Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 3

Today, the definition being given runs counter even

7 This Hadith only mentions his recital of the part La ilaha illAllah, i.e.,

‘There is none worthy of worship except Allah’—he had not even uttered the remainder, Muhammadur Rasulullah, i.e., ‘Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.’ [Author] * Prayer beseeching God to cover up a sin. [Publisher] 8 Sahih Muslim, Kitabul Imani, Babu Tahrimi Qatlil Kafiri Ba‘da Qaulihi:

La ilaha illAllah, Hadith No. 277, 278, 279. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 32 === 16 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam to this third definition. How is it possible that this Hadith escaped the attention of the ulema? Today, the ulema are openly proclaiming that any Ahmadi, who recites La ilaha illAllah, would deserve to be put to death. We cannot tolerate it, under any circumstance, that an Ahmadi may recite La ilaha illAllah, or that he may go round wearing a badge of La ilaha illAllah on his lapel. The fatwas have gone to such limits as to declare that: 'if now we ever caught any Ahmadi in the act of reciting La ilaha illAllah, we will dismember his nose and ears!' Some fatwas have gone to the extent of declaring that it becomes obligatory upon every Muslim to kill any such Ahmadi who recites La ilaha illAllah, Muhammadur Rasulullah. And the argument they advance in support of their position is the one that has already been rejected by the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa. Their argument is: we prescribe this because La ilaha illAllah does not reside in their hearts; it only flows upon their tongues. It is astonishing. Such an act of transgression against that Spiritual Mastersa whose devotional servitude they continue to profess. This constitutes an open revolt, and they insist on continuing in this rebellion. And, due to this rebellion, they practice such high-handedness and persecution that they are forcing the government authorities that they should follow the lead of the ulema and officially declare the legitimacy of a general massacre of all those Ahmadis who proclaim to adhere to La ilaha illAllah, Muhammadur === PDF-Seite 33 === 17 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Rasulullah—i.e., 'There is none worthy of worship except Allah, Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.' Thus, as far as defining a Muslim is concerned I have found only these three definitions, and I like only these three definitions. Apart from these definitions of a Muslim given by the Holy Prophetsa himself I am not ready to accept any other.

LAME EXCUSE BY THE ULEMA

It is interesting to note here that, commenting upon the finding by the Report of the Court of Inquiry that ‘no two ulema were able to agree to any single definition’, the ulema subsequently voiced their criticism alleging that they in fact were not given adequate time and were thus not prepared to answer the question regarding the definition of a Muslim; were they granted enough time, they would certainly have succeeded in formulating a definition on which they unanimously agreed.9

9 Murtada Ahmad Khan Maikash Durrani, Muhasiba ya‘ni ‘Adalati

Tahqiqati Fasadati Punjab (1953) ki Report par aik Jami‘ aur Baligh Tabsirah, Page 38, Published by Daily Nawa’ie Waqt, [i.e., Calling to Account: A Comprehensive and Eloquent Comment on the Report of the Court of Inquiry into the Disturbances of the Punjab (1953)]. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 34 === 18 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam

A DEFINITION CONCOCTED BY THE ULEMA

Thus, they had to wait for a long time. When numerous years elapsed after the anti-Ahmadiyya Movement of 1953, then in 1974, the ulema were able to complete their preparatory work and they invented a definition of Islam that has absolutely nothing to do with the Holy Foundersa of Islam, or the Holy Qur’an and Sunna. A negative element was introduced in this definition, i.e., a Muslim is one who does not just affirm faith in La ilaha illAllah, Muhammadur Rasulullah, but he must also affirm that Mirza Ghulam Ahmadas, Qadiani was an impostor and thus, clearly and unreservedly, deny his prophethood. Unless a person becomes a "Muslim" according to this definition, he cannot be called a Muslim.10 The new door that has been opened in this definition has spawned many an evil outcome, and many more evil outcomes will follow. However, the main objection that applies to this particular definition is that a definition is supposed to be universal—free of time frame, and free of any geographical boundaries. It is inadmissible that a definition that could not be applicable during the time of the Holy Prophetsa should

10 Refer to National and Capital Registration act, under the section 4(1)(A)

promulgated by the Directorate General of Registration (Ministry of Interior) the Government of Pakistan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 35 === 19 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam be accepted today as correct. Only that definition will be acceptable which would first find application in the time of the Holy Prophetsa and, thereafter, goes on finding application in every subsequent era—without having even a single moment to elapse in which that definition becomes inoperative. Moreover, that definition may not just apply to the case of Pakistan, but it must find applicability, without exception, in every country of the world whether it is in the East or West, and whether it is in the North or South. But this particular definition is strangely flawed in that it cannot be made applicable to the pre-1974 period. It cannot be applicable even to the time of the Promised Messiahas because a multitude of Ahmadis have died prior to the formulation of this particular definition— they departed from this world in a state of being described as Muslims, long before this definition was invented. In the absence of this definition, and owing to the fact that nobody’s mind had conceived of such a definition, they were to be considered Muslims contrary to this definition. Then, there is the case of all those Muslims who existed prior to the time of the Promised Messiahas. What would you say about them? Because they, obviously, did not deny the Promised Messiahas, so for them only La ilaha illAllah, Muhammadur Rasulullah was enough. Thus, a definition which cannot find application in the earlier times is wrong and inapplicable even in this day and age. === PDF-Seite 36 === 20 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Should the ulema's rejoinder to this be that because in the earlier times there was no false prophet in existence the erstwhile definition could not possibly have found any reference to a false prophet, then there could not be a more blatant lie than this.

Because, Musailamah Kadhdhab, the impostor claimant to prophethood, who advanced his claim as a rival to the Holy Prophetsa was a contemporary of the latter. Despite the presence of this false claimant to prophethood, the Holy Prophetsa, did not modify the definition of a Muslim, nor did his successor Caliphs change the definition of a Muslim, nor did the tabi‘in [the generation of the followers of the companions of the Holy Prophetsa], nor even the taba‘ tabi‘in [the generation of the latter’s followers] brought about any such modification, nor did the generations that followed thereafter changed the definition of Islam. Was it so because it just did not occur to the Holy Prophetsa that until he incorporated the clause about the denial of an impostor prophet, his definition of a Muslim would not become complete? Now what is your reply to this? Search the entire world of Islam and show us a single instance of an application of this criterion—prior to 1974—according to which a Muslim cannot be considered a Muslim at all until and unless the denial of a false prophet is inevitably introduced as part of the definition governing his being a Muslim. === PDF-Seite 37 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 21 THE DEFINITION CONCOCTED BY MAULANA MAUDUDI

Apart from all these definitions Maulana Maududi Sahib has come up with a definition of his own. He has not set out this definition in any detail, but has presented its applied version. I would like to present an excerpt from a book of his, so that you can see for yourselves whether a look at the faces of contemporary Muslims in Pakistan would, as is implied by his definition, show the appellations 'Muslim', 'Kafir' written on their faces. Since the present regime is pro- Maududi, and the ulema of Wahabi school of thought presently hold sway over the government, it is necessary to present Maududi’s definition to you at this stage. In his book Musalman aur Maujuda Siyasi Kashmakash (Muslims and the Contemporary Political Strife) volume 3, Maududi Sahib writes:

"This gigantic horde that is called "Muslims", in reality 999 out of every thousand of its members neither have any knowledge of Islam nor are they able to distinguish between the truth and falsehood. Their moral viewpoint and mental attitude has also not undergone any transformation under Islam. A grandson inherits a Muslim name from his father just as the father inherited it from his own father—that is the sole reason why they happen to be === PDF-Seite 38 === 22 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Muslims. They have neither adopted the truth after recognizing it as the truth, nor have they abandoned false doctrines as a result of recognizing those to be false. After placing the reigns of power in the hands of such people, if someone entertains the hope that the caravan will traverse on the path of Islam then the naivety of his perception should be commendable."11

What happened in 1974 and consequently what definition was adopted then was in fact made possible only because the reigns of Islam were given in the hands of the people described above by Maududi Sahib. But one might interpret the above excerpt in a different way and say that Maududi Sahib was only expressing the opinion that if common people alone made any decision by consensus, then it would not carry any weight; and perhaps Maududi Sahib had it in mind that it was the prerogative of the leading ulema of high rank to pass judgement on such important matters, because—on account of their possessing Islamic perception and because of their understanding of Islam—their judgment on such matters has authenticity. Moreover, since ulema of this calibre

11 Musalman aur Maujudah Siyasi Kashmakash [Muslims and the

Contemporary Political Strife], vol. 3, Page 130, Published by, Maktaba Jama‘ati Islami, Darul Islam, Jamalpur, Pathankot (India). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 39 === 23 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam were participants in the decision given in 1974, it [the decision] stands on a different pedestal. Or one might argue that the popular sentiment emanating from the laity alone ought to be rejected—just because the laity is of the kind described above by Maududi Sahib, yet the Representative Assembly elected by the same laity must necessarily possess the right [to decide questions of faith] and that they are above reproach. Instead of giving my own reply to both these points. I give a reply in Maududi Sahib's own words. His reply to the first point is:

'Whether it is the political leaders who have received Western education and training, or it be the ulema of our faith and the mufties* of the Islamic Sharia12, the leaders of both these types—on account of their ideology and their policy—have equally lost their way: both categories have gone astray from the path of truth, and are floundering in a myriad of darkness … neither of these possesses the vision of a Muslim.'13

·

10 of 10 left today