Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 13
THE THIRD VERSE:
80 Sirah Ibni Hisham, Qudumi Wafdi Nasara Najran. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 97 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 81
Here is the subject of apostates’ killing is fully dealt with. The Holy Qur’an says:
"How shall Allah guide a people who have disbelieved after believing and who had borne witness that the Messenger was true and to whom clear proofs had come? [It was not only a verbal commitment; they had disbelieved after witnessing clear Signs!] And Allah guides not the wrongdoing people."81
But the Ulema of today know the art of providing guidance by the dint of sword! About the punishment of the said apostates it has been declared that:
"Of such the reward is that on them shall be the curse of Allah and of angels and of men, all together." [It is not said that all of them shall be murdered!] "They shall abide thereunder [in that condemned condition.] Their punishment shall not be lightened nor shall they be reprieved; except those who repent thereafter and amend. And surely (they shall find that)
81 The Holy Qur’an 3:87-90. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 98 === 82 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful."82
THE FOURTH VERSE:
"Surely, those who disbelieve after they have believed and then increase in disbelief, [if they were to be killed immediately then how could they increase in their disbelief?] their repentance shall not be accepted. and these are they who have gone astray [and thus enhanced greatly in sin]. As for those who have disbelieved, and die while they are disbelievers, there shall not be accepted from anyone of them even the earthful of Gold, though he offer it in ransom. It is these for whom shall be a grievous punishment, and they shall have no helpers."83
82The Holy Qur’an 3:88-90. [Publisher] 83 The Holy Qur’an 3:91-92. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 99 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 83 A CROOKED REASONING:
I understand that some ulema argue from the verse ["their pardon will not be accepted"] that Islam prescribes death penalty for apostasy. However, the next verse refutes this argument. Allah says: 'As for those who have disbelieved, and die while they are disbelievers,'. What is not said here is i.e. they were killed while they were disbelievers, meaning that they died a natural death while they were disbelievers and were not killed having apostasized. Then it is said: "No ransom shall be accepted from anyone of them even though it be earthful of gold." This phrase makes the meaning clear. Here, acceptance of their repentance in this world by other humans is not mentioned at all. And as they would die in a state of disbelief, there shall not be any bargaining with them even on the Day of Judgment. And nothing shall be accepted from them as ransom even if they offer gold equal to the mass of earth or anything other than that. For such, there shall be a grievous punishment, and they shall have no helpers.
THE FIFTH VERSE:
Allah Says: === PDF-Seite 100 === 84 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam
"O ye who believe! if you obey those who have disbelieved, they will cause you to turn back on your heels, [that is, they will take you out of your religion and push you back in disbelief], and you will become losers."84
Here, it is not stated that if you returned to disbelief, you shall be killed. If for apostasy the prescribed penalty was death, then it should have been mentioned here.
THE SIXTH VERSE:
"Those who believe, then disbelieve, then again believe, then disbelieve, and then increase in disbelief, [as it is not the established law—the Sunna—of Allah to forgive them,] Allah will never forgive them nor will He guide them to the way. Give to the hypocrites the tidings that for them is a grievous 84 The Holy Qur’an 3:150. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 101 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 85 85 punishment."
Here again it is mentioned that they will first believe, then recant and become disbelievers; and then again they would become believers and once again they will become disbelievers and increase in their disbelief! But for such persons, there is no mention of being killed by the hands of the Muslims. What is stated is only this: O Prophet! give them the tidings that from God is a grievous punishment for them.
THE SEVENTH VERSE:
"…And whoso from among you turns back from his faith and dies while he is a disbeliever, it is they whose works shall be vain in this world and the next. These are the inmates of the Fire and therein shall they abide."86
This verse also states that the works of the apostates shall be vain in this world and in the Hereafter. And they will have Fire as chastisement on
85 The Holy Qur’an 4:138, 139. [Publisher] 86 The Holy Qur’an 2:218. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 102 === 86 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam the Day of Judgment. There is no reference at all in this verse that they will get any corporal punishment by the hands of others in this world! On this topic there are other verses, too, which deal with apostasy, but ‘killing’ is not prescribed in anyone of them. On the contrary, their subject matter most clearly presents evidence against killing.
THE VIEW OF DEATH PENALTY FOR APOSTASY IN THE LIGHT OF AHĀDITH:
Now, I come to Ahadith. When the ulema cannot find anything in the Holy Qur’an in support of their views, they turn towards Ahadith. This attitude is permissible only to the extent if we cannot find, because of our ignorance, any verse in the Holy Qur’an dealing with a specific matter and we wish to seek help from Ahadith. But we cannot make a Hadith to overrule the Holy Qur’an. That was exactly the inviolable principle adopted by the Holy Prophetsa. In itself I have no objection to referring to Ahadith. But those whom I have mentioned earlier—who did not care to misuse the Holy Qur’an—cannot refrain from misusing Ahadith too. Those who did not respect the Word of God and forced their misplaced ideas upon it, we should not expect from them that they would not treat Ahadith in the same manner. And that is exactly what they do. === PDF-Seite 103 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 87 AHĀDITH ADOPTED BY THE SUPPORTERS OF DEATH PENALTY FOR APOSTASY.
THE FIRST HADITH:
A Hadith concerning ‘Abdullah bin Abi Sarh is presented that he had once been a scribe of the Holy Prophetsa, however the Satan led him astray. At the time of the fall of Mecca, the Holy Prophetsa gave orders for his killing. Later, Hadrat ‘Uthmanra sought refuge for him which the Holy Prophetsa granted87. So according to some, this is the Hadith that substantiates killing of the apostate! Those representing the testimony, in addition to their crooked arguments, have committed unfairness by concealing the background of the event from us. They have tried to give the impression that as soon as the man apostatized, the Holy Prophetsa gave orders for his killing, and then awaited his capture for this purpose. Most certainly nothing of this sort took place. The actual fact is that this man was one of those criminals who had exceeded all limits and who were thus exempted from the general pardon after the fall of Mecca. Just as, despite the exemption from the general pardon, many were mercifully forgiven by the Holy