Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 12
72 The Holy Qur’an 9:128. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 89 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 73 * too shall be refuted, insha’Allah.
THE HOLY QUR’AN’S STAND CONCERNING APOSTATES:
Now, against the forgoing arguments, I present the verses of the Holy Qur’an that clearly deal with the subject of apostasy, but there is no mention at all that death is its punishment. On the contrary, the subject is so very evident that there remains no place to entertain the opinion that the punishment of apostasy is death.
THE FIRST VERSE:
Allah the Exalted says:
"In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. When the hypocrites come to thee, they say, 'We bear witness that thou art indeed
* Allah Willing. [Translator] === PDF-Seite 90 === 74 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam the Messenger of Allah.' And Allah knows that thou art indeed His Messenger, but Allah bears witness that the hypocrites are surely liars. They have made their oaths a shield; thus they turn men away from the way of Allah. Evil surely is that which they have been doing. That is because they first believed, then disbelieved. So a seal was set upon their hearts and consequently they understand not."73
Apparently they are saying the truth but in reality they are telling a lie as they do not believe in their hearts what is on their lips. Pertaining to the subject this is the first instance that has come to our knowledge where God Himself is bearing witness that some persons have turned into apostates. That was not possible for men to know, but God knows the secrets of the hearts. He Himself bears witness that though some persons are verbally making a confession of faith, but they are lying and they have nothing to do with the religion—they have become apostates! Then Allah says: 'They have made their oaths or declarations of their faith a shield; thus they turn men away from the way of Allah. Evil surely is that which they have been doing. That is because they first believed. Then, after that they disbelieved i.e. they have openly become apostates. So a seal was set upon their hearts and consequently they understand not. 73 The Holy Qur’an 63:1-4. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 91 === 75 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam They have become staunch apostates now that all the doors of repentance in their hearts have been shut! And they themselves do not understand what is happening to them.
THE HOLY PROPHETSA AND HIS COMPANIONSRA KNEW WHO WERE THE APOSTATES:
Who were those people? Did the Holy Prophet and his Companions have any specific knowledge of them or not? If they had the knowledge, then, after having such strong and certain evidence that not only that they had turned apostates but also that there was no chance of their repentance, then why an order for killing them was not issued? Or, why none of them was killed on the command of the Holy Prophetsa? For their identification the Holy Qur’an goes on to say that there are specific persons, about whom you (i.e. believers) know; but in spite of this knowledge you call them and say "Come [and repent so] that the Messenger of Allah may ask forgiveness for you,"74 It is not said here that the Messenger of Allah will kill them as soon as they repent because this is the punishment of apostasy that is enjoined by Allah. Not at all! What is said here is an invitation to come and repent! And if they repent, then the Messenger of Allah
74 The Holy Qur’an 63:6. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 92 === 76 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam will also seek forgiveness for them. What else could be done? And "they turn their heads aside (in arrogance), and you see them keeping back while they are full of pride." And they stop others too from coming forward. They are continuously doing so and "they are full of pride."75 In the light of these verses of the Holy Qur’an, it is evident that God did not command to kill the apostates even when Allah, Who knows the secrets of the hearts, Himself was a witness to their disbelief, and the Holy Prophetsa and his Companionsra knew well who they were. They were specifically invited to repent! Those apostates kept on stopping others from joining Islam. They were arrogant and proud, and they persisted in their crime. Despite all these factors, the Holy Prophetsa did not ask anyone to kill them.
MESSENGER OF GOD’S TREATMENT OF THE CHIEF OF THE APOSTATES:
An amazing incident is recorded in the Holy Qur’an concerning the chief of the hypocrites. Allah had informed the Holy Prophetsa about him by telling him his name. Knowing the merciful heart of the Holy Prophetsa that he would try to seek forgiveness for him, Allah commanded him not to perform his funeral prayer.
75 The Holy Qur’an 63:6. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 93 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 77
"And never pray thou for any of them that dies, nor stand by his grave (to pray); …"76
That hypocrite remained alive among the Muslims. He continuously derided the Holy Prophetsa and was so disrespectful that at one place the Holy Qur’an states:
"They say, 'If we return to Medina, the one most honourable will surely drive out therefrom the one most mean;' …"77
‘Abdullah bin Uba’i bin Salul had arrogated himself the title of the "most honorable" and (we seek protection from Allah from this) he called the Holy Prophetsa "the one most mean"! Here, Allah, the Exalted, did not mention the name of the Holy Prophetsa. The wisdom in doing so was that the Companionsra could reverse the order of the persons referred to in this verse. And that’s what happened. One of the Companionsra talking about this
76 The Holy Qur’an 9:84. [Publisher] 77 The Holy Qur’an 63:9. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 94 === 78 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam event submitted to the Holy Prophetsa: "O, Messenger of Allah! He speaks the truth! The most honorable man on the earth (that is, the Holy Prophetsa) will drive the meanest man, the chief hypocrite, out of Medina." That wretched person, the chief of the hypocrites, despite all his expressed insults, was kept alive. He roamed arrogantly in the streets of Medina unchecked, and tried to turn others to become apostates! He made his own group. At the time of war, they deceived and defected. He committed all sorts of atrocities; hurled all kind of abuses. Despite all that, the Holy Prophet’s attitude towards him was such that, seeing the condition of his heart, Allah had to command him saying: O, Muhammadsa! and do not seek forgiveness for him. 'Even if you seek forgiveness for them [the hypocrites] seventy times, Allah will never forgive them.'78 There was no one more obvious and confirmed apostate than Abdullah bin Uba’i bin Salul. Show us if you can find any! And also show us if you could find any better and splendid treatment than the treatment anyone would have received from any quarters! Now you are daring to make these claims! And you are trying to blemish the illustrious character of the Holy Prophetsa, making it look contrary to the teachings of the Holy Qur’an! You should feel ashamed that you are making filthy accusations against a personsa who was the most kind and loving! You are trying to defame his 78 The Holy Qur’an 9:80. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 95 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 79 religion in the world!
The Second Verse:
Allah, the Exalted, says:
"And a section of the People of the Book say, 'Believe in that which has been revealed unto the believers, in the early part of day, and disbelieve in the latter part thereof; perchance they may return;'"79
It is reported in the Tafsir books that this verse was revealed after the Christian delegation of Nijran had visited the Holy Prophetsa in Medina. And the visit of the Nijran delegation took place in the later years of Holy Prophet'ssa life. By then the Islamic State was well established. This provides definite proof that at that time when the Nijran delegation’s visit took place there was no trace of the idea of death penalty for apostasy. How was this possible that the People of the Book could suggest to their own brothers to believe in
79 The Holy Qur’an 3:73. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 96 === 80 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam the Holy Qur’an in the morning and then to commit apostasy in the evening?80 At that time, the Islamic State was firmly established and the People of the Book were fully subjugated. If they knew the prescribed punishment for the act of apostasy was death, then they could never dare suggest this behavior to their companions. If we accept the stand taken by those who believe in the death penalty for apostasy, then obviously those People of the Book who were advised to adopt the above behavior would have considered the advisors as completely out of their minds! Did they not know that if they recanted their faith in the evening after accepting it in the morning, then in consequence Muhammadsa and his Companionsra would behead them instantly? It just proves that they did not have any reason to fear of committing apostasy in the evening if they believed in the morning.