Text
Political Solidarity of Islam
Political Solidarity of Islam
Fatwas of Kufr and their significance
Political Solidarity of Islam
A Timely Warning to Muslims
Pat.was of Kufr and their Significance*
When evil days come upon a people God causes the judgment of their leaders to become warped and they begin to indulge in activities which bring destruc· tion on their own heads and prove fatal to those who follow them. I have noticed of late that the leaders of a _section of the Muslims are passing through that phase. I know that they are not the acknowledged leaders of the whole Muslim Community nor do they wield any very great influence with all the Indian Muslims. Their activities are largely confined to the Punjab and to the territories contiguous to it. The rest of India is, to a large extent, immune from the poisonous effect of their baneful activities. And even in the Punjab and the provinces adjacent to it, their influence does not extend to all the Muslims. Only the urban Muslims are under their influence and of these particularly that section of the Muslims in Lahore and Amritsar is affected by their agitation who have become used to creating mischief and disorder as a result of constant wranglings and bickerings with the members of other communities.
It is human nature that when a person does a certain thing once or twice, he feels impelled to do it again and again. This is why persons who are used to picking a quarrel with other people become easily excited and are inclined towards creating mischief and disorder. In the past few years, due to political differences the inhabitants of a few towns in the Punjab had become dissatisfied with the existing state of affairs and had lost their peace of mind. Naturally a section of them, whether they be Muslims, Hindus or Sikhs, seem to have become deprived of their balance of judgment and on causes too trivial and trifling burst into anger and are led to commit acts which are detrimental to their own interests. Since urban. opinion, as a rule, leads the rural, the activities in the towns have their repercussions in the countryside. But a few towns such as Lahore, Amritsar, Sialkot, Gujranwala, Ludhiana and Batala alone are the hot-beds of all heat and agitation. Sialkot of late appears to have cool¢d down, perhaps because that section of its in-
tp d,isturb the peace have realized their m~stake or h'?1ving tired qf creating constfi.nt disorder are taking rest. By that secticm of pebple to whom I have referred are meaμt the Ahrars and by their mischievous campaign I mean those activities which for some time pai:;t they have been carrying on against the Ahm~diyya; <;:orμmunity. These activities are so obvio\lsly injurious and detrimental to the· best interests of the Muslim <ommunity that sometime I am left in doul:>t whether the Ahrar leaders. themselves have set them on fqot or they are m~re . tools in the hands of more sinister influences which are work~ng from behind the curtain, -some. individuals or groups who realizing that th~ Ahi:nadiyya Community stands in the way of their dealing an effective qlo.w to Muslim interests hav~ initiated them and the Ahrars are mere pawns in thi.s.
any clear and irrefutable proof to satisfy my doubts,
l. all) forced back to the concl\lsion that this section of
Muslims is an unfortunate victim of the perversio~ of
'j"udgment -which has affected their faculty of <lis'ting'uish~ ing between good and evil,
The Ahrar activities against the Ahmadiyya Community have been carried on for some time past without interruption or abatement of zeal. In the Conference that was held at Qadian last October great stress was Iaid on the fact that the Ahmdis should not be regarded as Muslims. To raise such a question at the present time, when the Muslims are already in a minority in India and are passing through extremely difficult times and their very existence is in danger, does
·not at all speak well for the intelligence and political
foresight of the A hrar leaders.
. A few years ago at a political meeting of the
Maulana Mohd. Ali the same question was raised. A Maulvi from Bihar il) the course of his speech said that the Hindus had derived great strength from the existence of the Sikhs as a distinct and separate politi. cal entity inasmuch as the latter being in a minority demand weightage; and in a lighter vein the Maulvj suggested that this accession of strength .to the Hindus' political power could be countermanded by excluding the Ahmadis from the main Muslim Community arid
hy asking them to demand, as a minority, reprei;;enta· tioh in excess of their numbers. The said Matilvi wasz
however, severely taken to task by Maulana Muhamma.d Ali who sternly told him that such fl. suggestion whicq was opviously at variance with Muslim inte.rests, if carried in to effect, would add to the disr.uption of the already hopelessly divided ranks of the Muslim Com. munity. But then this question was raised in a province like l3ihar and the president of the meeting was a per~oil of Maulana M uhafuin~d Ali's calibre and political foresight and now it 4a.s been raised in the Punjab . and py people like Maulvi Zafar Ali, Ch, f\faal Haq, Maulyi Hal?ibur Rahman and Syed At~ Vllah Shp.h Bokhari. These gentlemen seem tq think that by demanding our exclusion from the Muslim Community they are damaging our interests. But in rto conceivable fuahrier can our interests suffer. We
are. said to be 56,000 at present. . But though grossly
under-estimated we were not 58,000 even at the tinie of the last census and now when five years have elapsed since the last census was taken our numbers must certainly have swelled. But even if we are considered to number not more than one lac at present the Government, in view of the principle that minorities get representation in excess of their actual numbers, shall have to allot us at least one seat in the Legislative Council. Thus the number of the Muslim members in the Legislative would become less by one and if in view of exceptional circumstances as nomination. for instance, one more Ahmadi goes to the Council, Muslim seats which are generally considered to be 89 in the future provincial Assembly would be reduced to 87 and thus in a total strength of 175 members the Muslim majority would turn into a minority and Muslim interests as contemplated by the Ahrars would receive a severe set-back. But the well-known Persian adage, ("O Ayaz: know thy real worth") aptly illustrates the real position of these Ahrar leaders. Since when have they become the spokesmen of the Muslims ? Who has given them the right and the authority to exclude from the ranks of the Muslim Community whomsoever they like ? A vast majority of the Punjab Muslims do not attach to their opinions as much weight as they would to the opinion of a person of ordinary intellect. It is one thing for the Ahrar leaders to assert and claim that they are the real representatives of the entire 8 crores of Indian Muslims and quite another to prove and substantiate .such an extravagant claim. Could they tell us how many of these 8 crores of Muslims whose leaders and spokesmen the Ahrars claim to be, raised their voice of protest against the public statement that was recently issued by some very highly-placed Muslims regarding the Ahmadi v. non-Ahmadi controversy?
As many as 9 or 10 members of the Legislative Assembly i. e. 1/3 of the total Muslim strength in that body appended their signatures to the above statement and even more members would, in all probability, have done so if they could get the opportunity. Some members of the Council of State also signed it. Almost all the members from Sind signed that statement, a majority of th~ Muslim members from Bihar also were among its signatories and so were a majority of the Bengal members. An appreciable number of the l'unjah members also joined them. Thus out of the 8 crores ,of Indian .Muslims whose cause, the Ahrar leaders allege, they repref?ent, the representatives of the 3 crores of the Bengal Muslims in the Assembly and of tll,e 30 lacs of the Bihari Muslims and the representatives of 1/3 of the Muslims of the Punjab which comes up to about 40 lacs, and of the 30 lacs of the l\1uslims of Sind, by a$sociating themselves with the above statement have shown that at least! of the entire Indian Muslim Community do not view with favour the present activities of the Ahrars against the Ahmad.is. Of the remaining 4 crores as well there is nothing
tp prove that they reg~rd the Ahrars as their represen-
tatives. Only the views and opinions of those persons
of highest intellect and ability whom the 1\1 uslim
Community have elected as their representatives will carry weight and not of those whose lead no one is prepared to accept. So when the acknowledged spokemen of about 4 crores of the Indian Muslims have openly condemned and viewed with disfavour the present activities. of the Ahrars against the Ahmadis and the remaining 4 crores have remained silent, the Ahrars' claim of Muslim leadership is demonstrably shown to possess no foundation in fact. After all on what basis does this claim of their leaders4ip rest? By what peculiar methods these self-styled leaders have ascertained the Muslim opinion and have found it to be in their favour. Let alone the entire 8 crores of Indian Muslims the Ahrars cannot possibly prove themselves to be the leaders and spokemen of even the whole of the Punjab Muslims. A few weeks ago in the party that was given in honour of Ch. Zafarullah Khan, 80/'0 of the members of the Punjab Council participated, which means that at least as many Muslims of the Punjab regard the Ahrars as mere mischief-makers. They may now assert that Ch. Asadullah Khan's unopposed return to the Punjab Council was due to a technical mistake on the part of the rival candidate but how can the Ahrars ignore the fact that when some time back Ch. Zafarullah Khan was a candidate for the Sialkot constituency, the Ahrars, inspite of all their efforts and by using all their resources, could not get ev~ a single person to .op.pose the Chaudhri Sahib. If the Ahrars were the accredited leaders of the entire 8 crores Muslims, how did Ch. Zafarullah Khan come to be returned unopposed to the Punjab Council ? And is it not a fact that 'in the last by-election, when Maulvi Mazhar Ali, an Ahrar leader, and Sh.
Ata Mohd stood from the same consti• tuency and the Ahmadiyya Community offered to help the latter gentleman, Maulvi Mazhar Ali conveyed to me through Sh. Bashir Ahmed, advocate, his request for enlisting Ahmadiyya support. If the Ahrars were the acknowledged leaders of the 8 crores of the Indian -Muslims, why did Maulvi Mazhar Ali feel the need of our support which incidentally was refused because he did not consent to give us his request in writing as was required of him. So it is wrong to say that the Ahrars are the spokesmen of the entire Indian Muslims. Eight crores is a very large number. They cannot honestly claim to be the representatives of even 8 rp.illions. Anyhow this high sounding claim is ill-based and obviously detrimental to Muslim interests .
.As a matter of fact the very principle on which the A hrars proceed is wrong. We have never inade any distinction between ourselves and the other Muslims while d~manding political rights for them. We have always supported the general Muslim demand, and for the attainment of this object have made sacrifices beyond our means. We raised our voice against the Nehru Report while the Ahrars supported it.. We assisted the Indian Muslim Delegation to the Round Table Conference, distributed useful political literature among them, while the Ahrars kept quiet all along. The Ahrars again have always supported joint electorates, and have vigorously worked in this behalf whereas a majority of Muslims are decidedly against the principle of joint electorates. The proposal of excluding a part of the Muslim Community, emanating from such a faction whose claim to represent 8 crores of Muslims is utterly baseless, is extremely ridiculous and injurious to Muslim interests.