Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 23

"And the same fate should befall Deobandis and Wahabis, including Maulana Muhammad Shafi Deobandi, Member, Board of Talimat-i- Islami attached to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan, and Maulana Daud Ghaznavi, if Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyad Muhammad Ahmad Qadri or Mirza Raza Ahmad Khan Barelvi, or any one of the numerous ulama who are shown perched on every leaf of a beautiful tree in the fatwa, Ex. D. E. 14, were the head of such Islamic State. And if Maulana Muhammad Shafi Deobandi were the head of the State, he would exclude those who have pronounced Deobandis as kafirs from the pale of Islam and invlict on them the death penalty if they come within the definition of murtadd, namely, if they have changed and not inherited their religious views."150

150 Report of the Court of Inquiry, Punjab Disturbances of 1953 – Page 219.

[Publisher] === PDF-Seite 170 === 154 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam

MAUDŪDĪ’S RIGIDITY

There is another interesting reference in the writings of Maulana Maududi in which he expresses his disagreement regarding the fact that all born Muslims should be considered Muslim. He says that he will not accept such people as Muslims in an Islamic regime; rather he will give them a year’s notice. They will be told that in view of their being apostates for all practical purposes, they will be at liberty to verbally reject the truth of Islam and declare that Islam is a false religion. If this is done they will be forgiven and pardoned. [How much the Maulana longs to hear Muslims to declare Islam false]. However, if they do not follow this and a year goes by and they remain in the state of apostasy, then they are warned that they will be killed and wiped out. Alternatively they will be forced to observe that particular Islam which the regime considers to be Islam. He writes:

‘The Muslim population of the region where an Islamic revolution takes place should be issued a notice that those who have in belief and in deed rejected Islam and wish to remain disaffected, should within one year of the date of announcement, make a formal declaration of being a non-Muslim and leave our communal system. After this duration all those born in the === PDF-Seite 171 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 155 lineage of Muslims shall be considered Muslims. All Islamic laws shall be enforced on them. They will be compelled to follow all religious obligations and duties. After this, whosoever steps outside the sphere of Islam will be killed’. 151

No one should be misled by Maududi Sahib’s words here that ‘all those born in the lineage of Muslims shall be considered Muslims’ because in an excerpt referred to earlier Maududi Sahib had given out an edict about those Muslims that the condition of the Muslims is such that out of 1000, even 999 are not true Muslims. This means that these Muslims are born non-Muslims. The fact is that the Prophet of Allah says that each child is born in the true nature, that is, Islam. These are the intentions of these ulema and this is their concept of Islam and this is their opinion concerning freedom of conscience.

APOSTASY AND THE HISTORY OF THE PROPHETSAS

Now I shall present to you one last observation which is interesting, but in one respect very painful, too. It will be the final word on this subject. The Holy Qur’an presents a comprehensive and

151 Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun Mein. Page 80-81. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 172 === 156 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam authentic history of the Prophetsas covering long eras. It has preserved vast historical details from the time of Adamas till that of the Prophet Muhammadsa. It informs us about the beliefs and practices of all the Prophetsas; morals and lifestyle of their followers; and in contrast the beliefs and behaviour of their opponents. The Holy Qur’an has preserved all this in great detail, giving us a systematic and continuous historical record. Narrations covering Hadrat Nuhas up to the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa, concerning their opponents and what discussions took place between them—all are preserved in the Holy Qur’an.

THE BELIEFS OF THE ENEMIES OF THE PROPHETSAS

It is evident from the Holy Qur’an that all who opposed the Prophetsas held without exception the position that anyone who left his religion and became an apostate must be subjected to dreadful punishment. Hence if there is a consensus of opinion, it is a consensus among all the enemies of the Prophetsas and not among the Prophetsas nor among their true followers. The Holy Qur’an says that God was on the side of His Prophetsas, and He cursed those who upheld this tenet and tried to execute it. The Holy Qur’an condemns them who believed in punishing converts by death, burning them alive, and throwing them out of homes or imprisoning them. === PDF-Seite 173 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 157 AS HADRAT NUH WAS ACCUSED OF BECOMING AN APOSTATE:

Thus the Holy Qur’an tells us about Hadrat Nuhas that his people accused him of apostasy and that he was attempting others to change their religion, and – "They said, 'If you desist not, O Noah, thou shalt surely be one of those who are stoned.'"152

They warned him with unanimity that if he did not desist, if he did not repent from his apostasy and did not cease to make others apostates, they were certain he would be stoned to death. Therefore, if the ulema of Quetta have given the verdict that Ahmadis are apostates, and they have declared them out of Islam against their [Ahmadi's] wishes and announced that their punishment is stoning to death—that they should be put in the ground and then stoned to death—then this is not a new claim. Earlier, the opponents of Hadrat Nuhas had made exactly the same claim.

152 The Holy Qur’an 26:117. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 174 === 158 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam VERDICT OF APOSTASY AGAINST HADRAT IBRAHIMAS.

Concerning Hadrat Ibrahimas, the Holy Qur’an narrates that he was warned by his father:

"Do you turn away from my gods, O Abraham? If you cease not, I shall surely cause you to be stoned to death. Now leave me alone for a while."153*

The attitude of Abraham’sas father was adopted by his people also, and they invented a new way to punish apostasy. They said,

"They said, 'Burn him and help your gods, if at all you mean to do anything.' We said, 'O fire, be thou cold and a means of safety for

153 The Holy Qur’an 19:47. [Publisher] * Some of the view that it was his uncle who repute him so, but the Holy Qur’an

·

10 of 10 left today