Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 6

30 i.e., unlike a warden—who is charged with the responsibility of safekeeping of valuables and, if something is lost, he is held accountable— you will not be held responsible for it. [Author] 31 The Holy Qur’an 88:22-25. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 51 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 35 FIRST ARGUMENT OF ULEMA

‘Allama Shabbir Ahmad ‘Uthmani has presented the one and only argument in his booklet, Ash-Shihab. He develops his argument in the following manner. He quotes the following part of the verse 55 of Al- Baqarah: which he translates as: "O nation of Bani Isra’il! you wronged your souls by making a calf an object of worship. You should now turn toward God and, then murder your own people." and basing his thesis on this translation of his he tries to substantiate it by arguing thus:

"Although there are many verses of the Holy Qur’an which prescribe death penalty for an apostate there is one incident recorded in the Holy Qur’an with such clear exposition and elucidation—regarding the killing of a group of apostates, under the command from God—that, for those who have fear of God in them, there is no room left, not even a wee bit, for any other interpretation of it.32 The context does not imply any fighting, or cutting off of a passage, or any other offence—with the sole exception of the offence of apostasy, for which 32 As if, the verses of the Holy Qur’an that I have recited here, before you, do

permit (God forbid!) a considerable leeway of interpretation, but the incident noted in this particular verse [‘Allama ‘Uthmani postulates] allows no interpretation. [Author] === PDF-Seite 52 === 36 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam God has commanded that they be unhesitatingly put to sword…"

Just imagine! Maulawi Shabbir Sahib could not find any incident from the lifetime of the Holy Prophetsa, yet he could spot a single incident in the case of the people of Prophet Mosesas, narrated in the Holy Qur’an, which he is uses to lay the foundation for the thesis that an apostate should be killed. He further writes:

"The meaning of [the word] anfusakum in [the phrase] faqtulu anfusakum is the same as it is in [the phrase] thumma antum ha’ula’i taqtuluna anfusakum." "Thus, there is no reason whatsoever to deviate from the literal and real meaning of the word qatl which encompasses all manners of killing, whether with the help of iron or of stone." "As a result of this commandment from God, it is noted in various related-traditions, thousands of people were slain in front of Prophet Mosessa due to the offence of apostasy. The situation got to a point where every single one of those people in the nation, who had not worshipped the calf, killed with his own hand any of his close relatives who had been guilty of worshipping === PDF-Seite 53 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 37 33 the calf." "Let it be clearly understood that these guilty ones, prior to their being punished with death penalty, were also engaged in a sort of repentance. But even this repentance did nothing to save them from meeting the chastisement in this world." "It may be argued that this incident is associated with the Mosaic Law, and it cannot be used in the case of the body of followers of the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa. But you must know that those ordinances and commandments that were applicable to the earlier religious communities—but which have been quoted in the Holy Qur’an—are also tenable for us and we, too, are under command to obey those, unless our own Prophetsa or our Book instructs us to part with it…Thus, under this principle the [mention in the Holy Qur’an about the] commandment to kill the apostates among the Children of Israel is, in fact a teaching for us Muslims."34

33 He has not given any further reason or explanation of this assertion. Later

on, when I will analyze the meaning of this verse, the reader will be astonished to learn how extensively ‘Allama ‘Uthmani has deviated from the meaning of this verse. [Author] 34 Ash-Shihab li Rajmil Khatifil Murtab by Maulawi Shabbir Ahmad

‘Uthmani, pp. 27-34, Published by Adbi Kutub Khana, Hussain Agahi, Multan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 54 === 38 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam MUTILATED FACTS:

The above-noted assertion is totally wrong and baseless, viz., the commandments and ordinances of the ancient Scriptures that are mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, become part of our Sharia—unless it is explicitly forbidden by the Holy Qur’an to act on them. A historical reality has been presented in distorted form. And that historical reality is as follows. Up until the teachings of the Holy Qur’an were completely revealed, and the revelation of the Sharia was not yet completed, it was the practice of the Holy Prophetsa that if there had not yet been revealed any commandment regarding a particular matter, then the Holy Prophetsa used to take guidance (regarding that particular matter) from the earlier scriptures.35 But, in regard to those matters about which a clear injunction from the Holy Qur’an had already been revealed, the Holy Prophetsa never ever—not even once—looked at the precedent in any earlier Scripture in order to make it applicable to the Muslims. Despite the mention of apostates in it, the Holy Qur’an makes absolutely no mention of killing an apostate. A detailed exposition of teachings in regard to apostates is found quite frequently in the Holy Qur’an. But, when the Holy Qur’an has given complete expression to the issue of apostates—and has not mentioned anything about

35 See Muslim, Kitabul Fada’il, Babu Siffati Sha‘rihisa …, Hadith No. 6062.

[Publisher]. === PDF-Seite 55 === 39 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam killing them—then it is an extremely spurious argument to assert that since an incident from the ancient history is mentioned, and it has not been disavowed, we shall take it as precedent and shall make it a part of our Sharia, and that it is incumbent on us to do so. This idea is completely wrong and diametrically opposed to the Sunna. Although it is true that until a commandment on a specific issue was revealed to him, the Holy Prophetsa used to follow the earlier religious scriptures, i.e., Torah. But when an injunction regarding that particular issue was revealed to him then, he would not even consider the possibility of consulting Torah.

FURTHER EXAMINATION OF THE ARGUMENT OF ‘UTHMANI SAHIB

Let us now further examine his argument. Maulana ‘Uthmani Sahib refers to the following verse of the Holy Qur’an:

"And when they were smitten with remorse and saw that they had indeed gone astray, they said, 'If our Lord do not have mercy on us and forgive us, we shall surely be among the === PDF-Seite 56 === 40 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 36 losers.'"

That is, when they lost control over that matter, and they came to a full realization that they had gone astray, and had been guilty of wrongdoing, they exclaimed: If Allah, the Exalted, does not show mercy on us, and does not forgive us—or, had He not shown mercy to us and forgiven us—we would certainly (have) become of those who are the losers. Quoting this portion of the verse, Maulana ‘Uthmani says:

"But even this repentance did not save them from the punishment in this world" [i.e., they were murdered in spite of their repentance.]37

It is as if, according to Maulawi Sahib, this is the definition of the 'losers' [Khasirin].

DETAILS OF THE INCIDENT ACCORDING TO THE HOLY QUR’AN

·

10 of 10 left today