Text
Political Solidarity of Islam, Part 3
If the agitation that is now being carried on against our Community with such vigour and virulence had possessed some weight and _substance, it should have been based on honesty, which evidently it is not. Only day before yesterday I saw a statement in the papers by Sir Mirza, Zafar Ali in which he says that the Ahmadis are not Muslims, that the Government is wrong in considering them to be a part of the Muslim Community and that if the Government wishes to regain the confidence of the Muslims it should look upon the Ahmadiyya Community as a minority separate and distinct from the other Muslims. It is surprising to note that the same Sir Mirza Zafar Ali, barely a year ago, at the time of the election to the Punjab Council wrote to me two letters in which he confessed that he was not hostile to our Community and that like other sects of Islam he looked upon the Ahmadis as a part of the Muslim Community. These letters are safe with us and they could be published if Sir Zafar Ali were to deny their authorship. Now when Sir Zafar Ali stood as a candidate to the Punjab Council and required our support he considered us Muslims and requested that though on some doctrinal points he differed with us he should not be -·refused Ahmadiyya support on account of that difference. He went so far as to write about one of the rival candidates that he was a sinful transgressor and an evil-doer whereas he himself was a strict observer of the Islamic prayers and on that account alone deserved our support. If we are really Kafirs, is it consistent with reason for a person holding the honour of Knighthood and having been a High Court Judge to say of himself that he is a strict observer of the Islamic prayers and therefore deserved our support?
In his letters Sir Zafar Ali admitted that he treated the Ahmadi$ as he trea!ted other Muslims and that he looked upon the Ahmadis with the same feelings with which he looked upon other Muslims. He ·did not even hesitate ·to stigmatise one of his rivals as a person of loose moral character. Even after what Sir Zafar Ali has written in the Press regarding us, I extend to him the 'Courtesy of not disclosing the name of the Muslim gentleman about whom he used such disparaging remarks lest he might be sued for defamation. But is it, I again ask, in keeping with honesty or with any principles of morality that a year ago Sir Zafar Ali should have taken us to be Muslims and now should ask the Government to exclude us from the Muslim Community? He cannot take shelter behind the plea that he was unaware of our beliefs at the time, for the Siasat of Lahore was in those days writing a series of articles against us in which the Promised Messiah, the Holy Founder of our Movement, was alleged to have laid claim to Godhead and to have been a denier of the finality of the Holy Prophet Muhammad's prophethood and to have shown disrespect to other prophets and Sir Zafar Ali had himself written an appreciatory note about these articles which evidently shows that he had read the Siasat articles against us and he approved of them. So Sir Zafar Ali cannot plead ignoran~e of the Ahmadiyya beli~fs or at least of the beliefs that were ascribed to us. In the face of all these beliefs, however, he regarded us as Muslims which fact he even acknowledged in his signed letters. What new belief has now come to light that has led him to think that the Ahmadis are not Muslims? It is perfectly clear that h~s present attitude towards the Ahmadis is due not to his jealousy of Ch. Zafarullah Khan's being made a member of the Viceroy's Executive Council but is due
to his failure to get out support in his own favour in
the Council elections. So if the name of Sir Zafar Ali be written in place of Ch. Zafarullah Khan's and the words "the Punjab Council" be substituted instead of the words "the Viceroy's Executive Council," it would be nearer the truth. Is it, I ask, in harmony with honesty or does any moral code allow it, that a person who only a year ago regarded us as Muslims should now address a letter to the Governor saying tha.,t Ahmadis are not Muslims and- that therefore they
shoqld- be excluded, from the Mm1lim Community? Is it b~~ause by supporting his riyal we came under Sii: Zafar: AJi's displeasure that we deserve tp be expelled f.rom the Muslim Community?
If the Ahrars. honestly believe that they are· the·
real representa.tives of the 8 crores of the I.ndian Mus-. lims then why do they seel~ to exclu,de us from: the. Muslim Community? When they know that the entire Muslim Community is with them and we are inno constituency in a majority, then instead_ of excluding· us from the Mttslims, they shou,ld, on the contrary,· have insisted on our inclu,sion in them, as being everywhere in a minority there was clearly no possibility of any Ahmadi being returned to the Legislature while if created into a separate minority we would be entitled· tp at least one seat in the Legislatu.re. Their insistence 1:1pon our separation from the Muslim Community cJearly demonstrates that the Ahrar leaders. are convinced in their heart of hearts that the 8 crores. ofr Muslims are not with them and that instead of support,. ing them in the matter of election they would give us· their support, By demanding our expulsion from the Mμslim Community they wish to deprive us of the benefit, which they are afraid,, we would derive if we_ Qontinued, to remain within the Muslim Community •.
If the Ahrars thi11k that the whole Muslim Community
is with them, then why are they afraid of our remaininK within it. If, for instance, the Sialkot constituency, a,s, they claim, is solidly with them, then all possibility of Ch. Zafarullah Khan or for that matter of any other Ahmadi candidate being returned to the Council from that constituency or any other constituency, entirely d;isappears, and therefore instead of demanding our exclusion they ought to have insisted on our remaining in the Muslim Community and thm;1 to ha,ve hepefited by one seat which in case of our separati9n.- tbey would have lost. This opposition, therefore, is not at all based on hone,sty. The Ahrars may, if they so desire, exert their utmost against us but in our' opposition they should not at least part compan_y with honesty and moral obligations. But what is now actually happening is this that a man, say from Jamm1;1, at first, addresses me as the Kha.lifatul l\([asih and;
professes to be friendly towards the Ahmadis and against the Ahrars. Then he gets it into his head to become a leader and throwing consistency to the winds, at once begins to indulge in anti-Ahmadi activities. The self-same Sir Zafar Ali of whom I was speaking, addressed me a letter when Sir Shadi Lal was retiring, and after using the Islamic expression, Assalam-o-Alaikum, i.e., "God's blessing be on you," requested me to send Rs. 50 in order that I might also be included among the Muslim hosts of the proposed farewell party but to-day we have become Kafirs in the sight of the self-same gentleman. Sir Zafar Ali was foremost among the organisers of the party given to Sir Shadi Lal but when a party was to be given to Ch. Zafarullah Khan he was, all of a sudden, reminded that the Ahmadis were not Muslims, as if Sir Shadi Lal was a thorough-going Muslim and it was Sir Zafar Ali's religious duty to join the party given to him but Ch. Zafarullah Khan being a non-Muslim it would have amounted to Kufr to participate in the party that was given in his honour. This is not what justice would dictate. It is a palpably obstinate attitude and such an attitude is never conducive of good results for any people. I, therefore, invite the attention of the Ahrars, though they may not accept my advice and I also invite the attention of other people though they too may ignore my advice, that the great majority of the Muslims should try to realize the real motives that are working bthind this opposition to the Ahmadiyya Community. The real object of this agitation is not to show whether we are Muslims or not. The Ahrars have, in fact, realized that they cannot succeed in injuring the interests of the Muslims in face of the Ahmadiyya Movement as was proved by their failure at the time of the Nehru Report. Therefore they seek first to remove the Ahmadis from their way. Or perhaps they think the Ahmadis are an obstacle in the way of the Muslims getting some benefits. Anyhow they have realized that because of the existence of the Ahmadiyya Community they cannot hope to popularise some of those ideas among the Muslims which they consider to be good for them but which as a matter of fact are harmful to their best interests. They, therefore, want to have a free field for themselves by removing the Ahmadis from their way.
Printed at the Ripon Printing Press, Bull Road, Lahore By Mirza Muhammad Sadiq. and Publittheri
by Malik Fazal Buuain, Manager, Book Depot Talif-o·Isha'at Qadian (Punjab-India.)