Text

Political Solidarity of Islam, Part 2

But the question is, who is there to exclude us from the Muslims ? What right or justification have Government to say that they would not regard us as what possible connection there is between the numbers of a community and the profession of their faith ? Even

if there was a single Ahmadi in the world, no power on

earth could turn him out of the pale of Islam. One's faith is a matter of one's profession. Who is there so audacious as to dub a man a non-Muslim and seek to expel him from the Muslim Community when the latter protests that he is a Muslim ? So the very question of the expulsion of the Ahmadis from the Muslim Community is manifestly absurd. As long as we protest that we are Muslims, no power can exclμde us from the Muslim Community. It has been said that we forfeit our right to be Muslims by styling other people as Kafirs. But our calling other people Kafirs only means that we consider ourselves alone as true Muslims. Is it then possible for anyone to turn really true Muslims out of Islam? Our only offence, ifoffence. it can be, which makes us forfeit our right to be part and parcel of the Muslim Community is that we do not regard other people to be as true and good Muslims as we regard, ourselves. We are sought to be expelled from the Muslim Community on this plea. But what an absurd plea! If that is the offence which renders us liable to expulsion and excommunication, then I would say with all the emphasis at my command, that this is an offence which is very freely committed by all the Muslims. Is there any sect of Muslims which has· not been styled as Kafir by the other sects and vice versa. Has not Maulvi Zafar Ali Khan himself been. under a fatwa of K ufr and Maulvi Habibur Rahman and Syed Ata Ullah Shah Bukhari too? These Ulema indulge in the game of kafir-making as a pastime. If in the vast ocean of Kitfr which already existed, we. added another drop, why should they lose temper over it? They themselves have made Kufr very cheap.

According to the religious belief of men of their own ranks any person a part of whose trousers falls below his ankle is a Kafir, any person who while saying his prayers folds his hands above his navel is a Kafir, any person who raises his fore-finger while praying in sitting posture is a Kafir. Why then these people who themselves are so adept in dubbing other people as Kafirs over such trifles have lost their not show that there is either something of unusual significance in our calling them Kafirs, ot else it is mischievous on their part to raise a hue and cry ovet it. Do not the Shias style' the Sunnis as Kafirs and 'Oice -oersa. And do not the Ahl.;i-Hadith call the H anafis Kafirs and the latter call the former Kafirs, and is it not a fact that the Chakralwis style the n.on- Chakralwis as Kafirs and the latter retaliate by stigmatising the Chakralwis as Kafirs. The Chakralwis even go so far as to declare that the non-Chakralwi Muslims consider the Holy Qur’an as abrogated and what sort of a Muslim is he who believes that the Holy Qur’an has been abrogated. On the other hand the non• Chakralwis allege that the Chakralwis have disgraced the Holy Prophet (peace by upon him) and it requires no great intelligence to understand that a person who disgraces the Holy Prophet cannot be looked upon a-s a Muslim. If to the great storm of kafir-making raised by these people we have added a handful of dust, we do not think we have done anything bvet which they should have lost their heads. This strange attitude of theirs reminds one of the story of the wolf and the lamb who were drinking water from the same stte·am, the wolf being high up the stream and the lamb down stream'. The wolf who had a design to devour the Iamb and was in search of an excuse said to the lamb, " ate you not ashamed of yourself that you are making the water dirty while I am drinking."

The larrib meekly replied that it was not possible for her to make the water dirty as she was drinking at a point down-· stream. On hearin'g this the wolf pounced upon her saying, "What! have you become so audacious as to make a reply to met'' and devoured her. Similarly these people out of vanity and relying upon their superior numbers, say to us that we should not include ourselves among the Muslims as we call other M·uslitns Kafirs. But don't they look to their own Fatwas printed in decorative ·designs, and published under the anthoiity of ten, twenty, thirty, forty, fifty or even a thousand Ulema, in the form of charts which can be hung on the walls, if one liked, .as a decoration. Why ate not these self-styled representatives of the 8 crores Muslims of India provoked and why is not their jealousy for Islam and the Holy Prophet excited when they see these fatwas of their own Uleina ? It is, therefore quite wrong to say that this hue and cry is due only tC: the fact that we call them Kafi:rs, for it is a crime of which they are much more guilty than we :are.

Moreover, there is a great deal of difference bet\J\reen our definition of K ufr and theirs. They understand by J(ufr to mean the denial of Islam, which is the meaning we do not ascribe to this term when using it about the non-Ahmadis. Our view is that if a petso11 conforms to the tenets and teachings of Islam to a given extent, he is entitled to be called a Muslim. But when he falls below even that point then although he may be called a Muslim, he cannot be regarded a perfect Muslim. We never allege on the basis of this definition that every Ka/fr is doomed to hell-fire for ever. We do not call even the Jews and the Christians to be Kafirs of that description. On the other hand. we believe, that every Hindu, Sikh or Christian or even an atheist will ultimately find the grace of God and finally God will say to him, " go and enter heaven". So there lies a vast difference between the two view., points. Under their definition of Kufr they consign ·a person to everlasting perdition. Spiritually it grinds to atoms the person to whom it applies. For him there is no hope, no salvation. But we call others Kaftr~ only technically. According to our definition of Kufr it is quite possible that a person who dies a Kafir may go to heaven on account of some good in him, and his want of faith may be overlooked on account of his ignorance of the true faith, or on account of the real teachings having not reached him. On the other hand it is quite possible that a man, apparently a Muslim, may be sent to hell, because he failed to act up to the requirements of the faith. A Hindu, a Christian, a Jew; an atheist, a Sikh and a non-Ahmadi, dying in a state of Kufr, according to our belief, may be admitted to heaven, on the ground that as far as it lay in his power he endeavoured to cultivate piety, did good deeds, and that there was no opportunity for him to be acquainted with the true teachings of I slam. Similarly it is possible that a man styling himself an Ahmadi who does not act up to the teachings of Ahmadiyyat may go to hell. There lies, therefore, a world of difference between the term of Kufr ~s used. by us alld the one used by them. Our definition of Kujr as compared with theirs is like a tiny atom as compared with the sun. Then why should they fume and fret over our calling them K affrs ?

It is being emphasised nowadays that the Ahmadis call non-Ahmadis Kaftrs. If this allegation is honestly made, then let the Ahrars come forward and prove that it is we that took the offensive in this respect. The fact is that it is they that began the battle and they were the first to call us Kafirs. They are morally bound to find out who threw down the challenge and took the initiative in issuing Fatwas of Kufr. Even now they are daily saying and writing in their newspapers .that Ahmadis are Kajirs. Can they prove that any Ahmadi newspaper has been guilty of thus calling the Ahrars Kafirs? He who calls another person a Kafir without rhyme or reason hurts his feelings and provokes a quarrel. We never do that. It is only when we are asked by a person as .to what we think of him and we are compelled to give an answer that we say we take him to be a Kafir in the sense in which this term has been explained above. Although our answer in. that case is always in reply to their question but even then they resent it and seek to pick a quarrel. What answer possibly can we give to a person who is dark-coloured when he asks .our opinion about his. complexion except that he is dark-coloured and not fair. What would you call such a person who picks a quarrel on that account? This inexplicable attitude of these people reminds me of ah interesting incident which sometime back occurred to a doctor in the Army. He told me that he was asked by the wife of an officer who was a :Major in the Army, how old he thought she was. The said doctor was in a fix. He knew that English ladies felt offended if even in compliance with their own request they were told their correct age if that happened to be a bit advanced. He therefore tried to dis_suade the lady from asking him that awkward question but she w:ould accept no e:iccuse. and insisted on .knowing her age. The doctor then computed within his mind that being the wife of a Major sh~ must at least be 36 or 37 and he thought that she would be satisfied if he told her that $he was only 27. But she .flew .into a. rage when ,the poor:

doctor .told her he thought she was 27. These people are like that lady. They insist upon knowing what we think of them and when we tell them what we think of them they resent it -and say we call them Kafirs.

I have noticed it many a time that it is the Ahrars or the Lahore Seceders (members of the Ahmadiyya Anjuman-i-Ishaat-i-Islam, Lahore) who take a special interest in starting this questio11 which has no bearing on the Muslim social or political. requirements. It does not profit us in any manner to know what others think of us. What really matters is that we should try to co-operate with each other as far as possible and we should avoid dragging in the discussion about our respective beliefs in such matters. We may want to know the beliefs of a person when, _for instance, he intends to contract new matrimonial relations with us. But what connection, on earth, there is between the politics of the lndian Muslims and their sectarian beiiefs. We have never raised this q~estioh. It was the late Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din, who by his speeches and writings, at first, started this question of

Kuf1' and Islam in our Community. We have never

felt the need or necessity to raise it. It is the Lahore Seceders to whom the late Khwaja Sahib belonged who sometimes feel irresistibly inclined to revert to this question thinking that a discussion of it would frighten away the orthodox Muslims from us. But in spite of their efforts to set people against us they come to us for being accepted into the Ahmadiyya Community and do not go to them. The saying of the Holy Prophet " Thou shalt not overstep thy measured limit," aptly applies to them. They spare no pains, leave no stone unturned to discredit us. But all their efforts and endeavours only result in the increase of our num hers and do not benefit them in any way. Similar is the case of the Ahrars. People will surely begin to look with contempt on their propa~ ganda when they realized the real state of affairs and came to kno"w that this question which was calculated to disrupt the political solidarity of the Muslims was raised not by the Ahmadis who always avoided it but by the Ahrars. I take this opportunity to proclaim once more that we do not define K uj1' in the same terms in which they do, nor do we attach the same

$ignificance to it as they do. We do not say that every Kafir is predestined to go to hell. We believe that. the term Kafir applie$ to a person after he has

takes Islam as his religion and accepts the injunctions in the Holy Qur’an and teachings as his guide of action, he is entitled to be called a Muslim. But if he denies a basic principle of the faith of Islam then although he may be called a Muslim yet in reality he is not so. We do not therefore take Kafi,'I' to mean that such a person denies the Holy Prophet Muhammad {peace be upon him). Who can say to a person who says that be believes in the Holy Prophet that in reality he has no such faith ? Nor do we take this term to mean the denial of the existence of God. One who says that he has belief in God, who can dare say that he has none? According to our definition of Kuft' the denial of a fundemental doctrine of Islam renders a person Kafit'. On the other hand only belief in all the es.sen.tials of lslam can make a person a true Muslim in the real sense of the word. But we do not at all regard a Kafi'I' to be foredoomed to hell. A Kafir according to our belief could go fo heaven. We will call a person Kafi'I' who, for instance, has throughout his .life remained unacqqainted with Islam, but God

will not sel)d him to hell on that account only because

through no fault of his he did not come to know of Islam and God is not so cruel as to punish an ignorant person. So when we use the term Kuf'I' we use it in the above sense only. But we never go about calling a person Kafir. It is only when we are compelled in answer to the enquiry of a person to say what we tbink of hi:rp. that we have to give expression to our belief. But with the definition of Kufr as given by the non- Ahmadi$ as our basis of judgment we would not regard as Kajirs even the Hindus, the Jews, the Christians or the other non-Muslim communities, because we believe that there exists no such community whose every mem her is foredoomed to everlasting hell. ,from among ali communities and nations-from among the Hindus, the Jews, the Christians, the Sikhs, and even from among the athiests-some individu~ls

will, acco.rding to their deserts, be admitted to heaven.

Q.μr beJief is that if an atheist is born and lives in a country where he has not the means to become acquainted with the true religion; say, for instance, he lives in a mountainous region, far away from all contact with civilization and religion but he leads his life in strict conformity with the laws of nature, and does good to others, abjuring all evil ways and practices and acting unjustly towards nobody, such a one in spite of his atheistic views and beliefs, will go to heaven.

·

10 of 10 left today