Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 22
Raushni mein, pp 30, 31, Idara Tulu‘i Islam Ashraf Press Lahore. [Publisher] 141 Tafsir Tarjamanul Qur’an, Vol. 1, Zamzam Company Ltd., Lahore.
[Publisher] 142 A‘azmul Kalam fi Irtiqa’il Islam, Vol. 1, First Edition, Haiderabad
Daccan, 1910. [Publisher] 143 Sirat Muhammad ‘Ali by Ra’is Ahmad Ja‘fari, First Edition, Kitab
Manzil, Lahore. [Publisher] 144 Islam aur Masihiyyat, Thana’i Barqi Press, Hall Bazar, Amritsir, 1941.
[Publisher] 145 Qatli Murtad ki Shar‘i Haithiyyat, Third Edition 1987, Idara Adbiyat
Islamiya, Multan. [Publisher] 146 Punishment of Apostacy in Islam, Idara Thaqafati Islamiya, Pakistan.
[Publisher] 147 Report of the Court of Inquiry, Punjab Disturbances of 1953. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 164 === 148 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam IS MAULANA MAUDUDI SERIOUS?
Maulana Maududi had said that if one reflected realistically on the contemporary Muslims, one would realise that they are not Muslims at all. Now, we have to resolve the issue whether he was serious in this fatwa of his. Take note about what he had to say about those who forsake Jama‘ati Islami. He says, warning those who renounce Jama‘ati Islami, and not those who forsake Islam:
‘This is not a path on which going forward and retreating is the same. No, here retreating means apostasy.’148
If forsaking Jama’ati Islami and joining another community is apostasy then the other community can be nothing but an embodiment of kufr.
THE OBJECTIVES OF THE MULLAHS
So what are their objectives? If they could have their way—and indeed the manner in which they are seizing control over the Government of Pakistan and in this they are fully supported by a global conspiracy against Islam—what would they do? The Court of Inquiry to enquire into the Punjab Disturbances of
148 Maududi, Ru’idadi Jama‘ati Islami, (Compiled by— Shu‘ba’i Tanzimi
Jama‘at) Part I, page 8, Maktaba Jama‘ati Islami. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 165 === 149 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 1953 reflected on the issue of the possible outcomes of this belief. The sitting judges Justice Munir and Justice Kiyani wrote that in the genuine Fatwa (Ex. D. E. 13) by the Diyubandi Darul ‘Ulum the Shias are Kafirs and Murtad (apostates), and:
"According to the Shias all Sunnis are kafirs, and Ahl-i-Qur’an, namely, persons who consider hadith to be unreliable and therefore not binding, are unanimously kafirs, and so are all independent thinkers. The net result of all this is that neither Shias nor Sunnis nor Deobandis nor Ahl-i-Hadith nor Barelvis are Muslims and any change from one view to the other must be accompanied in an Islamic State with the penalty of death if the Government of the State is in the hands of the party which considers the other party to be kafirs."149
Today Islam is in danger from within the world of Islam. This is a most horrific conspiracy that is being led today by the American ‘colonization’. The countries under the influence and domination of USA are pushing forward the death penalty for apostasy. These oppressors aim for the Muslims to destroy each other rather than to divert their attention to them. They are fully aware that the weak [Muslim] governments
149 Report of the Court of Inquiry, Punjab Disturbances of 1953 – Page 219. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 166 === 150 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam which are totally dependent on their aid, are fed by them, get their weapons from them, would not ever dare to kill any Hindu, Christian or Jew. Indeed if their wrath was to descend on anyone it would descend on the fellow Muslims. If they were to destroy anyone it would be Muslims alone. They would have one Muslim sect declare another Muslim sect apostate, and have the sect with the greater sway destroy the one deemed by it as weak and apostate. A calamity would thus fall on the world of Islam and the rest of the world would curse the followers of the religion (as well as the religion itself) who regard the shedding of blood of their own brethren permissible and remain busy cutting each other's throats. This is the essence of the western conspiracy against Islam.
OLD WAYS
This scene has been enacted before within the Islamic world and is not a mere supposition. In actual fact, the countries where the Muslim governments have been in the clutches of the mullah, or where oppressive Muslim rulers have used the religious scholars to support them in achieving their objectives, a most horrendous performance has been staged in the name of death penalty for apostasy, the thought of which, even today, make hairs stand on ends. I shall present before you some incidents of the era of the Abbasid King Mamun and of the subsequent === PDF-Seite 167 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 151 period. Some extremely truthful, God-fearing, pious and scholarly Muslims were crucified for the crime of having a belief that the Holy Qur’an is a ‘creation’. However, when the era changed and a person who himself was of the belief that the Holy Qur’an is a ‘creation’ held the office of Khilafat, he ordered the killing of all the scholars who did not consider the Holy Qur’an a ‘creation’. The blood of venerable Muslims thus went on spilling in the streets for the crime of apostasy, whereby death was the punishment of apostasy and the argument for deeming them apostate was merely the fact that, in the light of Tanzihi*. Attributes of God, they had declared the Holy Qur’an a 'creation'. This was indeed a most horrific and cruel era, but then this was not the only era, rather there is a myriad of such brutal episodes that stigmatise the Muslim regimes. To this day, the free world feels hatred and contempt for Islam and its adherents because of this ignominy, and considers Islam an ignorant faith belonging to the dark ages. Today these religious scholars do not seem to have learnt lessons from this. They are devoid of any sense of shame. They keep on forcibly attributing beliefs, against the Holy Qur’an and Sunna, to Islam which are
* Those Attributes of Allah which exclusively belong to Him and cannot be
shared by His creation as His being All Knowing. Others like kindness, love, can be shared by his creation and are called Ghair (Non) Tanzihi. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 168 === 152 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam infact un-Islamic and thus carry on making the history of Islam murky and gory. However, now that the mullah has become used to this kill, he is not easily going to let go. If the world of Islam does not wake up and does not dismiss the dominance of the mullah as rubbish, and if the mullah is not forced to keep religious affairs separate from politics and to refrain from hurting the faith of Islam and to limit himself to preaching righteousness, prayer and worship, then the dreadful history will repeat itself! The present situation is backed by great political powers which wish Muslims kill Muslims, and Islam be destroyed by the world of Islam itself.
AN IMPORTANT EXCERPT.
I shall now present another excerpt from the Court of Inquiry and then move on to the conclusion of this subject. The Court of Inquiry acknowledges: "Apostasy in an Islamic State is punishable with death. On this the ulema are practically unanimous." That is to say that only the religious scholars who appeared before the court unanimously concurred with this issue. Here the court is not referring to the renowned religious scholars who did not attend the court proceedings who hail from Pakistan as well as various other Arab countries. The court could not refer to them. Such scholars, currently as well as in the past, have striven against the punishment of death for apostasy, they have performed === PDF-Seite 169 === 153 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Jihad against the opinion and have written books. Therefore the court most certainly does not mean that all religious scholars were unanimous on this viewpoint, rather only those who had attended the court. The Court states: