Cover Page
Relationship between Religion and Politics in Islam, Part 2
to all its population, then, by the same reasoning and the same logic, every other country with the majority of its population belonging to other religions would have exactly the same right to enact their laws. The entire world would become a world of not only political conflict but also of a politico-religious conflict, whereby all the laws would be attributed to God, yet they would contradict each other diametrically. There would be such a confusion that people would begin to lose faith in a God who speaks one thing to one people and another thing to another people, and who tells them to enforce this law on the people or ‘they will be untrue to Me’. As such, you can well imagine what would happen in India for instance, if the law of the Hindu majority is imposed on the Muslim minority. As a matter of fact, a large section of the Indian society is gradually being pushed towards this extremist demand by way of reaction—I suppose—to what is happening in some Islamic countries. What would happen to the Muslims and other minorities of India? Moreover, this is not a question of India alone. What if Israel enacts the law of Judaism—the law of the Talmud? I have read it and I know it will be impossible for any other non-Jew to live there normally and decently. In the same manner, Christianity has its own rights and so has Buddhism. === PDF-Seite 17 === The Relationship Between Religion & Politics 7
Participation in Legislation
The next consideration is the very concept of the state. This is the most fundamental issue which has to be resolved and addressed by those who are concerned with politics or international law. The question is that anyone born in a state has a right to participate in its legislation. In the secular concept of the running of governments and legislation, everyone born in a given country—whatever be his religion, colour, or creed—acquires the basic fundamental civic rights. And the most Important among these rights is the chance, at least, to participate in the shaping of legislation. Of course, parties come and go; majority parties today may turn into minority parties tomorrow. Everybody’s wish is not ful- filled or carried out, but, in principle, everybody has a fair chance and an equal chance to make his say heard—at least by the oppo- sition—on matters of common principle. But what would hap- pen if one Shariah or one religion is imposed as the law of that country? If Muslim law were imposed in a country, all the rest of the people, who are inhabitants of the same land, would have to be considered as second, third, or fourth rate citizens of the same country with no say whatsoever in the legislation. But that is not all, the problem is further complicated within Islam itself, because Islam has a Book revealed by God and the Muslim scholars claim that it is their right to interpret the Book. === PDF-Seite 18 === 8 The Relationship Between Religion & Politics
Legislative Body Subordinate to Religious Scholars
On issues of differences of opinion, the legislative body stands subordinate to the scholastic opinion of such scholars who spe- cialise in understanding the Holy Qur’an, or who claim to spe- cialise in understanding the Holy Qur’an. What would be their mutual relationship? A body is elected to legislate. They legislate and you hear from some scholars of Islam that: ‘What you have proposed as a law is against the fundamental principles of Islam. Islam has no room for such nonsense.’ Whose voice should be heard? On the one hand, it would apparently be God speaking behind those people, but only appar- ently. On the other hand, there will be the voice of a majority of people from the country. So the dilemma becomes almost impos- sible to be resolved.
All Religions Split into Sects over Time
But that is not all. Every religion, at the source, is one and single and inseparable, but as you pass along in period of time, the reli- gion begins to diverge and split within and multiply, and become more and more in number, so that the same faith which, for instance, at the time of Jesus Christ as was one single Christianity, turned into many hundreds of Christianity. Looked at from the vantage point of different sects, the one single source appears to be different in colour. Different coloured eyeglasses are used by various followers of different sects. The same is true of Islam. It’s not just a question of Sunni Islam === PDF-Seite 19 === The Relationship Between Religion & Politics 9
and Shia Islam and how they interpret the Shariah. Within Shia Islam there are 34 sects whose interpretation of Shariah differs with each other. Again, within Sunni Islam there are at least 34 sects whose interpretation of Shariah differs with each other. There are issues on which no two ulemah of different sects agree—not just superficial issues—even the fundamental ones. You have only to read the Munir Inquiry [Commission] Report1. Justice Munir, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court [of Pakistan], was one of the two judges appointed to investigate into the background rea- sons and the modus operandi of the anti-Ahmadiyya riots in 1953. Who was responsible and who was not?
How to Define a Muslim?
During the course of the inquiry, Justice Munir pointedly asked every Muslim scholar who appeared before him if he knew of a definition of Islam which could be acceptable by the other sects as well, which could equally apply to everyone and by the help of which we could define, ‘Yes, this is Muslim’, and ‘That is not Muslim’. In the report Justice Munir submits that no two scholars of all the Muslim scholars interrogated, agreed on a single defini- tion of what Islam was. In the case of one particular scholar, he wanted some more time to think over it, and Justice Kayani who was a partner with Justice Munir, had a very peculiar sense of humour. His answer
1. Report of the Court of Inquiry, constituted under Punjab Act II of 1954 to enquire into the Punjab Disturbances of 1953. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 20 === 10 The Relationship Between Religion & Politics
was: ‘I cannot give you more time, because you have already taken more than 1,300 years to ponder over this question. Is that not enough? If thirteen centuries, plus some years are not enough for you to be able to define the very fundamentals of Islam—what is its definition—how much more time would you require?’ So this is a very grave issue. If the Shariah interpretation of one sect is imposed, then it will not just be the non-Muslims who will be dispossessed of the fundamental right of participation in the country’s legislation, but within Islam also there would be many sects who would be deprived of this right.
The Interpretation of which Sect is to be Imposed on Shariah Law?
Again, there are so many other problems. For Instance, according to some, Shariah concept of punishment for a crime is so much different from the concept of another sect, that Islam would be practised in the world so differently on the same issue, that it would create a horrible impression on the non-Muslim world. What sort of faith is that which advises one punishment for the same crime here and another there? And in some other places it is just the very thing to do and it’s no crime at all. These and many such issues make the question of imposi- tion of Shariah almost impossible. Moreover, the fundamental rights of other sects are also tampered with, or trampled upon, in many possible situations. For instance, on the question of drink- ing of alcohol; alcohol is forbidden in Islam, alright, but the very === PDF-Seite 21 === The Relationship Between Religion & Politics 11
question of whether it is a punishable offence and whether the punishment, if any, is imposed by man in this world, is a fluid issue. It is a controversial issue and has not yet been agreed upon by all the people involved. What is the punishment for drinking? The Holy Qur’an does not mention any punishment. This is a funda- mental law, the Book of law, and it is inferred from some tradition by some scholars that ‘such and such’ should be the punishment. But that inference is far-fetched and the traditions themselves are challenged by others not to be authentic. So, will a large section of not only Muslim society, but also a large section of non-Muslim society, be punished for such rea- sons as in themselves are doubtful? Whether it is valid or not, this is the issue. Yet there are extremists everywhere and particularly those who go for Shariah to be imposed. You will find many extremists who are totally intolerant of other people’s opinion. Consequently, such grey areas will also be taken as no doubt areas by the extremists. They will say: ‘Yes, we know; it’s our opinion. It’s the opinion supported by a medieval scholar of our thinking. And that is law.’
Difficulties Faced by the Pakistani Government for the Enactment of Shariah Law
Now this difference resulted in a debate in Pakistan very recently and Nawaz Sharif, the Prime Minister, had ultimately to decide that Shariah of no one sect will be adopted. The law passed in Pakistan is that they will accept the suprem- acy of the Holy Qur’an, and they will agree that no legislation will be === PDF-Seite 22 === 12 The Relationship Between Religion & Politics
made contrary to the fundamental teaching in the Holy Qur’an. But beyond that they will not adopt any rules and regulations which spring from laws as if they were legislative instructions from God. So, leaving that alone, what is left of Shariah is the general principle as enunciated in the Holy Qur’an, in the light of which an attempt would be made to Islamicise the country’s laws. So far so good. I think the Prime Minister has been able to extricate himself from a very difficult situation, but not for long. The ulema are already at his throat. Also, they are insisting that a Shariah Court should not only be continued—there is already a Shariah Court—to work, but its power should be enhanced. The final authority about whether the law is according to Islam or not should lodge with the Shariah Supreme Court. As such, again, the power balance will be shifted from the elected members of the country to the extremist mullahs. So, once you accept something which is impractical to be imposed, then this will always lead to various troubles and it is impossible for you to carry on without further complications.
The Lifestyle of Today’s Muslims is not Truly Islamic
That is one area of difficulties. But there is another very impor- tant area of difficulty; that is, the lifestyle of the Muslims in most countries is not truly and profoundly Muslim. You see, you do not require a law of Shariah to say your prayers five times. You do not require the law of Shariah to make you behave honestly. You do not require the law of Shariah to be imposed to make you === PDF-Seite 23 === The Relationship Between Religion & Politics 13