Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 4
As far as the whim that no matter what kind of
*Religious divines who are entitled to issue a fatwa, or religious edict. [Publisher] 12 Note that the Assembly—that passed the definition according to which the
Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama‘at is declared outside the pail of Islam—was composed of only these two types of people! [Author] 13 Ibid Page 95. === PDF-Seite 40 === 24 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam human beings they are is concerned, once they have achieved democratic power, and the representative status from the populace, then their fatwas must necessarily be considered legitimate and their 'definition' must become acceptable—I would give a reply to such an idea, again, in the words of Maududi Sahib. He writes:
'A democratic election has the exact analogy of the process of churning to extract butter.14 If the milk is poisonous, then the butter that will be extracted from it would naturally be even more poisonous than the milk itself. … Thus, those who have this whim that if the areas characterized by Muslim-majority are freed from the hegemony of the [overall] Hindu majority and a democratic order is established in them then this will result in the establishment of a theocracy*, their conjecture is wrong. In fact, as a result of this, what would be achieved would only be the Disbelievers’ Government** by the Muslims.'15
But these are the assertions of yesterday. Today, a different litany is being heard. Is this how Islam 14 What a great analogy—there is no denying it! But notice, also, the
conclusion he draws from it. [Author] * Hakumati Ilahi; literally, "Government of God". [Translator] ** "Musalmanun ki Kafirana Hakumat". [Translator] 15 Ibid Page 132. === PDF-Seite 41 === 25 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam changes its colours? Or, for that matter, does any statement of truth takes such twists and turns and acquires a variety of appearances and shapes? He writes further:
"In our case, the nation that is given the appellation of "Muslims" is filled with all kinds of riffraff. This nation has as many types of [malefactor] characters as are to be found among kafirs."16
DEFINING APOSTASY
Now, I turn to the question of defining apostasy. ‘Allama Raghib wrote in his lexicon, Al-Mufridat:
The words Irtidad and Riddatu mean, ‘to return on the same path as one had traversed earlier’, however the word Riddatu is specifically used to indicate a return to kufr
16 op cit. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 42 === 26 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam [disbelief], whereas the word Irtidad may be used to indicate a return to disbelief or to any other matter, Allah says: 17 ["Surely those who turns their backs"] and Allah says: 18 ["O ye who believe! whoso among you turns back from his religion"].19
The latter verse illustrates the usage to indicate 'returning from Islam to disbelief'.
A GREAT SUBTLETY IN THE WISDOM OF GOD
The word "Irtidad" is exclusively used in active sense, and it can never be used in the passive sense. That is, only such a person is called a murtad [i.e., an apostate] who himself announces that he is relinquishing the faith. The rules of Arabic grammar certainly do not permit someone else to declare him a murtad and throw him out of faith. The volition of a murtad is, inevitably, implied here. God has chosen such a remarkable word to describe apostasy as [it emancipates] every Muslim from any unilateral intervention in his faith by anyone else. The Holy 17 The Holy Qur’an 47:26. [Publisher] 18 The Holy Qur’an 5:55. [Publisher] 19 Mu‘jamu Mufradatil Alfazil Qur’ani [known as Al-Mufradat] by ‘Allama
Husain bin Muhammad, known as Imam Raghib, Al-Asfahani, under Radda. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 43 === 27 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Qur’an, too, provides a definition along the same lines. It says:
"And say, 'It is the truth from your Lord; wherefore let him who will, believe, and let him who will, disbelieve.'"20
NOBODY HAS THE RIGHT TO CALL ANYONE A ‘KAFIR’
The act of ‘willing’ is associated with one’s heartfelt desire. The Holy Qur’an has not, under any circumstances, permitted anyone that if he wants he can declare so and so to be included among the faithful and, if he so desires, declare so and so to be a disbeliever. Instead, it has been granted as a volitional right of everyone to profess his or her faith and freely announce it. Thus there is no room left for anyone to coerce others in matter of faith. For the verdict has been given:
20 The Holy Qur’an 18:30. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 44 === 28 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam "let him who will, believe, and let him who will, disbelieve."21
But if apostasy [irtidad] is punishable by death, or if disbelief [kufr] is punishable by death, then what meaning can be attributed to the phrase "let him who will"? One’s 'will' can only be arrived at by one’s own self. Thus, if someone is asked, "Do you want to become a kafir or remain among the faithful?", and he replies, "I am one among the faithful—I am a Muslim", then—since the act of ‘willing’ is associated with one’s own heartfelt desire the Holy Qur’an does not, in any way, grant permission to another person to state how someone else’s heart feels about his faith.
THE HOLY QUR’AN’S VERDICT ON THE IDEA OF CAPITAL PUNISHMENT FOR AN APOSTATE
I will now present a few verses that exemplify Islam’s marvelous teaching regarding freedom of religion and, subsequently, I will advert to those arguments that are advanced by the ulema to legitimize capital punishment for an apostate.
21 ibid. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 45 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 29 FIRST VERSE:
Allah the Exalted says:
"There should be no compulsion in religion. Surely, right has become distinct from wrong; so whosoever refuses to be led by those who transgress, and believes in Allah, has surely grasped a strong handle which knows no breaking.22 And Allah is All-Hearing, All- Knowing."23
This verse presents a profound piece of wisdom. The theme presented here is directly opposite to the contemporary practice. Allah has not stated here that: 'You have a right to prevent people from becoming apostates.' Rather, Allah has said: 'Nobody has the right to force you to give up your faith.' Allah says: 'Since the truth has become manifestly obvious, and since there is no compulsion in matters of religion, you [O people of faith!] are not expected to use 22 Or, alternatively, now that hand is not going to let go of that