk. They asserted that the ring was proof of this and they had removed it, without him noticing, when he was in a state of intoxication. Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) inquired, “Did he drink alcohol in front of you?” They did not dare respond in the affirmative, because if such had been the case, this would implicate that they too were involved with Walid. Instead, they responded, “We saw him vomit alcohol.” The ring was at hand as evidence and two witnesses were present. In addition, a few other mischievous people accompanied them as well in order to further strengthen their testimony and continued to furnish circumstantial testimony of the incident.
Counsel was sought from the companions and it was decided that Walid would be punished for the consumption of alcohol. He was summoned from Kufah to Madinah and lashed as a penalty for drinking. Although Walid defended himself and informed Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) of their mischief, but Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) responded:
“According to the law of the shariah you must receive a
punishment as per the testimony of these witnesses. Of
course, a person who gives false testimony shall be punished
by Allah the Exalted.”
Walid was deposed on a false account, but according to the counsel of the companions, Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) sentenced him. Since witnesses and circumstantial evidence was present against him, it was necessary for him to be punished according to the law of the shariah. Sa‘id bin Al-‘As (ra) was made the governor of Kufah and sent in his place. When he went to Kufah and saw the state that prevailed there, he was shocked. The delinquents of society and those who were unfamiliar with religion had primarily taken control and the well-mannered had been subjugated and suppressed. He informed Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) of the matter, who advised him to restore the respect and honour of those who had offered great sacrifices and came forth to fight the opponents in earlier times. If, however, they demonstrated a lack of interest in religion, then of course, he could replace them with those who were more pious.
When this mischief had broken out in Kufah, Basrah was not at rest. Through Hakim bin Jabalah, an agent of Ibnus- Sauda’, and his accomplices, false allegations were being spread against the deputies of Hadrat ‘Uthman (ra) there as well.